WED, 2:45PM ET
LIV
REAL
WED, 2:45PM ET
AND
ARS
WED, 2:45PM ET
OLY
JUV
WED, 2:45PM ET
GAL
BVB
WED, 2:45PM ET
ATL
MAL
WED, 2:45PM ET
LEV
ZEN

Why Rodney Marsh’s Assertion That Yaya Toure Is Not Happy At Manchester City Has Validity

yaya toure Why Rodney Marshs Assertion That Yaya Toure Is Not Happy At Manchester City Has Validity

I flew through London Heathrow Airport the other day wearing a retro Manchester City shirt. When asked about it in Terminal 5, I simply stated it was a Rodney Marsh kit (which it is not — it is a generic kit from the 1971-72 season when Marsh joined the club and the team collapsed falling from first in the table March 15 to a finishing spot of fourth), which was understood by the gentleman asking the question. “What a player!” was the response I got when Marsh’s name was mentioned.

Rodney Marsh spends most of his time these days in Tampa, Florida but still has his finger on the City pulse. When I have spoken to him at Tampa Bay Rowdies games over the course of the past few years, he has been able to stay informed on City partly through his contacts but mostly through the initiation only a truly great footballer has for his former club.

So when Marsh told TalkSport the other day that Yaya Toure was unhappy at Manchester City, I took it very seriously.

Marsh said:

“People close to (Manchester) City tell me Yaya Toure is not very happy and he’s one of their great players.

“When you start to hear rumblings from within the camp, and you see the way Toure played last weekend ( versus Sunderland), when he was strolling around and didn’t look interested, I’m wondering now if it will all go a little bit the other way.”

While Toure quickly put down the speculation, Manchester City’s indifferent play away from Eastlands this season indicates a side that is not properly motivated and going through the motions.  Perhaps the mercenary tag that had been lost under Roberto Mancini, particularly at the epic end of the 2011-12 season, is back, considering the lack of interest top stars at City including Toure seem to show during adverse away matches.

The two took to Twitter to exchange messages beginning with Toure

Toure:

“Hey buddies, don’t listen to the rumors, I’m happy at city..the Toure brothers are in Casa and are missing Manchester.”

Marsh:

“Ask yourself this. Why would Yaya dash to deny a rumour from an old man sitting in Starbucks in Florida?”

Toure:

“Out of respect for my fans and my club!! How can I be unhappy when I get so much love and respect from everyone in city?”

I have noted at times earlier in the season the lack of passion and enthusiasm Toure is demonstrating at times during matches. While outsiders have often accused the Ivorian of laziness on the pitch, he seems to always pipe up in the right spots and critical times in matches. While this season Toure has added free-kick excellence to his repertoire, his influence in the middle of the park has been far less significant than anytime since joining Manchester City in the summer of 2010.

Like many of the other experienced members of City’s playing staff, when things do not go well for the side away from home Toure appears to lack the passion for the cause he previously had. We’ve heard repeatedly that Manuel Pellegrini is a player’s manager as opposed to the motivational tactics of Roberto Mancini that were direct and often crippling to morale. Whether these characterizations are fair or not, Mancini appeared to have gotten far more out of the squad than Pellegrini has to this stage in his young tenure.

My sense is Marsh is on to something. The cracks at Manchester City were obvious to anyone who bothered to pay attention this summer. As a supporter of the club, I came into the season simply hoping the side would not fall out of the top 4 even while pundits less attuned to the situation at the club predicted a Premier League title. At this stage in the season, I am not even sure City can sustain a viable challenge for the top 4 positions, while qualification for any European competition may hinge upon the ability to win a domestic cup competition, which seems highly unlikely given the inconsistency in the squad.

While it has become fashionable for many in the media, some of whom picked the Blues to run away with the title this season, to blame Joe Hart for the club’s embarrassingly poor start to the season (Manchester City has lost four games this season in the league more quickly than the team lost its first league match either of the previous two season and faster than the team lost its second league match in the 2009-10 season when Mark Hughes was sacked in December and the club finished fifth in the league), the reality is that Hart’s woes have simply compounded obvious problems of squad cohesion, motivation and  managerial tactics.

Marsh doesn’t come to conclusions in a vacuum, and doesn’t say things about City for dramatic effect. He’s a former player who wears his support for the club on his sleeve even when working in the media. I tend to believe his commentary has validity when it comes to this situation.

Editor’s note: Read more news, analysis and opinion about the Citizens on our Manchester City team page.

This entry was posted in Leagues: EPL, Manchester City. Bookmark the permalink.

About Kartik Krishnaiyer

A lifelong lover of soccer, the beautiful game, he served from January 2010 until May 2013 as the Director of Communications and Public Relations for the North American Soccer League (NASL). Raised on the Fort Lauderdale Strikers of the old NASL, Krishnaiyer previously hosted the American Soccer Show on the Champions Soccer Radio Network, the Major League Soccer Talk podcast and the EPL Talk Podcast. His soccer writing has been featured by several media outlets including The Guardian and The Telegraph. He is the author of the book Blue With Envy about Manchester City FC.
View all posts by Kartik Krishnaiyer →

6 Responses to Why Rodney Marsh’s Assertion That Yaya Toure Is Not Happy At Manchester City Has Validity

  1. Marc L says:

    But if Toure is so unhappy, why did he recently extend his contract? Well, money, of course, but he would have gotten that anywhere.

    Nothing to see here as far as the ostensible topic of the article, I think.

    But I do agree that this season will present a formidable hurdle as far as winning the league and/or European qualification.

    Six points off the top may not look bad with 27 matches to play, but City has played an absurdly weak list of fixtures vis-a-vis the main competition.

    Remaining, we have rags away, Everton away (never get anything from that one), two against Liverpool, Arsenal, and So’ton. Two against Spurs.

    If they overperform in those matches, then anything is attainable.

    But is do-able for a club that can lose to Sunderland and Cardiff and probably deserved to lose to Stoke (and even, arguably, Hull?)

    Hard to say. But that’s alright. I still love them. Only rags expect/need to win something every year.

  2. cam says:

    Yaya could have gone to Monaco last summer on higher wages, but accepted a reduced basic to extend his contract. It’s just the way he is, even in his first two seasons he had these lazy games.

  3. Why? says:

    Who is Rodney Marsh? who is he in relation to City?

    Rodney Marsh was as second rate player who won a couple of league cups and and English third div title. He had 9 England caps. I puzzles me why somebody would say ‘what a player’ lets face it he was a drunken fool, lazy showboater, always trying to gain the attention of the media on the pitch and off it with his big mouth. Not much has changed.

    In relation to City who would this clown actually know? He was there for a few seasons 40 years ago!! True Mick Summerbee is employed by the club and I wouldn’t put it past the clown to imply he said somthing, but then you have to think why would Yaya Toure tell any bit part employee at the club he’s unhappy? He just wouldn’t would he? It’s obvious the clown is not rich but loves the lifestyle, so he sees a city loss and thinks ‘I’ll get in the adig in and get in papers again, make up some sext and bingo, press will be all over me’ this clown already has a very low rating with city fans in general why not try to get to F list celebrity status it might get me a few quid to drowned my sorrows.

    Toure tool him apart on Twitter and show him to be the lying drunken clown he is, just like when he was a player, if you could call him that joke suits better. He’s after the attention! Sad, sad old man

  4. Tony Butterworth says:

    Marsh has to say and do stuff to keep himself in the news.

  5. Mike says:

    What are you talking about you fool?

    “I have noted at times earlier in the season the lack of passion and enthusiasm Toure is demonstrating at times during matches”.

    Toure has been in brilliant form this season, have you been watching at all?

    7 goals in 14 appearances this season from central midfield and he is also making assists. Is there any more evidence of you making a fool of yourself? Yes

    “At this stage in the season, I am not even sure City can sustain a viable challenge for the top 4 positions”

    We aren’t even a third of the way into the season yet and with City 6 points behind the league leaders you suggest this? And you are a city fan?

    Don’t make me laugh

  6. James says:

    Whenever a new manager takes over all the players have to adapt and each usually has a different role to the one they had previously. Toure may not be playing as well as he could but that doesn’t mean he is unhappy. He is playing with a different partner in midfield. It will take time for them to gel.

    City may be struggling in the league to meet expectations but they are still in every competition they have been involved in.

    If City haven’t improved by January and Toure is still not playing as well as he is capable of then one can complain. With 6 points to make up in 27 matches left for a team with the talent of City is not insurmountable. After all they won the league when they were 8 points behind with jut a handful of matches left.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>