It’s Time to Give Racial Witch-Hunts the Red Card in English Football

Mark Clattenburg will referee Chelsea against Swansea this Sunday.

Despite Clattenburg’s magnanimous efforts to put the recent racial accusations against him to bed, we can learn some lessons, lest another hapless victim falls foul to indiscriminate accusations of racism.

Liverpool’s Luis Suarez and Chelsea’s John Terry are two high-profile players who’ve been punished for racial abuse. I hope their punishments are deterrents, but I also believe those who feign victimization, perhaps motivated by vengeance, should be deterred.

We all hope racism is expunged from soccer. The Premier League is one of the most popular sports leagues in the world, and its cosmopolitan nature is the source of much appeal. Nevertheless, just as we ridicule the player for waving an imaginary yellow card after being fouled, we should be equally cynical of players, and their employers, who exploit the current sensitivity towards racism by hurling accusations in bad faith.

Clattenburg’s appointment for Sunday’s game conjures memories of Chelsea and Ramires.

Last October, Ramires injected himself into an incident between Clattenburg and an overwrought John Obi-Mikel.

Hosting Manchester United, Stamford Bridge was a bit louder than normal that day. Clattenburg, having already issued a yellow-card to Mikel for his remonstrations, kept his cool in the controversial incident. As the ill-disciplined Mikel continued to back-chat, Clattenburg put his finger to lips in a gesture of silence. Mikel continued his tantrums; nevertheless, Clattenburg remained poised, a picture of restraint, as he ordered Mikel to go away.

Mikel didn’t hear anything untoward in that order, but his team-mate Ramires, even further away, somehow contrived to hear a racial taunt amidst the cauldron of bellowing fans. When interviewed about his allegations Ramires explained his reaction as “instinctive.” That’s pretty damning towards his integrity, considering instinctual conclusions often unravel in the cold light of day.

Given the egregious harm to Clattenburg’s personal and professional life, I describe Ramires reaction as reckless as one of Mikel’s miss-timed tackles, as misguided as one of his passes. Remember, Ramires was also “instinctively” seething over perceived injustice by the referee that day.

If the F.A. wants to red-card racism in football, they must encourage reporting of legitimate abuses, and they must discern between good and bad faith complaints. They must also discourage “instinctive” accusations from solitary players with an axe to grind. Flimsy allegations from a disconsolate player who speaks broken English, yet can decipher the heavy Geordie accent of a referee amidst the bedlam of Stamford Bridge, warrant suspicion.

The forgiving and classy Clattenburg has said: “The on-pitch relationship between match officials, players and managers is the best we’ve ever known it.” For that to continue, improvable allegations of racism must be squelched so that the FA can truly “Kick it out.”

Let’s see: Terry got banned for 4 matches for racially abusing Anton Ferdinand; Suarez was suspended for 8 matches for doing the same to Patrice Evra. What should a footballer get for unsubstantiated claims that do even more harm to anti-discrimination efforts?

Let’s split the difference – a 6 match ban as the benchmark for eliciting a racially induced wild-goose chase. That ought to send the message loud and clear: we don’t tolerate frivolous accusations that ultimately undermine the laudable goals of bodies like “Show Racism the Red Card.”

2 thoughts on “It’s Time to Give Racial Witch-Hunts the Red Card in English Football”

  1. While the article is good in its intentions it doesn’t mention the reality that racism isn’t a football problem it’s a social problem. The FA can’t kick racism out on its own…it can help…but racism is a social problem that will not go away without recognition of that fact..

    Because football is woven so deeply in the fabric of many society’s (europe, south america, asia, africa) it could be mistaken for be responsible…but that would be a mistake.

    Education over generations is what is needed, by schools, parents, religions (the biggest transgressors of non pluralism in human history). it is a slow battle, more akin to moving mountains, but with the right focus.

    Football can be a tool in this quest to remove racism from people’s hearts and for sure the FA’s mishandling of punishments and cowardice in dealing with alleged tough issues/situations does not help.

    But the instance you quote involving Clattenburg and his incorrect accusal of making racist remarks make it seem as tho its all to common an occurrence, and while any incorrect accusal is 1 too many, there are far far far more actual racist incidents in football (and even more in society) that are not addressed at all.

    This feels more like an article that isn’t so much a cautionary piece about defamation and the wrong use of racial incidents being charged against people but one written out of frustration and belief that the frequency and presence of racism is somehow exaggerated…

    I could be wrong but that’s the sense I get from reading the article.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *