Sign up for the free World Soccer Talk newsletter to find out how you can win 2 free tickets to Copa America »

SAT, 3:45PM ET
SAT, 3:45PM ET
SAT, 4:30PM ET
SAT, 9:30PM ET

Gap In Talent Between Germany And USA Soccer Teams Is Not As Wide As Many Argue

usa germany Gap In Talent Between Germany And USA Soccer Teams Is Not As Wide As Many Argue

The United States faces possible elimination from the World Cup if they don’t get at least a draw against Germany on Thursday. The USA’s failure to close out Portugal in stoppage time has left the national team with everything to do against Germany.

Assumptions are abound in the United States among some lazy pundits and those who quite honestly might want to see the sport fail that Germany is somehow an invincible force and the United States will be eliminated. The feeling is that the American team simply cannot compete with the might of Germany’s side, which is among the World Cup favorites.

USA Head Coach Jurgen Klinsmann, who won the 1990 World Cup as a player with Germany, will face his native country in this decisive final group game. Klinsmann also managed Germany in the 2006 World Cup and is given credit for transforming the side into an open, attack-minded team. But while the German team of 2014 retains Klinsmann’s attacking principles, they lack the classic German organization at the back. The full back position is a particular concern, and with the US showing real spunk in wide areas thus far in this World Cup, Graham Zusi, Fabian Johnson and DaMarcus Beasley could prove to be important assets.

The United States also has the ability to play in a more direct fashion testing the German backline. Ghana was able to use a high-line and long balls to their advantage, testing the German back four in the second group game. The pace of the Ghanaian midfield also caused Germany problems in that game as well. Germany also showed a slight vulnerability down the flanks in the opening group game against Portugal before that match was decisively influenced by the indiscipline of the Portuguese back-line.

The lack of reliable striking options also hampers this Germany side. Sure, they have scored six goals in two matches but they have several repetitive players in midfield that if they are tightly tracked and marked can be limited. Critical for the US will be Jermaine Jones, who was born and grew up in Germany and has suited up for Die Mannschaft in friendlies before filing his one-time FIFA switch of allegiance in 2009. Jones has been the best player in Group G during this World Cup. He stated weeks ago that he would not celebrate a goal against Germany, but no doubt he will be properly motivated.

Sami Khedira’s lack of mobility coming off a serious injury is another factor that must be considered difficult for Germany. The loss of Marco Reus before the World Cup was also a devastating blow to the side, as Reus was perhaps the most complete and resourceful members of the midfield.

Historically, the US has played better against Germany than other top European opposition. I was at a match in Jacksonville Florida in 1999 when the United States beat Germany 3-0 in a friendly. Later that year, the US beat Germany in a winner-take-all match in the Confederations Cup. Many also recall the 2002 Quarterfinal where the US went toe-to-toe with the eventual finalists. Michael Ballack’s goal decided proceedings that day but the US was oh so close to shocking the world.

In those days, the United States lacked the belief, the national support and squad depth to compete the way they do today. Yet the USA always played well against the Germans.

This German team lacks the mental strength of past sides. All too often in big games they have capitulated both at the club level and with the national team. Consistently when Germany has been pushed at the international level with this set of players, they have lost. The soccer might be slick and the passing pretty, but the lack of trophies and big game success mean this German side is underachieving. The pressure has never been greater on this set of players who have for the most part never won a decisive match of any sort against non-German opposition (domestic league and Bayern’s Champions League triumph, which was over fellow Bundesliga side BVB).

It is also worth noting the United States has not lost a World Cup game inside of 90 minutes since 2006. The USA is undefeated in six successive matches within ninety minutes.

While it is difficult to see the United States as clear favorites against the Germans, the gap isn’t as wide as some would lead you to believe. The Americans also have elements that could create the environment for a shocking victory.

This entry was posted in German National Team, US, US Soccer, World Cup, World Cup 2014. Bookmark the permalink.

About Kartik Krishnaiyer

A lifelong lover of soccer, the beautiful game, he served from January 2010 until May 2013 as the Director of Communications and Public Relations for the North American Soccer League (NASL). Raised on the Fort Lauderdale Strikers of the old NASL, Krishnaiyer previously hosted the American Soccer Show on the Champions Soccer Radio Network, the Major League Soccer Talk podcast and the EPL Talk Podcast. His soccer writing has been featured by several media outlets including The Guardian and The Telegraph. He is the author of the book Blue With Envy about Manchester City FC.
View all posts by Kartik Krishnaiyer →

8 Responses to Gap In Talent Between Germany And USA Soccer Teams Is Not As Wide As Many Argue

  1. jtm371 says:

    I am sorry please tell me which American would replace which German NONE! PLEASE

  2. Jake says:

    We have a good team Kartik but to say the gap isn’t that wide is just delusional. Is our press starting to become like the English one used to be now?
    We hyped up Bradley and he’s been nowhere to be found in the world cup.
    Kartik the fact that Schurrle, Podolski, Draxler, Durm, Bender Brothers, Schmelzer, Weidenfeller, Ter Stegen, Kevin Grosskreutz, etc. can’t get consistent playing time for Germany says something about the talent gap. They’ve lost their best attacking player in Reus and their second best midfielder Gundogan to injury and Schweini and Khedira aren’t fully fit yet. With all those things that have happened to their squad they still can make 2 deep XIs. All the players I listed walk into our lineup.
    Do you think we’d be where we are if we lost our best attacking player (Dempsey), had a half fit Jones and 1 of the others out to injury???
    They have the most talented side in the tournament so this is the last team we should compare ourselves to.
    I can safely say not one of our players makes their 23 man squad. Tim Howard isn’t better than Ter Stegen, Neuer, or Weidenfeller.
    We need to just chill out and not hype up our players after 1 or 2 good games. The best player in group G has been Mario Goetze Kartik. He’s been fantastic and he wasn’t even guaranteed a spot in the starting XI and didn’t look like he was gonna start in the tournament either.

  3. Frill Artist says:

    Another delusional post from Kartik.

  4. Gregg says:

    To say Tim Howard couldn’t make the German team is laughable!

  5. sniper says:

    what did u smoke before type bro ??
    some american player is best in the group G ? what about thomas mueller ?? or mario goetze ? any of your american player wouldn’t have chance to play in german team, if there was any rule :)

    chillout indian dude, let USA play 30-45 match in worldcup and then think about winning it . ok ?

  6. Ben says:

    and italy is going to win the tournament, right?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>