Connect with us

Leagues: EPL

Sunderland move does not make sense for Sam Allardyce


Sam Allardyce has returned to club management after a short sabbatical by accepting an offer to manage Sunderland. Ellis Short, the reclusive American-based billionaire who owns the club stated the obvious when he said “Sam was the obvious best choice for the job.”

Clearly Allardyce, whose record speaks for itself, was the best choice for Sunderland. That is beyond any reasonable debate. But is Sunderland the best choice for Allardyce? It depends entirely on your level of expectation.

For three years running, Sunderland has relied on great escapes to remain in the Premier League. In each of the last four seasons (including this one), Sunderland will end a Premier League campaign with a different manager than they had at the start of the season. Each of these managers — Martin O’Neill, Paulo DiCanio, Gus Poyet and Dick Advocaat — have been high-profile figures who have demanded Short spend money and buy players that suited their specific tastes.

Short always came through and monetarily backed his managers in the transfer market. What has resulted is a bloated wage bill that has consistently been among the top half in a league on to see the team’s results fail to approach that stature. Additionally, all the chopping and changing has led to a squad list that resembles a hodgepodge of repetitive players, differing styles and levels of player.

SEE MORE: Advocaat is wrong; Sunderland have the talent to stay up.

Into this walks Sam Allardyce, a manager renowned for creating strong tactical structures and getting results even, if the play is far from easy on the eye. “Big Sam” will inherit a team not without major talent but with little consistency and a woeful lack of fight, except when it comes to playing rival Newcastle or needing a critical win in May to avoid relegation.

Sunderland are a massive club with support levels that rival those of English sides that routinely compete for trophies. But the Black Cats last won a trophy in 1973 – when the club recorded one of the historic upsets of the era, defeating Leeds United at Wembley in a famous FA Cup final. Since then, Sunderland has bounced between divisions but always maintained strong loyalty and support.

But the commitment level of fans has been tested during the Short regime, which began in 2009. The ambitions of the American owner were to maintain a high-level Premier League club, thus he has sacked managers and spent money to maintain a spot in the richest division of world soccer. But by doing so, Sunderland has yet to have a normal season of routine consolidation, and, quite frankly, the club needed to be relegated one of these past few campaigns so that they could get the house in order. Sunderland’s continued spending of good money after bad has left the club in a precarious financial state should they go down now, whereas had the club been relegated in 2013 or 2014, things would not be quite as gloomy.

Instead, Sunderland continues to tug along, spending money and achieving minimal results. Allardyce is a manager that gets optimum results and will likely keep the Black Cats in the division. But what this means is that the much needed clear out from the club will be postponed by a year, if not longer. If the clear out does not occur before eventual relegation from the division, it could be quite ugly, even if the new Premier League television deals might offset some of that financial pain.

Given what Sunderland does to managers and how toxic the atmosphere around the club has become, why Allardyce would take a job like this? My only guess is that Big Sam having “failed” at neighboring Newcastle United would like another shot at managing a well-supported northern club. Allardyce has managed brilliantly at Bolton and Blackburn, two Lancashire clubs that have historic lineage but minimal support when compared to Sunderland. He also managed a London club, West Ham United, where despite achieving good results he was never really welcome because of the attitude of many fans and his northern pedigree.

Make no mistake about it, Allardyce is a good enough manager to keep this Sunderland team in the Premier League. But why he would want the challenge is questionable, and his reputation could take a hit if somehow the Black Cats do get relegated.

So while this appointment was a no-brainer for Sunderland, did it make sense for Allardyce himself? I really don’t think it does, but he certainly will make the best of the situation. That’s what good, resourceful and pragmatic managers do, and Big Sam is certainly all of those things.

200+ Channels With Sports & News
  • Starting price: $33/mo. for fubo Latino Package
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup, Euro 2024 & more
  • Includes NBC, USA, FOX, ESPN, CBSSN & more
Live & On Demand TV Streaming
  • Price: $69.99/mo. for Entertainment package
  • Watch World Cup, Euro 2024 & MLS
  • Includes ESPN, ESPN2, FS1 + local channels
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
  • Price: $6.99/mo. (or get ESPN+, Hulu & Disney+ for $13.99/mo.)
  • Features Bundesliga, LaLiga, Championship, & more
  • Also includes daily ESPN FC news & highlights show
2,000+ soccer games per year
  • Price: $4.99/mo
  • Features Champions League, Serie A, Europa League & NWSL
  • Includes CBS, Star Trek & CBS Sports HQ
175 Premier League Games & PL TV
  • Starting price: $4.99/mo. for Peacock Premium
  • Watch 175 exclusive EPL games per season
  • Includes Premier League TV channel plus movies, TV shows & more


  1. Black Wizard

    October 11, 2015 at 2:20 pm

    This really is a boring–though understandable–hire.

    The real problem is that the Premier League is facing the crisis both the NBA and the NFL faced in the late 1990s–early 2000s: clubs are still in that period of reluctance regarding hiring new and diverse talent. Until the NBA started hiring recently retired players as coaches and the NFL implemented the Rooney Rule, both were in this holding pattern of hiring retreads who failed elsewhere. Doug Collins and Mike Fratello were up for every job despite their lackluster records in the NBA; the old boy network dominated the NFL.

    Premier League clubs need to learn that lesson, and there are signs of its success (such as Gary Monk at Swansea). To hire Allardyce with no apparent attempts to talk to guys such Patrick Vieira or (even better) Jimmy Floyd Hasselbaink is just absurd.

  2. Brn442

    October 10, 2015 at 3:00 pm

    Why this man keeps getting jobs at top flight clubs is beyond me. He is surely capable of getting the out of immediate danger but beyond that?

    If Sunderland aspires to be an ambitionless Premier League back stop then Big Sam is their guy.

  3. The Cat

    October 10, 2015 at 2:23 pm

    Actually, I think the appointment of Allardyce does not make sense for Sunderland. West Ham fans have told me of their frustrations with Allardyce’s tactical approach which often comprised taking a one goal lead and then sitting back to protect that league. With Sunderland’s poor defence that approach will not work. Many Sunderland fans are saying “Sam will sort the defence out”. But how? He can’t magically make poor players better or old players young again. He can’t fix the defence until January when the transfer window re-opens.

    What Sunderland do have is an excellent front 5 or 6 (players such as Lens, Toivonen, Defoe, Borini, Whatmore, M’Vila). Under Dick Advocaat the midfield and forwards were looking better and better. A more sensible appointment would be someone like Nigel Pearson who would set up a team to go for the jugular from the outset.

    The appointment of Sam Allardyce also marks a sharp departure from the more continental model of club structure that Sunderland have been trying to implement for the last few years. Although this struggled initially it was just beginning bear fruit with the signings of many of the forward and midfield players I’ve listed above. Now it has been prematurely dismantled.

    Sunderland are the biggest club that Allardyce has managed so it is a great move for him. Just not vice versa.

  4. Michael

    October 10, 2015 at 12:06 pm

    Why would he not want to take the job? He was out of work and he has enough time to change Sunderland to keep the club up. He also signed a short term contract which is perfect for both sides.

  5. trickybrkn

    October 10, 2015 at 11:44 am

    Sam will like living in the North… He’ll pick up Kevin Nolan, be able to play his sort of football with an audience of supporters that will be content for the hoof and chase.
    That never happened in London… Even when Sam kept the team up and out of financial crisis the support of a London club will never buy into knuckle dragging football.

    If anything this is Fat Sam’s dream job, he is clearly not a top club manager, no top player would stay with a manager with his tactics… Sam is a keep a team up, scratch out a big win now and then sort of manager…

    All the best to Sunderland, and to Sam .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More in Leagues: EPL

Translate »