It’s easy to feel a measure of sympathy for Jack Harper, the Spanish-born Scotland footballer currently on the books at Real Madrid. Through no fault of his own, the 19-year has set off a debate in Scottish soccer that has seen the likes of Craig Brown, Ian Cathro, Kevin Gallacher and Graham Hunter all weigh in with their opinions.
So what’s been the cause of this very Scottish controversy? Scotland Under-19 coach Ricky Sbragia opted to leave Jack Harper out from his squad. A surprise decision perhaps but one that Sbragia has every right to do as he is the coach. However it was his justification for Harper’s omission that has prompted the outcry and led to a larger discussion about the direction of the game in Scotland.
Before we delve in to the intricacies of this debate, it’s important to know what Sbragia said. Building up to the matches against Austria, Italy and Croatia, Sbragia explained:
“Our concentration is on the opening game with Austria (which Scotland won 2:1) and we’ve deliberately got more height in our squad. That’s one of the reasons why Jack isn’t in.
“Unfortunately, I don’t see enough of him in action. The last time he was with us, he did OK, but I wanted a little more impact. At Real Madrid he can float all over the place, which he does. But with us, he has to be more disciplined.
“He’s an exceptionally gifted lad, but sometimes we can’t carry him. He can be a luxury sometimes. In some cases, if it’s going well, he can be a good luxury.
“Listen, Jack’s time will come. The last time I spoke to him, he wanted to really settle in at Real Madrid and find a place there. That’s been a big thing for him. I’ve gone with the boys I’ve seen most in the last six months. We keep tabs on Jack and see video clips of him. We have people over there who keep their eye on him.
“There are others I’ve left out like Dominic Thomas at Motherwell who will have gripes that they’re not in the squad. But I’ve picked a group of 18 which will hopefully do well for us. It’s my opinion and I’m not saying it’s right. But the squad I’ve picked is an extremely strong one.
“I can only pick 18 when I really could have picked 26 or 27. I’ve gone for a physical side and runners. Hopefully I’m right. It’s purely tactical and there certainly hasn’t been a lack of enthusiasm from Jack about playing for Scotland.”
There are quite a few things to unpack in that statement.
First, Sbragia hasn’t banished Jack Harper into the international wilderness. It is entirely feasible that if Harper progresses into the Real Madrid first team squad (easier said than done), he will in all likelihood become a full Scottish international on the proviso he’s not capped by Spain first.
Second, he mentioned height which is a rather more confusing justification. Harper stands at 6ft 1in so he’s not exactly on the short side — sleight perhaps but not small. Was Sbragia more concerned about the Real Madrid player’s heading ability? Former Scottish international Kevin Gallacher was dubious citing his own playing career:
“I don’t believe in it. I stood at 5ft 8ins and under 11 stone when I played my best. It’s about the talent, how you can play for that team and if you fit into it. For me, that’s a football player.”
Third, Sbragia admitted that he didn’t see Harper enough. Now that is an interesting statement to say the least though he did qualify that by stating that there are people there observing Harper’s progress. Spanish football expert Graham Hunter (who happens to be a Scot) was scathing in his assessment when the Scotland U-19 coach made that admission. Hunter reasonably claimed:
“This coach isn’t in a full-time club job, and one of the complaints of all who coach at international level is the lack of day-to-day contact with players.
“What they DO have is time. Time to study, time to follow players’ development. If Ricky hasn’t seen a lot of Jack … then WHY not?
“Games in the Madrid youth system are easy to follow, there’s no reason not to have taken in five or six of them in person or via a scout”.
Another point worth raising is that if Sbragia didn’t see Harper enough, then how can he label the youngster a ‘luxury’ player? Surely to form that kind of conclusion the coaching and scouting team at the very least should have seen him play enough times at Real Madrid and in close quarters to make that decision. Again Hunter shot down Sbragia’s assessment and conduct:
“Quality is never a luxury. High technique is never a luxury. If the coach has an issue with Jack’s work rate he should a] tell him in private b] help alter that.
“Personally, having seen how Jack plays, understanding his will to play for Scotland, and having suffered too long without Scotland having sufficient high quality players in our playing pool I think this is a retrograde step, almost impossible to understand and extremely disappointing”.
Is the footballing public being seduced by the name Real Madrid? It’s not every day that a Scottish talent is progressing at one of the leading clubs in world soccer but then again there’s no guarantee that Harper will fulfill his potential. Former Scotland boss Craig Brown opined:
“The name Real Madrid hypnotizes people. They have hundreds of development players; you can’t simply say because he plays for Real Madrid he’s got to play for Scotland.”
That said Graham Hunter made the point that the Real Madrid youth system is not a place for those short of the highest quality:
“They cull every year if you’re not good enough, if you’re not athletic enough, if you’re not intelligent enough, if you’re not professional enough – you’re out”.
Finally, Sbragia said that the choice to omit Harper was a purely tactical one. This is a tough statement to consider too. Is the focus purely results driven hence the decision to take a more physical approach? Is Harper incompatible with the other players in the Scotland Under-19 squad? Is this the footballing identity that Scotland wants to pursue? The under-19 coach explained:
“It would be great to have eleven technical players, but that doesn’t happen now. The more games I see, the more it is becoming physical and the height factor. It has gone back to that now.
“They say ‘let’s play from the back’. There are not many teams that play from the back now, maybe the top four or five. They launch it and play off the second ball.
“Set-plays are a big part of it now. We lost a set-play against Finland and one against Norway. At that time, we were on the edge of maybe being too small and it was a concern.
“I looked at what I saw in Austria, Italy and Croatia – and they are big, physical teams – so that is the idea behind the squad I have got now.
“If it had been different depending on the draw, it might have been a different squad.”
Sbragia’s observation about the game becoming more direct could be interpreted in a couple of ways. Is he simply being pragmatic to the changing nature of soccer? Is he being reactive rather than trying to forge his own path? To be fair, the game has been favoring teams that are quickest to transition from attack to defense and vice-versa though his description of sides launching and playing off the second ball does suggest that he’s looking to go direct.
However judging from his quotes, Sbragia has clearly decided to take a pragmatic approach rather than an ideological one. As he admitted if the draw was different his squad make-up may have been too. That again throws up the question of results versus player development and what’s valued more.
Will that style of game suit the likes of Harper, who has been described as an intelligent, technical player? Can the team adapt to Harper’s interpretation of the game? Is the focus on the team stifling the development of individual skill? Former Scottish FA Performance Director Mark Wotte, who labeled Harper as Scotland’s answer to Robin van Persie, has railed against emphasis on results rather than the development of players. In an interview with Inside Futbol, Wotte claimed:
“I’m not sure if academy managers in Scotland have picked up what is essentially the most important aspect for current football youngsters: to be recognized as individuals with their own potential and DNA, to be treated as football pupils/students, to be educated as world-class footballers and prospects for their clubs and to become part of a better future within the first team or somewhere higher up with a decent return on investment”.
He went on to elaborate his fear that Scottish football would stagnate or even go backwards when it comes to developing talented players.
100+ Channels With Sports & News
- Starting price: $29.99/mo. for fubo Español Package
- Watch Premier League, LaLiga, Liga MX & MLS
- Includes NBC, NBCSN, ESPN, FS1, FS2, TUDN, beIN SPORTS and more
Favorite Leagues At The Best Price
- Starting price: $7.99/mo. for Live TV Package
- Watch LaLiga, Primeira Liga and Copa Libertadores
- Includes beIN SPORTS, GolTV, TyC Sports and more
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
- Price: $5.99/mo. (or get ESPN+, Hulu & Disney+ for $12.99/mo.)
- Features Serie A, Bundesliga, FA Cup, EFL & more
- Also includes daily ESPN FC news & highlights show
Live TV, Soccer & Originals
- Starting price: $5.99/mo.
- Features Champions League, Europa League & NWSL
- Includes CBS, Star Trek & CBS Sports HQ