With just one year to go until the 2026 World Cup on home soil, pressure is mounting on Mauricio Pochettino and the U.S. Men’s National Team (USMNT). A disappointing performance in the CONCACAF Nations League earlier this year — capped by a semi-final loss to Panama — has intensified scrutiny. As the CONCACAF Gold Cup looms and after the two friendly losses to Turkey and Switzerland, Pochettino faces a pivotal moment early in his tenure. But he will have to navigate it without his biggest star: Christian Pulisic.
The absence of the Milan forward, who was given permission to rest after a long European season, sparked considerable debate. His omission, along with several other Europe-based regulars — Antonee Robinson, Weston McKennie, Gio Reyna, Yunus Musah, Folarin Balogun, and Tim Weah — has left the squad looking experimental ahead of the summer’s only competitive run.
Still, Pochettino remains bullish on the long-term project — and particularly on the man he believes should be central to it.
The Messi comparison that raised eyebrows
Ahead of the Gold Cup, Pochettino appeared on the Unfiltered Soccer podcast with USMNT icons Tim Howard and Landon Donovan, where he made a bold statement. Though he was careful to clarify he meant no disrespect, the Argentine manager likened Pulisic to Lionel Messi — not in terms of talent, but in national significance.
“You say people compare Messi with Christian Pulisic. I don’t want to be disrespectful to Messi or Pulisic, but I think in this country, Pulisic should be our Messi, because he’s an iconic player. The kids on the street — for sure, if you ask one soccer player in this country — it’s Pulisic,” Pochettino said.
The statement sent ripples through American soccer circles. The former PSG boss, who coached Messi in Paris, highlighted how Pulisic carries more than just on-field responsibility — he is a symbol for a growing sport in a country preparing to host the world’s biggest tournament. But not everyone agreed with the timing — or the narrative.
Pulisic responds — Quietly but firmly
Just days after Pochettino’s comments aired, Pulisic gave his own take in a quieter, more subdued tone during an interview with Lega Serie A, where he was asked about being considered an idol to American fans. The 25-year-old forward, who scored 17 goals in 50 appearances for Milan this season, responded with a hint of humility — and a subtle rebuttal.
“I just try to always do my best. I try to represent my country. I don’t feel too much pressure from the Americans; I don’t feel like I have to be that much of a symbol,” the 26-year-old said. “I just always give my best, I think that will be enough for the people. And hopefully I can inspire some kids at home watching.”
While not directly addressing Pochettino’s comments, Pulisic’s words come off as a gentle pushback — a reminder that his approach is grounded more in performance than symbolism.
