THURS, 1PM ET
WOL0
EVE2
THURS, 1PM ET
FEY1
SEV0
THURS, 3PM ET
TOT
PAR
THURS, 3PM ET
INT
DNI
THURS, 3PM ET
VIL
MON
THURS, 3PM ET
CEL
SAL

Premiership Referees Are In A No-Win Situation

 41203072 cup6 Premiership Referees Are In A No Win Situation
I feel sorry for Premiership referees. Never before has their jobs been so scrutinized or have they felt a much pressure as they do now. The issues are compounded by the speed of the game and the advanced skills of some players where they’ve made diving in a penalty an art form, albeit a sickening form when you consider the harmful effects on the game.

What complicates matters is that even when players have the opportunity to stay up on their feet in the penalty area, they’re deciding to fall down in the penalty area (after being knocked) because they know the referee has to call a penalty. The perfect example of this was Kanu for Portsmouth in their 2-1 win against Watford when the Nigerian could have easily stayed up and shot at goal, but decided to fall down instead.

Worse still, I feel that the referees sometimes can’t win. A good example of this is the recent Blackburn versus Tottenham Hotspur match I attended at Ewood Park. The amount of controversy that rained down on Phil Dowd after this match was enormous, but Phil Dowd’s decisions on that night would have been more controversial if he didn’t make the calls he made.

This goes back to video technology and whether it should be used. I, unlike most others, am divided on the subject. For example, in that Blackburn match, Tugay seemed to foul Ghaly in the penalty area and Dowd pointed toward the spot. Later that night, Andy Gray replayed the incident over and over again approximately six times and even he couldn’t decide 100% whether there was contact or not.

When commentators and football insiders claim that a video call can be made in 30 seconds, I disagree. For such an important decision such as that penalty incident, it could take a couple of minutes — and even then, a wrong decision could be made because you’re still relying on the human factor to make the final decision after seeing the video.

The other aspect that complicates matter is the sheer pace of the match. Whether it’s in person or on television, I often find myself making rash decisions on whether a call should or should not be a penalty. But due to the speed of today’s game, it’s sometimes hard to tell if it’s a foul or not. While in real-time, I may feel confident that a foul is a penalty or not, when I watch it on TV replay, I often find that my gut reaction decision was wrong. When TV replays slow the incident down to a fraction of a second, you can better make a decision. But again, not always, and what would a video judge decide in the Tugay-Ghaly case?

What needs to happen is that other options needs to be tested to see if it can work. Earlier this week, Udinese used goal line technology in Serie A as a test. There’s also been talk about testing two referees on a field or using four assistant referees instead of two. That may help.

But what I believe is that the level of refereeing in today’s Premiership is far better than it was 10 or 20 years ago. It just seems worse because of the amount of TV coverage where every incident is reviewed over and over again. Watching football in the late 70s and early 80s, I saw many horrendous refereeing decisions being made that were far worse than today. The offside problem also seemed to be far worse back then. These days, for the most part, most of the offside decisions are far more accurate presumably because of better training for assistant referees.

So spare a thought for people like Dowd, Rennie, Poll, Gallagher, Clattenberg, Webb and others. After all, without the aid of TV replays, could you do better than these blokes?

This entry was posted in General, Leagues: EPL. Bookmark the permalink.

About Christopher Harris

Founder and publisher of World Soccer Talk, Christopher Harris is the managing editor of the site. He has been interviewed by The New York Times, The Guardian and several other publications. Plus he has made appearances on NPR, BBC World, CBC, BBC Five Live, talkSPORT and beIN SPORT. Harris, who has lived in Florida since 1984, has supported Swansea City since 1979. He's also an expert on soccer in South Florida, and got engaged during half-time of a MLS game. Harris launched EPL Talk in 2005, which was rebranded as World Soccer Talk in 2013.
View all posts by Christopher Harris →

2 Responses to Premiership Referees Are In A No-Win Situation

  1. Anonymous says:

    Remember that referees have to view incidents at ground level and, with the speed of play, often with players between them and the ball; TV cameras have a bird’s eye view from which it’s much easier to see the full action. And that’s before we even get on to slow motion replays and different angled shots from a multitude of cameras. Nevertheless the standard of EPL refereeing is too patchy. It seems to take a long time for some of the younger ones to come through the system whilst others, like Poll, spend too much time trying to be the centre of attention. I’ve yet to see a red card for diving in the penalty area. Why? It’s blatant cheating. They should be summarily banished. A few of those and diving would be eradicated.

  2. The Gaffer says:

    Corradi got a second yellow card today for diving in the penalty area against Man United and got sent off.

    I do agree with what you said though.

    Cheers,
    The Gaffer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>