Connect with us


Arsenal 1-2 Birmingham City: Carling Cup Final Review

This odd season of English football continued today, as Birmingham City persisted and stole the Carling Cup from a more ambitious-yet snakebitten- Arsenal side, 2-1 at Wembley Stadium.

Starting Formations

Arsene Wenger lost Theo Walcott and Cesc Fabregas in their midweek match against Stoke City, so the 4-2-3-1 formation contained Andrei Arshavin and Tomas Rosicky instead. Since Wenger prefers Arshavin’s contribution from the left, Samir Nasri set up in the right wing, while Rosicky took the central attacking midfielder position.

Alex McLeish fielded a rather narrow five in the midfield and Nicola Zigic as the center forward, a sign that he was willing to clog the pitch and stifle the Gunners’ passing attack.

As one would expect, Arsenal was the more attack-focused team, but they had their struggles against Brum’s tight marking. Whether it was a part of McLeish’s tactic or his own nature, Lee Bowyer very often pressed off the 5 man midfield, primarily at Alex Song and Johan Djourou. This often disrupted the flow from the holding positions. Arsenal did have some success, but it came after Brum’s midfield joined an attack. Upon regaining possession, once Rosicky or Jack Wilshere received the ball behind the pinching Bowyer and Gardner, space opened up and it allowed them to counterattack well. Early on, the saving grace for Brum was their center backfield, with Martin Jiranek and Roger Johnson adeptly thwarting a number of promising attacks.

With a team the size and strength of Birmingham, especially with Zigic as the nine, the direct attack is always an option. The first goal was the culmination of Bowyer’s pressure and Zigic’s presence in the 29th minute. As Arsenal tried to build an attack from the back, the high pressure caused a miscommunication between Sagna and Wilshere. The ball was possessed by Brum. The resulting buildup led to a conceded corner off an aerial in the 6 yard box intended for Zigic. The corner from Larsson was directed towards goal by Johnson and rerouted into the net by Zigic.

This seemed to shock Arsenal to an extent. Brum took the play for the next 5-10 minutes. What seemed to get Arsenal back in the game was the beginnings of stall tactics from the Blues. Bowyer took his second or third writhing knock since the goal, and you could feel the anger from Wenger and the Gunners, even from across the Atlantic. Arsenal was able to start a counterattack off of the following free kick. After Wilshere stung the crossbar with a shot, Arshavin eventually gathered the ball. He darted around Liam Ridgewell, and centered a pass for Robin van Persie. The Dutch international volleyed the ball past Ben Foster to equalize.

The Gunners had an interesting remedy for the lack of Fabregas. It was thought that Abou Diaby might have been asked to fill this role. Instead, Rosicky was plied there in this match, and it appeared that this was mainly to mark Barry Ferguson. Upon gaining possession, especially in the second half, Rosicky and Nasri nearly swapped positions. This seemed to help the flow of attack in the second half, where Arsenal dominated both possession and attempts on goal. In fact, it’s difficult to pinpoint tactically where Arsenal went wrong in this match. On paper, they should have won. But in each instance, one thing or another went wrong for the Gunners. Chances by 70th minute sub Nicklas Bendtner and Samir Nasri were matched by Foster saves. Other chances lacked the finishing touch to give Arsenal that precious second goal. In many cases, it was clear that Arsenal missed Fabregas, and Rosicky was not the answer.

After Martins Substitution

But the lightning strike came innocuously from a formation switch by Birmingham. Recent acquired on loan from Rubin Kazan, striker Obafemi Martins entered the match for Keith Fahey. Whether this was to help a tired Zigic, or to make a late push to win, it worked in a serendipitous fashion for McLeish. A Foster free kick in the 89th minute found Zigic at the edge of the area, but the ball bounded in a harmless fashion towards Szezesny. The following seconds were a combination of surreal and unjust. Szczesny and Laurent Koscielny both tried to make plays on the ball. The center back distracted the keeper, and Szczesny fumbled it right into Martins’ path. Without the second striker, there would have been no pressure on the Gunners to gain quick control of the situation. As it was, Martins easily scored the deciding goal, and fortuitously became a newfound hero in this season of disappointments for Brum.

It was an all-too-common feeling for Gooners alike. For the poise that the young Polish goalkeeper has shown in his first season of first-team action, it all came unraveled in the blink of an eye, much like it has time and again in different facets of the game. Much has been made in the last few years of the need for a solidified goalkeeper, and I still think Szczesny has shown much promise. One can hope that Szczesny puts this fluke incident behind him and continues his development.

For Birmingham City, this is not only a title, but also a ticket into the Europa League. It’s an accomplishment for the embattled McLeish, who has taken many knocks for a negative style of football. It could be an interesting twist should Aston Villa continue to ascend into the seventh spot. Brum is far from relegation safety, and many could end up wishing that the other Second City team had gotten the chance, especially with the additions they’ve made.

200+ Channels With Sports & News
  • Starting price: $33/mo. for fubo Latino Package
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup, Euro 2024 & more
  • Includes NBC, USA, FOX, ESPN, CBSSN & more
Live & On Demand TV Streaming
  • Price: $69.99/mo. for Entertainment package
  • Watch World Cup, Euro 2024 & MLS
  • Includes ESPN, ESPN2, FS1 + local channels
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
  • Price: $6.99/mo. (or get ESPN+, Hulu & Disney+ for $13.99/mo.)
  • Features Bundesliga, LaLiga, Championship, & more
  • Also includes daily ESPN FC news & highlights show
2,000+ soccer games per year
  • Price: $4.99/mo
  • Features Champions League, Serie A, Europa League & NWSL
  • Includes CBS, Star Trek & CBS Sports HQ
175 Premier League Games & PL TV
  • Starting price: $4.99/mo. for Peacock Premium
  • Watch 175 exclusive EPL games per season
  • Includes Premier League TV channel plus movies, TV shows & more


  1. Hhahahahahhah

    March 1, 2011 at 10:39 am

    Arsenal you suck
    Get rid of Wenger the whiner NOW

  2. Matt

    February 28, 2011 at 11:32 am

    The Fiver had it right – …”enjoy the fact that a team that wanted to win for the joy of winning, rather than win as a stepping stone on the way to winning something else, lifted the trophy.”

  3. Robert Hay

    February 28, 2011 at 8:24 am

    Great post on the match. I am glad you brought up the Diaby point – I was wondering why he wasn’t on the pitch for the match and was scratching my brain for any injuries or red cards he may have. Rosicky is increasingly seeming not to be the answer.

    As for Szczesny, he’s 19. He’s extremely talented, and he is a gambler. Mistakes will be made. Doesn’t excuse the second goal, and doesn’t make Arsenal fans feel any better, but keep with him. He’ll be fine.

  4. chi

    February 28, 2011 at 1:30 am

    Arsenal is their own worse enemy.Wenger will continue to suffer for his stubborness.He has refused to buy tested/expereinced defenders and a matured goalkeeper.He has started making history for the wrong reasons.As an arsenal fan i have had to watch over and over again how the team has stupidly thrown away opportunities to put smiles on the faces of their teeming fans all over the it a curse or whatever the team/management needs overhauling and i think i should begin with Weneger’s resignation.

  5. Phenoum

    February 28, 2011 at 12:07 am

    wow – so the substitution is what changed the game

    f me if that had anything at all to do with it. Mistakes happen.

    • Earl Reed

      February 28, 2011 at 5:59 am

      That’s not exactly what I said. It was a horrific mistake. If Birm had stayed 4-5-1, I don’t think Zigic was at fitness to do anything with that. I also think that Martins’ position in those moments was the key factor in forcing Koscielny’s action. The change wasn’t the tactical reason for the goal; if Zigic heads a ball into Martin’s channel and the Nigerian scored, that would be a tactical manifestation. This was serendipitous, a fluke that benefited the Blues in perhaps the greatest way possible.

  6. Jon Sharp

    February 27, 2011 at 11:56 pm

    Very interesting – thanks.
    Not sure how many Blues games you have seen this season, but I’ve seen them all and your chart shows a key reason for Blues success. In the absence of 2 strikers, Bowyer was the principal support player for Zigic. Bowyer had to get forward a lot and he, Gardner and Fahey had to run their socks off. Without that, Zigic would have been isolated. 4-5-1 with Zigic as the lone striker has not worked for Blues all season. But they needed Zigic to have any chance of beating Arsenal’s defence. The change when it came was because the midfield were getting tired of carrying that load and Arsenal were piling on the pressure. Martins and then finally Jerome provided some pace and ability to run the channels and keep Arsenal on their toes and off the Blues defence.

    Frankly the game could have gone either way. Blues played out of their skins and I am very proud of them. But Arsenal were under par which, all in all resulted in a tightly balanced game. On a different day, Arsenal would have taken some of their chances better and it could have been a different result. The pundits and media seem to be slightly embarrassed at having written Blues off before the game begun such that they seem intent on heaping scorn on Arsenal now. But we all know football is a funny old game and Arsenal and their fans should brush it off.

    Couple of clarifications
    a) Ben Gordon sounds like a vigorous Scottish Dance. Ben Foster is B’hams goalkeeper.
    b) Walcott went off on a stretcher against Stoke. I don’t know exactly when Cesc first picked up his hamstring injury, but he also started against Stoke and was substituted.

    • Earl Reed

      February 28, 2011 at 7:47 am

      Thanks for your feedback, both my mistake on Foster’s name as well as the circumstances behind the injuries to Walcott and Fabregas have been corrected. Appreciate it!

  7. pacificStyle

    February 27, 2011 at 11:34 pm

    Damn right Rosicky’s not the answer. The guy’s well past his best. Terrible in possession, no real play-making ability, just the very rare glimpse of talent – absolutely dreadful mistake putting him in the central midfield. Nasri needed to be there from the get go to command the flow of the game. They really, really, do need to work on getting someone other than Cesc to try and create chances for the likes of Persie, Walcott, Bendtner, etc. The midfield play since the Leyton Orient game has been woeful and they paid for that dearly yesterday. Jack Wilshere, meanwhile, is a genius, and I’m not even English. I watched this kid lose his temper a couple of times yesterday – that’s the wrong way to go. Keep your head about you boy and you’ll truly be a legend.

  8. gary

    February 27, 2011 at 10:30 pm

    The winning goal was a fluke but the thing that pissed me off the most was that Arsenal STILL cannot defend free kicks! Bir-min-um (to use Nick Webster’s pronounciation) has one guy that’s 8 feet tall – guess where the ball is going?

    • Gaz Hunt

      February 28, 2011 at 10:40 am

      Yup, Bir-nim-um not Bir-ming-hay-umn. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More in General

Translate »