Steven Cohen Offers Liverpool Fans No Hillsborough Apology

steven-cohen1

On Monday’s episode of the World Soccer Daily show, radio co-host Steven Cohen failed to apologize to Liverpool supporters regarding the inaccurate statements he made about their role in the Hillsborough Disaster that occurred on April 15, 1989.

The inaccurate statements made by Cohen on his April 13, 2009 episode of World Soccer Daily were that:

  1. Ticketless Liverpool supporters were the root cause of the Hillsborough Disaster,
  2. 6-8,000 ticketless Liverpool supporters showed up outside Hillsborough, and
  3. Sheffield Wednesday’s Hillsborough Stadium was used week-in week-out without incident.

Instead of apologizing, he softened his April 13 stance on his belief that there were 6-8,000 ticketless Liverpool supporters outside the ground. During the April 20, 2009 episode, he first said “There were several thousand who showed up without tickets.” But a few minutes later, when co-host Kenny Hassan gave Cohen an opportunity to retract the 6-8,000 number, Cohen replied “If it’s not the right number, it’s not the point. If I’m wrong on the number, then I’ll retract it and apologize. If it’s 25, 2500 or 25,000, my point is made for me. There were people there who shouldn’t have been there because they didn’t have tickets and they were hell bent on getting in. I’m sorry, those are the facts.”

Cohen is barking up the wrong tree when he claims ticketless fans contributed to the disaster. They did not. According to The Hillsborough Football Disaster paper entitled Context and Consequences, page 17, “[Lord Justice] Taylor surmised there was no substance to the allegation that ticketless fans caused the Disaster.”

And while there may have been some ticketless supporters outside the ground — as there are at any major football game or sporting event — “I have already found that there was not an abnormally large number of fans without tickets on this occasion,” said Lord Taylor in his interim report. “With one or two exceptions, the police witnesses themselves did not subscribe to the ‘conspiracy’ theory (of a large number of late-arriving ticketless supporters).”

Cohen has seemingly changed his tune about Liverpool — from the extreme opinion on April 13 that the ticketless fans were the root cause of the Hillsborough Disaster to a twisted logic on April 20 that insists on Liverpool fans admitting that they were part responsible for the disaster because some ticketless fans were hell bent on getting inside the stadium.

According to a report from the Health and Safety Executive (HSE), “it was unlikely that the terrace exceeded 10,124 and that total admissions were approximately equal to the designated capacity of 10,100 people.”

So even if there were as few as 24 ticketless supporters who were hell bent on getting into the Leppings Lane end, it would have been impossible for those fans — who were vastly outnumbered — to have an impact on the more than 3,000 fans who were inside the central pen.

“The point is if the people [without tickets] hadn’t been outside, this never [would have] happened,” said Cohen. “This is a stadium that had no problems prior to this particular day. That’s a fact.”

Except that it isn’t a fact. It’s inaccurate. As I reported in Monday’s EPL Talk article, there had been several incidents at Hillsborough prior to April 15, 1989 — most notably a game in 1981 when 38 Spurs supporters suffered crush-related injuries in the same Leppings Lane stand.

It’s time for Steven Cohen to share the facts with us that he claims he has. It’s also time for Cohen to publicly retract his statement that there were 6-8,000 ticketless Liverpool supporters. And most importantly of all, he needs to retract his statement that Liverpool fans were responsible for the Hillsborough Disaster.

There’s no evidence to show that 24 supporters sneaking over the wall at Hillsborough were a factor in the death of the 96 Liverpool fans who died from crush-related injuries. But there are plenty of pieces of evidence that chronicle the list of mistakes that South Yorkshire Police, Sheffield Wednesday and the Football Association committed.

For Steven Cohen to not apologize on air and to carry on about the need for Liverpool to share the responsibility of what happened at Hillsborough is sickening. It’s time for Cohen to admit he was wrong, apologize to Liverpool fans and to read the Taylor Interim Report to better educate himself and his World Soccer Daily listeners.

If he doesn’t apologize to his radio listeners, I’m concerned that he may spread his misinformation about what caused the Hillsborough Disaster to the weekly Fox Football Fone-In TV show that he co-hosts on Fox Soccer Channel. Having a loose cannon like Cohen on live TV is a risk that Fox has to determine whether it’s worth taking.

EPL Talk readers interested in learning more about Hillsborough as well as the chance to see TV footage and interviews should watch the excellent BBC Football Focus video from April 11, 2009 which was a special tribute to the 20th anniversary of the Hillsborough Disaster.

I should note that Kartik Krishnaiyer, from our sister site Major League Soccer Talk, had an interview previously arranged with Cohen for this Thursday, so feel free to post your questions for Cohen there. The interview is a golden opportunity for Cohen to respond to direct questions from you about his opinions regarding what really happened at Hillsborough.

You can listen to the segment of the April 20 episode where Cohen discusses the EPL Talk article below.

UPDATE: On May 18, 2009, Steven Cohen apologized on World Soccer Daily for his unfortunate and inaccurate statements he made about the Hillsborough Disaster.

UPDATE 2: The comments regarding the Steven Cohen controversy have been closed. It’s time to return the discussion to football.

421 Comments

  1. Rob Hodges April 21, 2009
  2. Target Man April 21, 2009
  3. John Maher April 21, 2009
  4. bob April 21, 2009
  5. Sang Yoo April 21, 2009
  6. PaulH April 21, 2009
  7. ProsperoDGC April 21, 2009
  8. ossie's dream April 21, 2009
  9. ProsperoDGC April 21, 2009
  10. Hank April 21, 2009
  11. Rich April 21, 2009
  12. Fredorrarci April 21, 2009
  13. Rickie April 21, 2009
  14. greg April 21, 2009
  15. wrighty April 21, 2009
  16. Paul Bestall April 21, 2009
  17. Ryan April 21, 2009
  18. Rickie April 21, 2009
  19. Tim April 21, 2009
  20. OPI April 21, 2009
  21. Rickie April 21, 2009
  22. todd April 21, 2009
  23. Tim April 21, 2009
  24. The Gaffer April 21, 2009
  25. Rickie April 21, 2009
  26. todd April 21, 2009
  27. The Gaffer April 21, 2009
  28. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  29. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  30. todd April 21, 2009
  31. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  32. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  33. ph0bolus April 21, 2009
  34. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  35. Scott April 21, 2009
  36. fsquid April 21, 2009
  37. John Holmes April 22, 2009
  38. PaulH April 22, 2009
  39. Tony April 22, 2009
  40. fsquid April 22, 2009
  41. Jonno April 22, 2009
  42. Jerry April 22, 2009
  43. Jerry April 22, 2009
  44. PZ April 22, 2009
  45. Jerry April 22, 2009
  46. Sean Atkinson April 22, 2009
  47. Josh April 22, 2009
  48. Ross Gallacher April 22, 2009
  49. United18 April 22, 2009
  50. mike April 22, 2009
  51. Dicky April 22, 2009
  52. Jimmy April 22, 2009
  53. The Gaffer April 22, 2009
  54. Jimmy April 22, 2009
  55. The Gaffer April 22, 2009
  56. Sejo April 23, 2009
  57. Paolo April 23, 2009
  58. Lisa Stevens April 23, 2009
  59. justice for the 96 April 23, 2009
  60. Shanks April 23, 2009
  61. Matt April 23, 2009
  62. Ryan April 23, 2009
  63. Melly Bean April 23, 2009
  64. Jerry April 23, 2009
  65. Aaron April 23, 2009
  66. Mark April 23, 2009
  67. Josh April 23, 2009
  68. Jeremy April 23, 2009
  69. Jeremy April 23, 2009
  70. Mark April 23, 2009
  71. stumpy313 April 23, 2009
  72. Jeremy April 23, 2009
  73. Mark April 23, 2009
  74. Jeremy April 23, 2009
  75. Paul S April 23, 2009
  76. Paul Bestall April 23, 2009
  77. Mark April 23, 2009
  78. Jeremy April 23, 2009
  79. David April 23, 2009
  80. Jeremy April 23, 2009
  81. David April 23, 2009
  82. ObjectiveMan April 24, 2009
  83. Ryan April 24, 2009
  84. The Gaffer April 24, 2009
  85. Jeremy April 24, 2009
  86. ArthurArseGooner April 24, 2009
  87. Jeremy April 24, 2009
  88. jim April 24, 2009
  89. ArthurArseGooner April 24, 2009
  90. ArthurArseGooner April 24, 2009
  91. ArthurArseGooner April 24, 2009
  92. ArthurArseGooner April 24, 2009
  93. webby April 24, 2009
  94. joanne church April 25, 2009
  95. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  96. PZ April 25, 2009
  97. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  98. Joe April 25, 2009
  99. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  100. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  101. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  102. Jaime April 25, 2009
  103. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  104. Jaime April 25, 2009
  105. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  106. jm April 25, 2009
  107. Jaime April 25, 2009
  108. Pakapala April 25, 2009
  109. Jaime April 25, 2009
  110. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  111. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  112. pjgalactica April 25, 2009
  113. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  114. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  115. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  116. Mark April 25, 2009
  117. RaiderRich2001 April 26, 2009
  118. Jacko April 26, 2009
  119. RaiderRich2001 April 26, 2009
  120. Arsene Wiener April 26, 2009
  121. matthew s April 26, 2009
  122. Jaime April 26, 2009
  123. joe April 26, 2009
  124. Jaime April 26, 2009
  125. eplnfl April 26, 2009
  126. Mark April 26, 2009
  127. Jaime April 26, 2009
  128. CrvnCttg April 26, 2009
  129. KW14Ultra April 26, 2009
  130. Mark April 26, 2009
  131. KW14Ultra April 26, 2009
  132. RedDevilManchester April 26, 2009
  133. Rich April 26, 2009
  134. Rich April 26, 2009
  135. joe April 26, 2009
  136. joe April 26, 2009
  137. Jaime April 26, 2009
  138. KW14Ultra April 27, 2009
  139. rio April 27, 2009
  140. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  141. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  142. Joe April 27, 2009
  143. KW14Ultra April 27, 2009
  144. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  145. Mark April 27, 2009
  146. KW14Ultra April 27, 2009
  147. Mark April 27, 2009
  148. Joe April 27, 2009
  149. Mark April 27, 2009
  150. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  151. Joe April 27, 2009
  152. David April 27, 2009
  153. Jaime April 27, 2009
  154. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  155. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  156. Joe April 27, 2009
  157. KW14Ultra April 27, 2009
  158. Joe April 27, 2009
  159. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  160. Jaime April 27, 2009
  161. KW14Ultra April 27, 2009
  162. KW14Ultra April 27, 2009
  163. Mark April 27, 2009
  164. Mark April 27, 2009
  165. Joe April 27, 2009
  166. Joe April 27, 2009
  167. Kevin April 27, 2009
  168. Mark April 27, 2009
  169. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  170. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  171. Joe April 27, 2009
  172. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  173. ELAC April 27, 2009
  174. The Gaffer April 27, 2009
  175. Jeremy April 27, 2009
  176. Sean Atkinson April 27, 2009
  177. Greg April 27, 2009
  178. Paul Bestall April 27, 2009
  179. Greg April 27, 2009
  180. Bishopville Red April 27, 2009
  181. shaft fc April 27, 2009
  182. Mark April 27, 2009
  183. shaft fc April 27, 2009
  184. Wizzell Fizzell April 27, 2009
  185. Trevor Hicks April 28, 2009
  186. KW14Ultra April 28, 2009
  187. davey hicks April 28, 2009
  188. Sean Atkinson April 28, 2009
  189. Sean Atkinson April 28, 2009
  190. davey hicks April 28, 2009
  191. Miguel April 28, 2009
  192. Joe April 28, 2009
  193. Mark April 28, 2009
  194. Shakira April 28, 2009
  195. shaft fc April 28, 2009
  196. Sean Atkinson April 28, 2009
  197. Kate April 30, 2009
  198. Jeremy April 30, 2009
  199. RaiderRich2001 April 30, 2009
  200. RaiderRich2001 April 30, 2009
  201. Kate April 30, 2009
  202. TheUnited May 1, 2009
  203. RaiderRich2001 May 1, 2009
  204. RaiderRich2001 May 1, 2009
  205. Jeremy May 1, 2009
  206. Jake May 1, 2009
  207. Jeremy May 1, 2009
  208. LFC JH May 1, 2009
  209. Mark May 1, 2009
  210. Jake May 1, 2009
  211. LFC JH May 1, 2009
  212. RaiderRich2001 May 1, 2009
  213. Greg May 1, 2009
  214. RaiderRich2001 May 1, 2009
  215. Joe May 1, 2009
  216. Joe May 1, 2009
  217. Mark May 1, 2009
  218. RaiderRich2001 May 1, 2009
  219. Jon May 1, 2009
  220. RaiderRich2001 May 2, 2009
  221. joe May 2, 2009
  222. Fuuzball May 2, 2009
  223. RaiderRich2001 May 2, 2009
  224. JohnE May 2, 2009
  225. RaiderRich2001 May 2, 2009
  226. Red in Dublin May 2, 2009
  227. RaiderRich2001 May 2, 2009
  228. Joe May 2, 2009
  229. Fuuzball May 2, 2009
  230. RaiderRich2001 May 2, 2009
  231. Joe May 2, 2009
  232. RaiderRich2001 May 2, 2009
  233. ArsenalFan May 2, 2009
  234. tank99 May 2, 2009
  235. Shakira May 3, 2009
  236. Mark May 3, 2009
  237. Fuuzball May 3, 2009
  238. Shakira May 3, 2009
  239. Jaime May 3, 2009
  240. Phil Kirwin May 3, 2009
  241. Shakira May 3, 2009
  242. Sam May 3, 2009
  243. Fuuzball May 3, 2009
  244. tank99 May 3, 2009
  245. Mr.Mister May 3, 2009
  246. Sam May 3, 2009
  247. Fuuzball May 3, 2009
  248. Jeremy May 4, 2009
  249. Gaz May 4, 2009
  250. Joe May 4, 2009
  251. Shakira May 4, 2009
  252. Tim May 4, 2009
  253. Chris May 4, 2009
  254. ILoveWaffles May 4, 2009
  255. Bob May 4, 2009
  256. steven May 4, 2009
  257. RickyJ May 4, 2009
  258. todd May 4, 2009
  259. ArsenalFan May 4, 2009
  260. Fuuzball May 4, 2009
  261. Fuuzball May 4, 2009
  262. Joe May 4, 2009
  263. CLAPSHOT12 May 5, 2009
  264. Spud May 5, 2009
  265. CLAPSHOT12 May 5, 2009
  266. Tim May 5, 2009
  267. tank99 May 5, 2009
  268. Mark May 5, 2009
  269. bobby May 5, 2009
  270. Shakira May 5, 2009
  271. Mark May 5, 2009
  272. Fuuzball May 5, 2009
  273. anton May 6, 2009
  274. Gaz May 7, 2009
  275. Fuuzball May 7, 2009
  276. Jeff D. May 7, 2009
  277. Joe May 7, 2009
  278. Huw Harris May 7, 2009
  279. John May 7, 2009
  280. Mark May 8, 2009
  281. RaiderRich2001 May 8, 2009
  282. RaiderRich2001 May 8, 2009
  283. RaiderRich2001 May 8, 2009
  284. Joe May 8, 2009
  285. Gaz May 8, 2009
  286. Phil Kirwin May 8, 2009
  287. Fuuzball May 8, 2009
  288. Mark May 8, 2009
  289. Jeremy May 8, 2009
  290. Jeremy May 8, 2009
  291. Mark May 8, 2009
  292. Mark May 8, 2009
  293. Mark May 8, 2009
  294. Mark May 8, 2009
  295. Joe May 8, 2009
  296. Shakira May 8, 2009
  297. RaiderRich2001 May 8, 2009
  298. Fuuzball May 8, 2009
  299. Jaime May 8, 2009
  300. Mark May 9, 2009
  301. Mark May 9, 2009
  302. Mark May 9, 2009
  303. Sam May 9, 2009
  304. Mark May 9, 2009
  305. RaiderRich2001 May 9, 2009
  306. Ron May 9, 2009
  307. Mark May 9, 2009
  308. Sam May 9, 2009
  309. Mark May 10, 2009
  310. LFC USA May 11, 2009
  311. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  312. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  313. LFC USA May 11, 2009
  314. Phil Kirwin May 11, 2009
  315. Rickie May 11, 2009
  316. Jaime May 11, 2009
  317. Mark May 11, 2009
  318. Mark May 11, 2009
  319. Mark May 11, 2009
  320. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  321. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  322. Jaime May 11, 2009
  323. Shakira May 11, 2009
  324. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  325. Shakira May 11, 2009
  326. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  327. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  328. Shakira May 11, 2009
  329. RaiderRich2001 May 11, 2009
  330. RaiderRich2001 May 11, 2009
  331. Sean Atkinson May 11, 2009
  332. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  333. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  334. RaiderRich2001 May 11, 2009
  335. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  336. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  337. RaiderRich2001 May 11, 2009
  338. RaiderRich2001 May 11, 2009
  339. Joe May 11, 2009
  340. RaiderRich2001 May 11, 2009
  341. RaiderRich2001 May 11, 2009
  342. Joe May 11, 2009
  343. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  344. Paul Bestall May 11, 2009
  345. RaiderRich May 11, 2009
  346. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  347. Joe May 11, 2009
  348. RaiderRich May 11, 2009
  349. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  350. RaiderRich May 11, 2009
  351. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  352. Jeremy May 11, 2009
  353. Fuuzball May 11, 2009
  354. RaiderRich May 11, 2009
  355. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  356. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  357. Rickie May 12, 2009
  358. Jaime May 12, 2009
  359. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  360. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  361. Jaime May 12, 2009
  362. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  363. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  364. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  365. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  366. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  367. Jaime May 12, 2009
  368. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  369. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  370. Jaime May 12, 2009
  371. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  372. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  373. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  374. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  375. Bob May 12, 2009
  376. Rickie May 12, 2009
  377. mike May 12, 2009
  378. Jeremy May 12, 2009
  379. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  380. mike May 12, 2009
  381. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  382. Greg May 12, 2009
  383. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  384. Fuuzball May 12, 2009
  385. Mark May 13, 2009
  386. The Gaffer May 14, 2009
  387. Jeremy May 14, 2009
  388. VfBPatrick May 14, 2009
  389. Fuuzball May 15, 2009
  390. Joe May 15, 2009
  391. Phil Kirwin May 15, 2009
  392. Jeremy May 15, 2009
  393. tank99 May 15, 2009
  394. Joe May 15, 2009
  395. LFC USA May 15, 2009
  396. Fuuzball May 15, 2009
  397. Joe May 16, 2009
  398. Mark May 16, 2009
  399. Mark May 16, 2009