The Art of Soccer Commentary And How FOX Is Breaking The Rules

FOX’s decision to throw Gus Johnson into the deep end next week with the Champions League match between Real Madrid and Manchester United sends a strong message to its hardcore soccer base who have been watching the Premier League on FOX Soccer for 15 consecutive years — we don’t care about you anymore. We’ve lost the EPL rights for the next 3 years so instead of Martin Tyler, let’s put Johnson into the pressure cooker and sees how he copes with one of the biggest matches of the European season.

FOX’s move is a kick in the teeth to Premier League soccer fans who have watched this sport religiously week-in week-out for years, or — for some — decades. What FOX fails to recognize is that the role of the soccer commentator is the most important bond between the broadcaster and viewer. Many of us enjoy some of the great commentators just as much as some of the games. We’ve grown up listening to commentators such as Tyler, Ian Darke, Jonathan Pearce, Alan Parry, Clive Tyldesley, Peter Drury and many others. I would argue that they are one of the reasons why we love watching the Premier League so much.

While there’s no argument that Johnson is a skilled commentator on American sports such as basketball and American football, the leap from those sports to soccer is immense. The role of a soccer commentator is to act as our window to the game. Pulling us closer into the experience. Enhancing our excitement, and pointing out the nuances that delight us.

We find ourselves in a transitional period in the history of soccer games on US television. There are two forces colliding against each other. The first is FOX Sports realizing that they can’t grow its hardcore soccer fanbase any more than what it is, so it needs to make changes to cater to the American mainstream. At the same time, you have the second force, which are the hardcore soccer fans who expect the very best and know the difference between quality commentating and talent that are not schooled in the game.

ESPN went through the same situation in 2006 when they decided to cater to the American mainstream by hiring baseball announcer Dave O’Brien to be the lead commentator for World Cup games on US television. The move backfired, and ESPN quickly learned that the path forward was to hire the best in the business and the mainstream would follow. Based on ESPN’s record breaking TV ratings for Euro 2008, World Cup 2010 and Euro 2012, the formula worked.

Pages 1 2 3

145 Comments

  1. Matt February 6, 2013
    • Bob February 7, 2013
  2. FCAsheville February 6, 2013
    • Henry February 6, 2013
  3. Phil Badger February 6, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
      • andrew February 6, 2013
        • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
          • OT February 8, 2013
        • Brian Zygo February 8, 2013
      • Earl Reed February 6, 2013
        • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
          • Earl Reed February 6, 2013
          • Guy February 6, 2013
          • Bob February 7, 2013
  4. ghl February 6, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
  5. BA14 February 6, 2013
    • Earl Reed February 6, 2013
  6. Gillyrosh February 6, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
    • Henry February 6, 2013
    • Paul February 6, 2013
  7. Fsquid February 6, 2013
  8. Colin February 6, 2013
  9. Alfredo February 6, 2013
    • Alfredo February 6, 2013
  10. Kody February 6, 2013
    • Matt February 6, 2013
      • Justin February 6, 2013
        • Cantona February 6, 2013
  11. Christian February 6, 2013
  12. San Franciscan February 6, 2013
    • Fernando February 6, 2013
      • Earl Reed February 6, 2013
        • San Franciscan February 6, 2013
      • San Franciscan February 6, 2013
      • Wongo1 February 8, 2013
    • Alfredo February 6, 2013
      • Marc L February 6, 2013
      • Alfredo February 6, 2013
        • San Franciscan February 6, 2013
  13. Fernando February 6, 2013
  14. David February 6, 2013
    • Cantona February 6, 2013
      • David February 6, 2013
        • Cantona February 6, 2013
    • Neil February 24, 2013
  15. varghese February 6, 2013
    • Alfredo February 6, 2013
      • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
        • Alfredo February 6, 2013
          • Alfredo February 6, 2013
          • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
  16. John February 6, 2013
    • Fernando February 6, 2013
      • Earl Reed February 6, 2013
        • Fernando February 6, 2013
          • Nathan February 6, 2013
      • John February 6, 2013
      • Wongo1 February 8, 2013
  17. ruffneckc February 6, 2013
    • Earl Reed February 6, 2013
  18. Marc L February 6, 2013
  19. noel February 6, 2013
  20. Earl Reed February 6, 2013
  21. Cantona February 6, 2013
    • Alfredo February 6, 2013
      • Cantona February 6, 2013
        • Alfredo February 6, 2013
  22. Frill Artist February 6, 2013
  23. noel February 6, 2013
    • Cantona February 6, 2013
    • Nathan February 6, 2013
  24. Mufc77 February 6, 2013
    • IanCransonsKnees February 6, 2013
    • Alfredo February 6, 2013
      • IanCransonsKnees February 6, 2013
  25. IanCransonsKnees February 6, 2013
  26. Henry February 6, 2013
    • Marc L February 6, 2013
      • Mufc77 February 6, 2013
        • Guy February 6, 2013
  27. Guy February 6, 2013
  28. IanCransonsKnees February 6, 2013
  29. kyle February 6, 2013
  30. Tom February 6, 2013
    • OT February 6, 2013
    • Paul February 7, 2013
  31. Jason February 6, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
      • Jason February 6, 2013
        • Kobashi February 6, 2013
          • Guy February 6, 2013
  32. steve February 6, 2013
  33. steve February 6, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
      • steve February 6, 2013
      • Wongo1 February 7, 2013
  34. Matt February 6, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 6, 2013
    • Wongo1 February 8, 2013
  35. Smokey Bacon February 6, 2013
  36. john marzan February 6, 2013
  37. john marzan February 6, 2013
    • john marzan February 7, 2013
      • Wongo1 February 8, 2013
  38. nak February 7, 2013
    • Tim February 7, 2013
      • Nak February 7, 2013
        • Guy February 7, 2013
  39. James February 7, 2013
  40. Todd Shenk February 7, 2013
  41. Nelson February 7, 2013
  42. john marzan February 7, 2013
  43. Brian Zygo February 8, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 8, 2013
      • Guy February 8, 2013
      • Brian Zygo February 8, 2013
        • The Gaffer February 8, 2013
          • Wongo1 February 8, 2013
  44. CVO February 8, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 8, 2013
    • Guy February 8, 2013
      • Ruben February 11, 2013
    • Wongo1 February 8, 2013
  45. tjt5055 February 8, 2013
  46. Leafsfan1967 February 8, 2013
  47. The Gaffer February 8, 2013
  48. Henry February 8, 2013
    • The Gaffer February 8, 2013
      • Guy February 8, 2013
  49. CTBlues February 8, 2013
  50. captain February 8, 2013
  51. MG February 8, 2013
  52. Scrumper February 9, 2013
  53. John February 11, 2013
  54. Raul February 11, 2013
  55. George May 12, 2013
  56. Sam Fairhurst February 24, 2014
  57. ProSports Pathways April 23, 2014
  58. r.j.henry February 19, 2015
  59. James March 25, 2017
  60. James March 25, 2017
    • vssssqz March 25, 2017

Leave a Reply