Connect with us


Messi the Greatest of All Time? The debate is pointless


Jerome Boateng had barely got back on his feet after Lionel Messi’s sublime second goal before the instant-pundits of the social media world were declaring the ‘debate over’ regarding Lionel Messi.

There are of course two debates about Messi. Is he the greatest player of the modern era? In other words, the Messi vs. Ronaldo debate. Then there is the ‘Greatest of All Time’ debate. Otherwise known as Messi vs. Pele/Maradona.

I’ll never tire of watching Messi play like he did in Wednesday’s Champions League semi-final but I am certainly weary of these endless debates which are without end simply because there really is no way to answer them.

There is no player that compares to Messi when it comes to tight control, his movement in tight spaces and his ability to exploit the slightest opening to score. But, then again, I’ve never seen a player attack on the break with such speed and yet still maintain total command of the ball like Cristiano Ronaldo. Both are great dribblers, but in very different ways. Both are a joy to watch when they are at their best – Messi wriggling out of tight-marking to make a goal out of nothing, Ronaldo when he is in full-flight, bursting forward, terrifying a back pedaling defense.

Spare me any discussion of these two that focuses on statistics. The numbers for both players are remarkable but reduce the two players to goal scorers when they are so much more. Which one would you rather have on your team? It rather depends on your team, doesn’t it? What league do they play in? In a slower-paced but more technical league, such as Spain or Italy, Messi would get the nod. In the higher-paced, more physical leagues, such as England and Germany, Cristiano might be more effective over the course of a season.

Messi carried Argentina at times during the World Cup, even though his performances were below his own high-standards. Ronaldo’s Portugal failed to get out of the group stage. But, for the sake of argument, how would you defend an Argentine strike force of Sergio Aguero, Carlos Tevez and Cristiano Ronaldo?

But if it is hard to definitively, without any reasonable doubt, name Messi the undisputed best player of the modern era, it is even more difficult to place him as the Greatest Of All Time.

The reason is simple. It is impossible to compare players of different eras in a game that has changed so much over the years.

Ferenc Puskas and Alfredo Di Stefano played in an era when the game was played at a tempo unrecognizably slower than in the modern era. Does that make them any less great?

Whenever anyone offers a strident opinion on Pele vs. Maradona, I have one question for them. How many Santos games have you watched? Or for that matter how many Napoli games during the seasons when Maradona led them to glory? If most of us are honest, our memories or knowledge of those two players are gleaned from special moments in World Cup finals.

If someone says no-one else could have scored a goal like Messi’s second on Wednesday, I’d suggest they go and watch some YouTube clips of Roberto Baggio, who was a master of leaving defenders on their backsides with a subtle body swerve.

How many times, in the context of this debate, have you heard people say ‘Messi needs to win a World Cup?’ But what a player has won should not come into the debate over individual geniuses. Nor does the quality of their team-mates. The suggestion that Messi needs to be downgraded because for years he was served by the quality of Xavi and Iniesta can certainly be jettisoned after last night.

And does the G.O.A.T. (Greatest Of All Time) have to be a forward? If not, then Franz Beckenbauer surely comes into the discussion. If you are looking for players close to perfection in their position, then you would have to be a severe critic to find fault with Paolo Maldini – not that a left-back is every going to be considered the all-time greatest in the game.

Do you spot a slight bias towards Italian players here? Well, yes, I watched plenty of Baggio and Maldini at their prime. Perhaps I mention Puskas because I lived in Hungary where there is virtually a cult around that player. Would a Dutchman throw Cruyff into the discussion? A Frenchman mention Platini or Fontaine in their list of the best? Very probably.

The candidates vary according to where you ask the question. The BBC on Thursday put together five possible players to vote for, which included George Best. As wonderful as Best was, he would be unlikely to get in the top-ten in many other countries.

We view the history of the game through our own national experiences. Or at least we did until the modern-era, where we can watch the Spanish league every weekend and where we all watched Messi on Wednesday. It is worth remembering that in the 1970’s and even into the 1980’s most of Europe just watched the European Cup and UEFA Cup games of their own nation’s teams.

So, here is a little suggestion. The next time Messi or Ronaldo produce a breathtaking goal and someone on Twitter suggests the ‘debate is over’, head over to YouTube and spend ten minutes watching goals from Maradona, Cruyff, Pele, Puskas, Baggio, Eusebio, Di Stefano and so on.

There have been plenty of geniuses in this game. There is a rich history of wonderful talent, from many countries and many eras. Messi is part of that rich history and we can enjoy his talent without the need for pointless comparisons.

Editor’s note: Every Thursday, World Soccer Talk featured columnist Simon Evans shares his thoughts and opinions on world soccer topics. You can follow Simon on Twitter at @sgevans. Plus, read Simon’s other columns for World Soccer Talk.


200+ Channels With Sports & News
  • Starting price: $33/mo. for fubo Latino Package
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup, Euro 2024 & more
Live & On Demand TV Streaming
  • Price: $35/mo. for Sling Blue
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup & MLS
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
  • Price: $9.99/mo. (or get ESPN+, Hulu & Disney+ for $13.99/mo.)
  • Features Bundesliga, LaLiga, Championship, & more
2,000+ soccer games per year
  • Price: $4.99/mo
  • Features Champions League, Serie A, Europa League & NWSL
175 Premier League Games & PL TV
  • Starting price: $4.99/mo. for Peacock Premium
  • Watch 175 exclusive EPL games per season
110+ channels, live & on-demand
  • Price: $59.95/mo. for Plus Package
  • Includes FOX, FS1, ESPN, TUDN & more



  1. خرید فیلتر شکن کریو

    May 8, 2015 at 4:24 pm

    oh man tnx for this
    iloveeeeee mesi

  2. Fred the Red

    May 8, 2015 at 9:00 am

    Can’t believe anyone can question his greatness. Scoring 90+ goals in a calendar year, scoring in 21 STRAIGHT games in La Lia, scoring in 2 consecutive Champions league finals appearances etc.
    Best, Charlton, Maradona, Pele, would kill to have the seasons he’s had.
    How many times did Baggio score goals like Leo?
    When he does it it’s not seen as brilliant anymore but customary. I bet you if he won the world cup he’d be deified. Goals aren’t everything but he’s scored 400+ professional goals. He’s on course to shatter every record in Europe. He’s already the all time leading goalscorer at Barcelona age 27 and he broke it when he was 25.
    Messi is the best player of all time.

  3. B

    May 8, 2015 at 7:31 am

    Let’s look at the comparable and measurable metrics for CRon since his move to Real and Messi over that same period of time and apply general scoring to develop a comparative player score…

    La Liga (League)
    Appearance: CRon = 197, Messi = 203
    Goals: CRon = 219 (1.11 gpg), Messi = 229 (1.13 gpg)
    Assists: CRon = 63 (.32 apg), Messi = 84 (.41 apg)
    Scoring: CRon (1.11*3)+(.32) = 3.65, Messi (1.13*3)+(.41) = 3.80

    Champions League
    Appearance: CRon = 62, Messi = 64
    Goals: CRon = 61 (.98 gpg), Messi = 60 (.94 gpg)
    Assists: CRon = 15 (.24 apg), Messi = 16 (.25 apg)
    Scoring: CRon (.98*3)+(.24) = 3.18, Messi (.94*3)+(.25) = 3.07

    Other Comps (League Cups, International Club Cups)
    Appearance: CRon = 37, Messi = 48
    Goals: CRon = 26 (.70 gpg), Messi = 38 (.79 gpg)
    Assists: CRon = 5 (.14 apg), Messi = 20 (.42 apg)
    Scoring: CRon (.70*3)+(.14) = 2.24, Messi (.79*3)+(.42) = 2.79

    All Comps
    Appearance: CRon = 296, Messi = 315
    Goals: CRon = 306 (1.03 gpg), Messi = 327 (1.04 gpg)
    Assists: CRon = 83 (.28 apg), Messi = 120 (.38 apg)
    Scoring: CRon (1.03*3)+(.28) = 3.37, Messi (1.04*3)+(.38) = 3.50

  4. Gbenga

    May 8, 2015 at 1:33 am

    Let us be sincere on the issue of where Messi can play his football, whether in England or Germany or Italy or France, Messi won’t fail in any league. D fact is that what is actually needed in all those leaques are loaded in Messi. In England, speed is needed and Messi has it even more than Hazard, EPL best, Messi can dribble beta than Hazard which is not common in England and if Hazard can thrive in England, Messi will be a more blessing to that EPL. If u are talking of passing ability, Messi is d king there bcos he has d most dangerous passing far beta than other players and his assists record is there for u to see. Messi don’t dive and don’t fall anyhow. He does not need to move out to another league to confirm his supremacy, he is d best.

    • B

      May 8, 2015 at 7:34 am

      We don’t have a relative comparison of Messi in the EPL, but we have plenty of comparative data of Messi and CRon playing in the same league together and carrying representative league, league cup and European league competition schedules…

  5. Smokey Bacon

    May 7, 2015 at 6:31 pm

    Unlike Messi, Ronaldo also did it on a Monday night at Stoke in January. That’s the only barometer that matters in the Messi versus Ronaldo debate. Messi is not suited to the EPL.

    • Fred the Red

      May 8, 2015 at 8:33 am

      But Messi has beaten the past 3 Barclays premier league Champions.
      If he’s suited to beating Manchester United, Chelsea, Manchester City and Arsenal then what about Stoke on wet rainy day will have him quaking in his boots?
      If he can beat the best teams in the EPL containing Ronaldo, Vidic, Evra, Terry, Drogba, Fabregas, Kompany, etc. why would he not be suited to the EPL.
      When Messi put Boateng one of the best center halfs in Europe this season on his back side then what would he have to fear in inferior premier league defenders?
      Bayern’s team was filled with big players EPL size players Muller, Neuer, Schweinsteiger, Lewandowski Boateng, Benatia etc. Yet he still scored two and set up 2.
      Physical ability in the modern game is far overrated. Strength doesn’t matter if you can’t read the game properly or touch Messi.

  6. StellaWasAlwaysDown

    May 7, 2015 at 2:50 pm

    It’s so hard to have these debates, but if you have to have the conversation, then the teams around them have to be considered. I truly think this is an important item with any player. There’s no question that they are great players, but what if they didn’t have $200 million worth of players surrounding them year in and year out?

    • Fred the Red

      May 8, 2015 at 8:41 am

      How many times has Messi dribbled past 5-6 players and scored a goal out of nothing?
      Your point makes no sense. He doesn’t need Xavi, Iniesta, Neymar, Suarez, etc. to shine.
      We’ve seen him create goals himself regardless of his teammates. Are you telling me that he relies on others to set him up?
      Ronaldo and Messi are the only players of this and past generations scoring 50+ goals on a regular. A 41 goal season was seen as sub par for Messi mind you.
      He’d bang them in playing for QPR, Valencia, Lyon etc.

  7. goatslookshifty

    May 7, 2015 at 1:52 pm

    Good article and can’t disagree with hardly any of it. I’d imagine there is a contingent of Brazilians who are already preparing the Neymar Jr argument. Ask my dad and he’d say Bobby Charlton because he grew up watching him, so your point is dead on. I’d give the edge to Ronaldo over Messi simply on the tiebreaker he was both superior in the EPL and La Liga.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More in Barcelona

Translate »