Connect with us

Leagues: MLS

What Has Gone Wrong with DC United? : League Staple in the Cellar

Clyde Simms is in my mind, one of the most underrated defensive midfielders in MLS. Until his recent injury problems, he was something of an iron man for DC United, appearing in nearly every fixture. He covers a lot of ground and is a workhorse in the midfield. He was also a key distribution point, building up from the back. Simms has a pretty good long range shot as well.

Ben Olsen is missed is so many ways. First and foremost, he was an inspirational leader on and off the pitch. Olsen for a long time had been an integral part of the club’s locker room chemistry.

On the pitch, age and severe ankle problems took away some of his pace and cutting ability, Olsen still had a lot offer. As mentioned, he no longer had the same speed. This forced a move from his spot on the wing to a role as a holding midfielder.

Olsen excelled at this new position. Playing inside now and alongside the roaming Clyde Simms, Olsen was able to use his intellgence and soccer IQ to help the team. The US National Team veteran played gritty and was key in breaking down opponent’s enterprising moves forward. He was also still very good in link up play.

Having these two in front of the backline helped clog up the midfield, limiting the space opposing teams had to work with. They also contributed to what was a very solid passing midfield.

Moving on to the attack minded players, United lost two of their more creative players this offseason, Fred and Christian Gomez.

Fred was an interesting talent. Personally, I think he had perhaps the best ball control on the team. He’s clearly skilled with the ball at his feet. However, he was plagued by poor finishing.

I can recall countless times when the Brazilian winger / playmaker completely missed a wide open net after being fed in nicely by teammates. With that being said, Fred did provide some of the better service on the team and he always had to be accounted for by the opposing team.

United were at their best the last several years when Gomez (or briefly Marcelo Gallardo) was at the top of his game. United had guys who could put the ball in the back of the net, but Gomez gave them someone who could find his teammate’s through a narrow window and unlock the defense.

One of the things that made Gomez so good at setting up teammates, was that he was not afraid to push forward and create his own shot. At times, it actually seemed as though he looked shot first. Needless to say, I feel he is a player who made others around him better by putting them on in the right positions.

This current United team lacks that. Yes, they have tried to play with a pair of two way players in the center of midfield, as opposed to using a more tradional playmaker. In either formation, you still want a key creative talent in the middle.

While Santino Quaranta is very capable at doing a decent job and perhaps eventually excelling there, I still think that the right wing is his best spot. It’s also clear that United misses something by his abscence there.  In fact, while the club has yet to find a solution to their problem, they have played more inspired since sliding Quaranta back out wide and inserting Jaime Moreno in the middle.

Moreno plays well in that creative role, essentially guiding the flow of the attack. The Bolivian MLS legend also seems to partner well with Aussiee striker, Danny Allsopp.  Having Moreno on the pitch instantly raises United’s soccer IQ on the pitch.  However, because of his age, it’s a delicate balancing act managing his minutes.   

Looking at the rest of the midfield and striking corps, I feel that last year’s rookie if the year contender, Chris Pontius, is better suited to playing on the wing as well. Last season, Pontius was sort of a jack of all trades, playing all over the midfield and as a striker.  This year, Curt Onalfo initially elected to start Pontius as the lead striker. The early returns seem to show it’s not the best place to deploy him.

It’s still open for debate whether it’s better to have him move around the pitch or stay at one position, both for the club and Pontius’s development as a player.  Does United and Pontius benefit more by having him polish the versatility he’s capable of or by having him really sharpen his skills at one spot.   Perhaps he will find some time on the wing with Salvadoran playmaker Cristian Castillo struggling with his form.

Castillo has incredible skill on the ball, yet has struggled to make an impact with United. His ball control even overshadows the ability of the aforementioned Fred.  Something that also might be a benefit to both him andhe club is his passing ability. Castillo has a tendency to rely on flashy moves and tries to make the razzle dazzle play, instead of making the simple passes that may be more needed.  When he’s focused on linking up fluidly with teammates rather than making the highlight reel, Castillo can be a deadly component to the attack.   

Castillo, who has brought large throngs of Salvadoran fans to RFK Stadium is simply too talented stay playing at this current level. He is also going through a period of adjustment.

All this midfield attacking talk leads us to the point of the spear, the players called upon to put on the (literally) finishing touches. DC United parted ways with their leading goal scorer over the past three seasons, Luciano Emilio.

Emilio had seen his productivity drop over each year and the club felt he was being overpaid for what he was producing. While that may be the case, they clearly have a void to fill. Emilio wasn’t a perfect finisher, but he wasn’t afraid to shoot when he had an opening.

That seems to be one of the key problems facing United so far this season. The offense has displayed an ability to get into the attacking third, (even in the 4 – 0 smashing by KC) but has not been able to get off quality shots on goal.

If you think about it, DC United has let go two recent MLS MVP’s, players who were crucial to the club’s ability to score goals. They lost a creative talent who had been with the team for several seasons in Fred and lost franchise staple Ben Olsen to retirement.

You throw in key injuries and you see a team that has a gutted core. A core that perhaps has needed some youthful change for a while.

All this while going through a coaching switch and a change in philosophy on the pitch. MLS does prescribe to a recipe for parity. However, even in this environment, such a vast amount of change doesn’t come without it’s rebuilding and adjustment time. The evidence is on the pitch.

DCU does have some good young talent developing, including 17 year old midfielder Andy Najar. The growth of players such as him, Pontius and Wallace is crucial to the club returning to their former glories.

200+ Channels With Sports & News
  • Starting price: $33/mo. for fubo Latino Package
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup, Euro 2024 & more
Live & On Demand TV Streaming
  • Price: $35/mo. for Sling Blue
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup & MLS
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
  • Price: $9.99/mo. (or get ESPN+, Hulu & Disney+ for $13.99/mo.)
  • Features Bundesliga, LaLiga, Championship, & more
2,000+ soccer games per year
  • Price: $4.99/mo
  • Features Champions League, Serie A, Europa League & NWSL
175 Premier League Games & PL TV
  • Starting price: $4.99/mo. for Peacock Premium
  • Watch 175 exclusive EPL games per season
110+ channels, live & on-demand
  • Price: $59.95/mo. for Plus Package
  • Includes FOX, FS1, ESPN, TUDN & more

Pages: 1 2



  1. louis vuitton

    August 30, 2010 at 4:40 am

    hey,this is one of the best posts that I’ve ever seen; you may include some more ideas in the same theme. I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post.

  2. jeff fleishman

    April 30, 2010 at 6:32 pm

    Nice work on a thoughtful analysis of the interrelated elements that comprise success on the pitch. As a successful championship coach at the Mens amateur first division level here in the Metro Washington area I had the blessing of four players in the defense and two in the midfield that held the team together from 1988 to 1998. I learned that It required a beginning roster of 24 players to field 14 viable players by seasons end. So the vulnerabilities of these maturing athletes lead to constant shuffling in the positioning of players; yet we maintained a winning chemistry through having those core guys who new and loved each other.
    Your article demonstrated a keen eye for soccer reporting. Keep up the good work as you answered the central question I was looking to have answered when I Googled – DC United Problems?

  3. Chris Webb

    April 27, 2010 at 7:29 pm


    Shoot me an e-mail. Want to see if you would like to come on the show this Sunday evening..

  4. Chris Riordan

    April 27, 2010 at 3:11 pm

    Cavan, you’re feeling my sentiments exactly. Every team that recharges or replaces their core experiences this. This also wouldn’t be DCU’s first time going through such a process.

  5. Cavan

    April 27, 2010 at 2:32 pm

    Solid roster analysis.

    United went through the wilderness back in the early 2000’s. They had a great core in the middle of the decade that won an MLS Cup and two Supporter Shields. They’ll be back. This year is about reconfiguring the core. They’ll start to look better in the last two months of the season but miss the playoffs. Next year you’ll see a more coherent team.

    It happens to every MLS team. The Revs are going through a similar process as are the Dynamo. The Galaxy went through the woods in 2006-2008. The fire wmet through the woods in 2004. United will be back. They’re finally cleaning up and restartim from the 2008 roster debacle.

  6. Luis

    April 27, 2010 at 12:09 pm

    I think that also we need to remember the amount of teams that are in the MLS now compared to when DC was winning consistently. It is much more difficult in my opinion to stay competitive in a league of 16 teams than a league of 10 teams. With this logic, DC is going to have even a tougher time next year as the team expands to 18 teams.

  7. Charles

    April 27, 2010 at 11:54 am

    BTW, appreciate the article. I do think there is an EPL attitude sometimes.

    DC will win, team x will always lose. However, this is the US, even the Saints win a SuperBowl sometimes.

    When DC lost in the US Open Cup last year, that was not some massive FA Cup upset, Seattle had a better team last year. Something you never would bother to say in the EPL…”better luck next year”

  8. Charles

    April 27, 2010 at 11:46 am

    You can call DC a cornerstone of MLS, but if it is MLS is in trouble. They have won four MLS Cups and still have average MLS support, which isn’t great and not growing at all. For those that support DC that is not a slam on you, but there is very little support in the city.

    There are four corners to every building and currently the pacific northwest seems to be the one that MLS will rely on to grow the building bigger.

    Secondly, this is a parity league, just because the team is named United doesn’t mean that MLS will be the joke of the EPL and have you win every year. Down years are part of the gig. Rebuild and come back strong.

  9. CTBlues

    April 27, 2010 at 9:04 am

    Move to the Rent in Hartford!

  10. Chris Riordan

    April 27, 2010 at 8:16 am

    FF, I’m sorry that you feel this way. It took me a while to write this, so you can imagine how it feels to know it wasn’t appreciated.

    You’re entitled to your opinion. It’s good to have feedback either way.

    I tried to tell United’s recent story of core change, while leaving their problems between the lines. As for Onalfo, I’ll get to him later.

    I’ll try to make sure I stay on point more in the future.

  11. F.F.

    April 27, 2010 at 1:54 am

    Seldom have I read so much that said so little.

    Oh, and you never actually got to Onalfo (or for that matter Kaspar and Payne) — you know, the guys who, as you say, are supposed to put all these pieces together, but who have actually failed miserably to build an effective MLS team.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More in Leagues: MLS

Translate »