The debate over the greatest player of all time is one that has divided fans, players, and pundits for years. Two names have dominated the discussion—Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo—each boasting an extraordinary career filled with goals, trophies, and individual accolades.
For many, Argentina’s World Cup triumph in 2022 was seen as the ultimate decider in Messi’s favor, a crowning achievement that separated him from his long-time rival.
However, not everyone agrees. One legendary figure in the sport, a World Cup winner and Milan’s last Ballon d’Or recipient, recently shared his perspective, dismissing the idea that winning soccer’s most prestigious tournament is the ultimate measure of greatness. His take has reignited the endless GOAT debate, adding yet another dimension to the conversation.
Kaka’s take on the GOAT debate
Kaka, the 2007 Ballon d’Or winner and a key figure in Milan’s historic triumphs, has made it clear where he stands in the debate between Messi and Ronaldo. Despite acknowledging Messi’s genius, he firmly believes that the Portuguese is the most complete player in soccer history.
In an interview shared by GiveMeSport, the former midfield maestro explained why he does not see the World Cup as a decisive factor in the GOAT conversation. “Winning a World Cup doesn’t change anything. I won it all, and I’m not the best in history. Messi is a genius, but the best and most complete player in history is Cristiano Ronaldo.”
His words immediately sparked discussion among fans, particularly those who believe the Argentine’s World Cup victory cemented his legacy. But Kaka’s argument suggests that soccer greatness is about more than just one tournament—it’s about the full body of work, consistency, and impact across multiple competitions.
Unique perspective from soccer legend
Kaka is uniquely qualified to weigh in on this debate. As a player, he reached the pinnacle of soccer, winning the 2002 World Cup with Brazil, the UEFA Champions League with the Rossoneri in 2007, and the Ballon d’Or the same year—becoming the last player to win the award before Messi and Ronaldo’s dominance began.
His career also intertwined with Ronaldo’s at Real Madrid. Both players joined the Spanish giants in 2009, though the Brazilian’s spell in Madrid was hindered by injuries. He eventually returned to San Siro in 2013, but his firsthand experience playing alongside CR7 clearly left a lasting impression.
