You’ve Got to be Kidding Me, Mr. Commissioner

Commissioner Don Garber should know better. As the man most personally responsible for growing MLS into a palatable product in the United States, he should understand something very basic. As we discussed on today’s Daily 2Gs show on CSRN, the league is only where it is from an international standpoint thanks to DC United. For Commissioner Garber to make the following comments smacks of an appalling lack of respect for the signature club of the league he is the head of:

” For this league to win over the core audience, we’ve got to be able to be among the best clubs in N. America. DC United talks about their goal is to win a spot in the World Club Championship. They want to be the best team in the region. They really struggled the other night at Pachuca.”

DC United Manager Tom Soehn responded with the following:

“I want to thank our commissioner for motivating us for some slighted comments he had against us in the papers. I appreciate his TV analysis.”

Perhaps Mr. Commissioner if you weren’t so busy over selling and over promoting your league and certain teams in the league you could focus a little bit on making MLS more successful in these sorts of events. It’s quite ironic that despite all the bluster from the league office and certain executives about the Los Angeles Galaxy and David Beckham, when the rubber meets the road and our little league has prove it has grown up in legitimate competitions, the Galaxy and their $9.1 million payroll are never to be found. (The SUM created Pan Pacific Cup and Superliga are events meant to showcase MLS and make money, not true international championships of any sort)

You mention, Mr. Commissioner that for the league to win over its core audience our teams must be among the best clubs in North America. If that is the case, which I believe it is, why has the league spent so much time trying to market to casual sports fans via David Beckham and other vehicles who don’t share this perspective or even understand it in the least? I applaud the leagues newly stated goals: they have been my goals as I have editorialized time and again on this site for years now. However, if that is in fact your goal, and the goal of the league, why when a team such as DC United or Houston have injuries to key players like Ben Olsen or Eddie Robinson are they not able to sign a replacement player that doesn’t count against the salary cap or the 18 man senior roster limit?

Hasn’t occurred to you Mr. Commissioner that DC United at one time was arguably the best club in North America and then quickly slipped behind about twelve Mexican league teams because of the MLS salary cap and the number of quality players DC United was forced to let go of? Didn’t it embarrass you when A.J. Wood, Micah Cooks and Carey Talley were starting for DC United in the Champions Cup instead of players like Roy Lassiter, Jeff Agoos and John Harkes who had qualified them for the event? Do you recall that? Was that the fault of DC United? (no disrespect intended towards Wood, Cooks and Talley but my point is DC qualifed for the event with superior players and were forced to dump them because of the salary cap)

How about last night when Houston was forced after the fourth minute to play with several non regulars and several players out of position? Dom Kinnear knows the rules of MLS and did a great job developing more depth for the Dynamo last season, but to ask him and his players to do the impossible and then imply the league won’t win its core audience is to say the least irresponsible.

Instead of creating loopholes for the LA Galaxy who finished 11th in a 13 team league to circumvent the salary cap, why don’t you, Mr. Commissioner focus on helping teams like DC United and Houston who have stated a desire to be among the best clubs in the region and are closer due to their actions than the LA Galaxy who simply has the bombastic rhetoric of its front office to fall back on? Why don’t you look at ways to help top MLS sides (a group which again does not include the Galaxy) gain exemptions so they can compete hard in top competitions. Last season, DC United lost to Chicago in the playoffs largely because of their participation in the Copa Sudamericana. This year, with a similarly tight schedule, United may be inclined to decline an invitation to COMNEBOL’s second most prestigious event or worse yet send a “B” team to compete because the squad rules and salary cap are too restrictive.

We all want MLS to succeed abroad in these competitions. I have stated time and time again on this site that these events are how MLS’ success is measured, not by some superficial standard the league employs. Yet the league office much as it did with expansion holds different teams to different standards.

11 Responses to You’ve Got to be Kidding Me, Mr. Commissioner

  1. dark says:

    DCUnited played most of their new heavy South American reinforcements in both legs. Ben Olson is not DC. This result reeks of poor match fitness, communication problems and pre-season jitters.

    I do agree with you on all points except DC’s shortcomings.

  2. Daniel F. US Open Cup says:

    Kartik, please add the Lidier Marmol Discovery Player situation.

  3. JustinR says:

    “Instead of creating loopholes for the LA Galaxy who finished 11th in a 13 team league to circumvent the salary cap, why don’t you, Mr. Commissioner focus on helping teams like DC United and Houston who have stated a desire to be among the best clubs in the region and are closer due to their actions than the LA Galaxy who simply has the bombastic rhetoric of its front office to fall back on?”

    Greatest article you have ever written. Thanks Kartik, for speaking the truth.

  4. Ryan says:

    These last two posts have been really really good Kartik. Keep it up.

  5. bzygo says:

    Great article Kartik. Is it me, or does it seem that Garber is modeling himself more and more like those blowhards Selig, Goodell, and Stern?

  6. Joe says:

    This is without question your best work since starting this blog. Keep it up!

  7. J R says:

    This is a great blog post. Your best ever.

    Garber showed his true colors with those comments. He’s a marketing man and a Galaxy lover to boot. His comments disparaging DC were designed to promote the Galaxy as the super club they claim they are. Just wait until the pretty boys hit the road again this season.

    They’ll crawl back to their toolshed cocoon with their hands behind their back.

  8. Ray says:

    Without a doubt the best piece this blog, or CSRN in general has seen in sometime. Better than those columnists and the third half also, although the third half is pretty good.

  9. eplnfl says:

    Well Kartik, you are now the Keith Olbermann of American soccer blogs. I never miss his show by the way. You have become the angry man of US Soccer and US Soccer needs one badly. An excellent, classic blog, for you.

    The question you raise is can the true soccer fan or for that matter the real sports fan in American, except for maybe and just maybe the NFL, survive in a sports world where we are given the sizzle and not the steak, in place of real sport. How long has the NBA got along on omitting the rules so, so called great players can be showcased on National TV broadcasts. Or for that matter, that MLB looked away as pumped up players jacked balls out of the park, but it created audience,the only measure of achievement, or how the NHL has forced the goalkeepers to be glued to the nets in order to create offense in a sport that if you can skate at an entry level you can make the pros. I can go on and on but is the MLS doing anything the rest of the American sports world hasn’t or isn’t doing right now. Not really, but I will tell you this, I really missed no MLS soccer on ESPN last night!

  10. bandeeto says:

    International competition IS the ONLY test of a leagues quality. I believe the league has gone about as far as it can under the current player and salery restricions, when playing meaningfull international competition.

    Way to go Kartik!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>