Why Manuel Pellegrini is a Worthy Replacement to Roberto Mancini

After three successful years in charge at Malaga, and months of speculation regarding his managerial future, Manchester City finally announced the appointment of Manuel Pellegrini as manager, coming a month after the the sacking of Roberto Mancini. And according to City’s official club website, the Chilean will officially take up his managerial post on June 24th.

Even before the Chilean has even assumed the role as coach, there is already an air of negativity surrounding his appointment with some English media outlets describing him as a “big-spending foreigner with a modest trophy record.” These are the same people who hailed the appointment of David Moyes as manager of Manchester United despite not winning a single title during his ten year tenure at Everton. Injustice? I think so.

“What about his tenure at Real Madrid?” they ask. “He spent a whopping €200 million and still won nothing!” they exclaim. Well the fact of the matter is, El Ingeniero was appointed during what was a political battle inside the headquarters of Santiago Bernabeu. Cristiano Ronaldo and Kaka were brought in whilst Wesley Sneijder and Arjen Robben were sold, all of these actions were against his own wishes.

“I didn’t have a voice or a vote at Madrid,” he told El Mercurio in an interview in 2010

“I can’t get anything out of an orchestra if I have the 10 best guitarists but I don’t have a pianist or a drummer.”

Pellegrini heads to a club in need of rebuilding. The Sky Blues suffered a somewhat humiliating season. The Manchester club, who were defending Premier League champions, were well off the pace, finishing 11 points off eventual champions and rivals Manchester United. They suffered a 1-0 defeat to Wigan (who were relegated from the EPL) in the FA Cup final, and were eliminated in extraordinary fashion in the group stages of the Champions League.

Compounded to this is the fact that the fans themselves are still emotionally attached to their former Italian tactician. This will certainly provide a Stamford Bridge-esque atmosphere, a tension between the manager/club directors and fans.

However, despite these certain negativities that are overshadowing his appointment, there is no doubt that Manuel Pellegrini will bring with him qualities that Mancini lacked.

Casual and very friendly, Pellegrini will bring with him an attractive brand of football, unlike that of Mancini. Pellegrini sides are built on strong defensive foundations. This in turn will allow for midfield and attacking creativity.

And with his four years at Manchester City about to commence, here are a few factors that will transform this mediocre yet cash-rich club into a prestigious team.

Experience and quality:

The 59 year old, who has managed an astonishing 10 clubs to date, will bring along with him a wealth of experience.  He has, over the course of his time as player and manager, evolved with the game and the tactics implemented will suit the current needs in a physical game.

Despite his duck in terms of winning European titles, he credentials are still worth praising.

During his time at Villarreal, he transformed a small club from a Spanish town near Valencia with little to no history and prestige into a well respected club. The Yellow Submarines managed 3rd place in La Liga in the 2004-05 season, were Champions League semi-finalists in 2005-06 and broke the big two in 2008.

Let’s not forget his efforts in helping Malaga secure Champions League football for the first time in their history. During the 2010-11 season, last season’s magical Champions League run into the semis was without big names such as Santi Cazorla. This should provide fans with the confidence that Pellegrini is the key to continued football success.

Tactical superiority:

Pellegrini is an enhanced version of Mancini, who at times was clueless with tactical choices. He previous spells at the aforementioned Spanish clubs proved flexibility and he has seemingly left every club better than before he had arrived.

With a well founded Barcelona blueprint making its way into the club in conjunction with Pellegrini’s every growing knowledge and football philosophy, Manchester City will develop a tactical superiority over its rivals.

Txiki Begiristain, the sporting director, who was formerly affiliated with the Blaugrana, is trying to instill Barcelona’s infamous 4-3-3 formation into the 1st team and all the youth sides.

However, before this can be achieved, Pellegrini will be expected to use his own favoured tactics. For much of his career, the tactician has favoured the 4-2-2-2 formation instead of a balanced 4-4-2. His used this to great effect whilst at Spanish club Villarreal where he combined South American authenticity with European efficiency, which led to many admiring that attractive brand of football played.

At Malaga, he showed tactical flexibility by switching through numerous formations. At times he favoured the 4-3-1-2 formation which allowed creative hub Isco to weave his magic in the middle of the pitch. However he used the 4-2-3-1 formation to devastating effect. He was able to inject stability throughout the team. He utilized attacking firepower without risking their defensive solidity, highlighted by their 4-0 thrashing against Valencia last November.

He did choose a conservative 4-2-2 approach throughout the Champions League campaign en-route to the semi-finals. However, stability will hold the key, and unless he is forced into a 4-3-3 formation, his 4-2-2-2 or 4-2-3-1 formation will be used constantly.

The Citizens in the past have confronted Europe’s top trainers but none can boast of a reputation higher than the ‘Engineer’. Pellegrini – a masterclass tactician – will definitely bring the club much-needed success. His previous fruitful relationships with fans should fill ‘ultras’ with much hope. All in all, City could not have asked for a better coach.

Follow Cronan on Twitter: @CrowzarY


  1. Marc L June 20, 2013
    • Marc L June 20, 2013
  2. Mike June 20, 2013
    • Tim Nash June 20, 2013
    • jtm371 June 20, 2013
    • christian June 21, 2013
  3. Sheldon June 20, 2013
  4. Steven P. June 20, 2013

Leave a Reply