It's Time for FIFA to Put an End to Cheating and Diving In Soccer

SOCCER/FUTBOL WORLD CUP 2010 ITALIA VS NUEVA ZELANDA Action photo of Daniele de Rossi (C) of Italy and Chris Killen (L) of New Zealand, during World Cup 2010 game held at the Mbombela stadium, South Africa./Foto de accion de Dienele de Rossi (C) de Italia y de Chris Killen (I) de Nueva Zelanda, durante juego de la Copa del Mundo 2010 celebrado en el estadio Mbombela, Sudafrica. 20 June 2010 MEXSPORT/OSVALDO AGUILAR Photo via Newscom

I appeared on a CBC TV news program in Canada Monday night and was asked to defend the theatrics of soccer. The diving and the cheating that are so woven into the fabric of soccer and are most evident to the public when the World Cup takes center stage every four years. To be fair, the diving and cheating is indefensible other than the fact that this is what countries often do to gain a edge in soccer. And oftentimes a slight edge is all it takes to win a game.

In the past few days, I’ve spoken to many North Americans who have enjoyed the World Cup but would be much more interested in the sport if the cheating and diving could be eradicated from the game. And they’re absolutely correct. The diving that we’ve seen by footballers has been disgusting such as Italy’s Daniele De Rossi (to win the penalty against New Zealand), Portugal’s Cristiano Ronaldo (to win free kicks in dangerous places on the pitch against Ivory Coast), Chile’s Jorge Valdivia (who received a yellow card Monday for diving to try to win a penalty), Ivory Coast’s Fadel Keita (who charged at Kaka on purpose to draw a foul, which ended up being a second yellow for Kaka and he was sent off), etc.

Several people I speak to say that they would love the sport if only the diving and cheating could be eliminated. They blame the referees for not seeing the fouls. They blame the players for faking and cheating. I blame FIFA for not being strong enough. Here’s why:

The referees are at a disadvantage. We get to see every controversial incident on replay as well as from different camera angles (including overhead cameras at times). Plus, we see the incident in slow-motion and we can watch it over and over again in a couple of minutes while the referee and his assistant referees are handicapped by only seeing it once without the aid of TV replays. When we as the TV viewer have so much more evidence at our fingertips, how can we expect the referee to make a fair and accurate result unless he sees the same things we see? Simply put, FIFA needs to introduce video technology to the modern sport of soccer.

FIFA has so far not introduced the chip technology in the ball and the addition of two assistant referees behind goals to help referees in World Cup matches. They’ve also resisted introducing video technology. The reason they are so archaic when it comes to the question of introducing technology is because they’re fearful of losing control and power. Once the decisions are made by people with video monitors, the balance of power and authority has shifted from the referees to a man in a TV studio or press box. Getting a decision correct with the aid of video technology should be the way FIFA is heading, but it undermines their authority and it undermines the authority of the referee.

FIFA wants to maintain as much control as possible. The best example of this was the controversial incident involving referee Koman Coulibaly who disallowed USA’s third goal against Slovenia. After the incident happened, no one knew what the call was. Was it offside, or was it pushing? As is FIFA’s policy, the referee didn’t conduct a post-match interview to explain his decision. And there was no word from FIFA regarding what really happened. This was on Friday. Over the weekend when the video highlights were added to the website, all evidence of the controversial incident was not included in the video highlights section. All we knew that FIFA was going to make a statement on Monday. So, for 3-4 agonizing days, FIFA said nothing until now when they announced that Koman Coulibaly would not be refereeing any more matches in the World Cup. And what did the head of referees think of their performance so far? “We are very, very satisfied with the performance of the referees,” Jose-Marcia Garcia-Aranda, head of refereeing for FIFA, said Monday.

FIFA is walking a tightrope. I’m convinced that between now and the final a very controversial incident will happen again and a referee will make an incorrect decision which will lead to a country being knocked out of the tournament and injustice being served. This is the sort of thing that turns fans off soccer. It can be corrected, but FIFA is too stubborn and too protective of the power they maintain to let anything go. Unfortunately it’s going to take a controversial incident that will get people incensed to encourage FIFA to change. And even then, FIFA will only change on their own time and when they feel like it.

Bottom line, FIFA needs to be more transparent and needs to be seen as doing everything they can to make the game fair. They also need to stamp out cheating and allow referees to come down hard on players who conduct that behavior. For the sake of soccer, let’s hope FIFA does something after this World Cup to improve the game.


  1. Simon Burke June 22, 2010
  2. brn442 June 22, 2010
    • Andrei June 22, 2010
      • Dave June 25, 2014
  3. Raatzie June 22, 2010
    • Taf June 27, 2010
      • Timo Pitkäranta May 12, 2012
  4. brn442 June 22, 2010
  5. Ed June 22, 2010
    • MarylandBill June 22, 2010
      • Pakapala June 22, 2010
        • jk June 22, 2010
          • Pakapala June 22, 2010
          • Enormo June 25, 2010
        • MarylandBill June 22, 2010
          • Pakapala June 23, 2010
      • Timo Pitkäranta May 12, 2012
    • McBride June 22, 2010
      • Pakapala June 23, 2010
  6. canyid June 22, 2010
    • ovalball June 22, 2010
    • jk June 22, 2010
  7. Randall June 22, 2010
  8. MarylandBill June 22, 2010
    • jk June 22, 2010
  9. Robert June 22, 2010
  10. Gedo June 22, 2010
    • ovalball June 22, 2010
    • Matt T. June 22, 2010
    • MarylandBill June 22, 2010
      • McBride June 22, 2010
  11. Jeremy U June 22, 2010
  12. Ismo June 22, 2010
    • MarylandBill June 22, 2010
      • Ismo June 22, 2010
        • MarylandBill June 22, 2010
  13. Phil Sandifer June 22, 2010
  14. Brickthrower June 22, 2010
  15. Mike in Idaho June 22, 2010
  16. Pakapala June 22, 2010
  17. David June 22, 2010
  18. Doctor L June 22, 2010
    • McBride June 22, 2010
  19. blade45 June 22, 2010
    • MarylandBill June 23, 2010
  20. Sandy B June 23, 2010
  21. Lawrence June 23, 2010
  22. CanadianChris June 25, 2010
  23. Tim Naylor June 26, 2010
  24. Brian June 27, 2010
  25. Greg July 7, 2010
  26. BobR January 22, 2012
  27. Dave G April 15, 2012

Leave a Reply