English Premier League Would be Better if 'Smaller' Teams Could Win Titles

Robert Hay
English Premier League Would be Better if 'Smaller' Teams Could Win Titles
English Premier League Would be Better if 'Smaller' Teams Could Win Titles
premier-league-trophy

Admittedly I am a newer soccer fan. The 2006 World Cup helped me truly fall in love with the beautiful game to the point where I began to actively follow it online and on TV. Since that World Cup, I have become a fanatic, following multiple teams on multiple continents while writing for this site, starting a manuscript, and spending way more than I should on memorabilia. The modern game is a great product for a busy sports fan like myself – matches last two hours, there is a definite flow, the game comes across beautifully on HD, and the personalities are not hidden behind equipment or masks. This is why soccer is now taking off like pundits have predicted it would for years – it is a sport for this era of fandom.

As a fan, I also vociferously read many different books on the sport, which is one of the reasons I have reviews on this site. Recently I have had the pleasure of reading David Goldblatt’s new book and am slogging through the excellent Red or Dead. These books – and others I’ve read – describe a sport I’ve never known. In this sport, the fans stand through the game, clubs generally have the same spending level, and rarely do they blow wads of cash to catch up with the oligarchs only to fall into administration. Not everything was awesome of course; I am happy there aren’t the organized racist chants and unsafe stadiums. However, there is something interesting about this earlier era of soccer that makes me wish we could be living through it again.

As an example, I am an Arsenal fan. If the Gunners continue their current pace, they will finish out of the top four for the first time in forever. In Red or Dead, when Liverpool finished 7th in 1965 the year after winning the league, they rebounded to again win the league the following year. If Arsenal finish 7th this year, the mountain to climb the win the league the following year would be nearly insurmountable, as they would lose out on European revenue which is almost required to win the Premier League nowadays. It’s even worse for non-big seven teams – can you ever imagine Blackburn winning another title unless they are bought by a billionaire with unlimited access to funds?

I want the Premier League to be more democratic, where more teams have access to titles and finishing in the top four every year is needed to compete for a title the next year. However, I throw this question out to soccer fans that have been following this game longer than I – should we new fans be yearning for soccer as it as, say, before the Premier League era? If you are a newer fan like me, do you agree with me that the “good ol’ days” sound good?

200+ Channels & Local Sports
200+ Channels & Local Sports
  • Price: Plans starting at $14.99/mo (Latino)
  • Watch Ligue 1, Copa Libertadores & World Cup Qualifiers
Every MLS Match in One Place
Every MLS Match in One Place
  • Price: $12.99/mo (Now included with standard subscription)
  • Watch every MLS regular season game, Playoffs & Leagues Cup
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
  • Price: $11.99/mo (or ESPN Unlimited for $29.99/mo)
  • Features LaLiga, Bundesliga, FA Cup & NWSL
2,000+ Soccer Games Per Year
2,000+ Soccer Games Per Year
  • Price: Starting at $8.99/mo
  • Features Champions League, Serie A & Europa League
Home of the Premier League
Home of the Premier League
  • Price: Starting at $10.99/mo
  • 175+ Exclusive EPL matches per season
EDITORS’ PICKS
When does the Premier League season start again?

When does the Premier League season start again?

Anticipation is building for the Premier League's resurgence. But before that, some of the league's biggest names will play their friendlies in the United States. July will see Arsenal take on Manchester United and Liverpool in Philadelphia and Los Angeles. At the same time, Chelsea's schedule includes a friendly against Real Madrid and Wrexham and […]

World Soccer Talk’s Premier League team of 2023/24

World Soccer Talk’s Premier League team of 2023/24

Selecting a Premier League team of the season for the 2023/24 campaign is not an easy task. Several players can certainly make their case to be among the best in their respective positions. However, the list was eventually whittled down to make a dream starting XI. Arsenal and Manchester City, unsurprisingly, have multiple players in […]

Pochettino ready for Chelsea exit: 'It's not a problem'

Pochettino ready for Chelsea exit: 'It's not a problem'

Mauricio Pochettino claimed it would "not be the end of the world" if he left Chelsea this summer. The Blues boss has been in the hot seat for much of the season as the club struggles. Despite spending over $1 billion on new players since 2022, Chelsea has failed to even get close to a […]

Can a spending cap make the Premier League less boring?

Can a spending cap make the Premier League less boring?

On Monday, Premier League clubs agreed in principle to introduce a spending cap ahead of the 2025/26 season to replace current profitability and sustainability rules. Also known as anchoring, this policy ensures clubs can only spend specific amounts on transfers, wages, and agents' fees. The hypothetical rule would mean clubs can only spend the equivalent […]

World Soccer Talk © 2025. Made in Florida.

World Soccer Talk, like Futbol Sites, is a company owned by Better Collective. All rights reserved. World Soccer Talk is reader-supported and may earn a commission through our partner links.

Better Collective Logo