Connect with us

Copa America

Grading the US Players at Copa America and the Gold Cup

Grading the US Squad at the Gold Cup and Copa America

The inexperienced side Coach Bob Bradley took to Copa America contrasted directly with the experienced “A” side that Bradley took to the Gold Cup. Despite lifting the Champions Trophy at the Gold Cup, the campaign was far from flawless, and in spite of an embarrassing last place finish at the Copa, the event did shed some positive light on certain us players. My player by player review follows.


Tim Howard (Everton, ENG)

Howard was solid between the posts and made some key saves in the final versus Mexico. He is clearly the new US #1

Grade: B +

Kasey Keller (No current club)

Keller is a legend of American football, but his instincts and skills have clearly diminished. In the Gold Cup semifinal he had trouble organizing the back four and was clearly on a different page than Oguchi Onyewu. During the Copa America, Keller made repeated mistakes either coming off his line too quickly, or misreading the flow of play. Thank you for a job well done, including four world cups and it’s now time to retire from international football.

Grade: D

Brad Guzan (Chivas USA )

Guzan is a very average keeper by any standard and it is a bit perplexing that for all these years US Soccer has been so high on him. Beaten out by thirty something journeyman Preston Burpo with Chivas USA last season, he regained his first team spot this year with some solid early season play. In his one Copa appearance he made some nice saves but also committed a shocking foul in the box conceding a penalty when he came storming off his line. Of course he saved the PK. Guzan is an average keeper who turned an average performance versus Columbia .

Grade: C


Oguchi Onyewu (Standard Liege , Belgium )

Onyewu’s poor positioning and propensity to commit silly fouls was shocking in the Gold Cup. However, as usual he turned in a good performance marking Jared Borgetti and the rest of Mexico ’s physical attacking players in the final.

Grade: C-

Carlos Bocanegra (Fulham, ENG)

Simply because Bocanegra scores goals for both Fulham and US off set pieces does not mean he is an adequate center back. The new US captain seemed to be chronically mis-positioned and still has not learned not to play back passes into the area when under pressure. Bocanegra’s shocking pass to Onyewu cost the US’ the match against Ghana last summer in Germany and despite a solid year at Fulham, Bocanegra still seems a bit slow reading the game at this level. Nonetheless, he is a fiery player and if he is on the pitch he is a decent choice as captain.

Grade: C-

Jay Demerit ( Watford , ENG)

Demerit has proven himself through this summer, in spite of a few errors to be the best US center back. During an otherwise forgettable Copa campaign he was probably the most consistent American defender despite a bad stomach virus. He also gave a much needed lift in the first group match of Gold Cup when he shut down Carlos Ruiz when the rest of the US defense had lost its composure. DeMerit also seemed to be the only sure tackler in the entire US squad during Copa.

Grade: B+

Jimmy Conrad ( Kansas City Wizards, USA )

A very indifferent Copa for Conrad. He made some nice reads of the game but also mis-communicated with Kasey Keller a few times and failed to react to Jonathan Bornstein’s now infamous back pass versus Paraguay . Conrad is a sold squad rotation player for national team but cannot be counted on as a regular player.

Grade: C

Danny Califf (AoB, DEN)

It was nice to see Califf return to the international scene after he had been forgotten by former Coach Bruce Arena because he had the audacity to try and improve himself by moving to Europe to play football . Califf played well and should remain in the national team picture.

Grade: B

Frankie Hejduk ( Columbus Crew, USA )

It’s hard to believe in 2007 that Frankie Hejduk is quite possibly still the best US defender. I believed by this time Hejduk famous pace would no longer be as much of a factor nor would his physical play. Sure his skills have diminished since his excellent run at Bayer Leverkusen in the late 1990s, but he’s still a keeper. Can he make the 2010 World Cup squad at 36? Well, at this rate we may have no choice but to find a role for him because he seems to be a valuable ingredient to every success the US has achieved over the past ten years.

Grade: A

Frank Simek ( Sheffield Wednesday, ENG)

Simek is developing nicely for the US National team and he showed some great flashes in the Gold Cup. He must work on his ball skills down the right side however if he is to be a viable long term option at right back

Grade: B-

Michael Parkhurst (New England Revolution, USA )

I was under the impression Parkhurst was called up just to avoid Ireland from capping him in the near future. However Parkhurst played twice in the Gold Cup and positioned himself well and also picked the proper times to push forward.

Grade: B

Jonathan Specter (West Ham United, ENG)

Specter has loads of talent but Bradley is still trying to figure out where to play him. Nonetheless, he seems to be an important factor going forward towards WC 2010 qualifying.

Grade: C

Jonathan Bornstein (Chivas USA, USA)

Bornstein is really a mixed bag. First off I do not believe he posses the man marking skills to be a defender at this level. Sure he did a nice job on Lionel Messi, but he all too often pushes forward and gets caught napping when in the attack. Nonetheless, his ball skills and well timed runs compliment the US attack. If not for the glut of talent at the left wide midfield position, Bornstein could play there.

Grade: C

Heath Pearce (FC Nordsjælland, DEN)

The self proclaimed best American left back showed zilch in the match versus Columbia at Copa America and got caught too far up the pitch in several situations.

Grade: D

Bobby Boswell (DC United, USA)

Did well in his one match of the summer, the meaningless final game of Copa America against Columbia.

Grade: B-

Drew Moor (FC Dallas, USA)

Moor will be forever remembered for his missed header that could have leveled the match versus Paraguay late in the 2nd half. However, that is hardly fair considering Moor looked more seasoned than defenders with far more international experience for the US. He picked the right spots to push up and generally was solid as a man marker.

Grade: B

Marvell Wynne (Toronto FC, CAN)

Did alright versus Argentina until the entire squad collapsed late in the match. Should get another call up soon.

Grade C+


Michael Bradley (Heerenveen, HOL)

Calm composure beyond his years, Bradley was one of the standout players of the Gold Cup. He doesn’t get an A grade however due to his clumsy challenge late in the semifinal versus Canada and his subsequent sending off.

Grade: B+

Ricardo Clark (Houston Dynamo, USA)

Clark was the ironman of the summer for the US, playing in eight matches, and providing both an offensive spark and regular ball winning at the back. He looked spent against Argentina after being a difference maker in the Gold Cup Final victory, but bounced back for a Man of the Match caliber performance versus Paraguay. Was quite possibly the only US player who appeared to care for the first 45 minutes versus Columbia.

Grade: A

Benny Feilhaber (HSV, G

Feilhaber provided the winning strike versus Mexico and some class versus Argentina. He’s the logical replacement for John O’Brien with the national team, but my bone to pick with Feilhaber is that he often times gave the possession away far too cheaply.

Grade B-

Landon Donovan (LA Galaxy, USA)

Looked more comfortable than would be expected out wide on the right flank. As usual he drifted in and out of games, but was tremendous as always against Mexico. Donovan inspite of constant criticism is perhaps the best footballer this nation has ever produced so I am guilty of holding him to a higher standard than everyone else in the current player pool.

Grade: B

DeMarcus Beasley (Rangers, SCO)

Beasley’s shocking miss against Mexico could have cost the US the Gold Cup title. Otherwise Beasley seemed to regain his mojo so to speak on the left side of midfield and he once again showed a great understanding of the system Bob Bradley is playing and of his role in the system.

Grade: B

200+ Channels With Sports & News
  • Starting price: $33/mo. for fubo Latino Package
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup, Euro 2024 & more
  • Includes NBC, USA, FOX, ESPN, CBSSN & more
Live & On Demand TV Streaming
  • Price: $35/mo. for Sling Blue
  • Watch Premier League, World Cup & MLS
  • Includes USA, NBC, FOX, FS1 + more
Many Sports & ESPN Originals
  • Price: $6.99/mo. (or get ESPN+, Hulu & Disney+ for $13.99/mo.)
  • Features Bundesliga, LaLiga, Championship, & more
  • Also includes daily ESPN FC news & highlights show
2,000+ soccer games per year
  • Price: $4.99/mo
  • Features Champions League, Serie A, Europa League & NWSL
  • Includes CBS, Star Trek & CBS Sports HQ
175 Premier League Games & PL TV
  • Starting price: $4.99/mo. for Peacock Premium
  • Watch 175 exclusive EPL games per season
  • Includes Premier League TV channel plus movies, TV shows & more

Pages: 1 2



  1. Sams Army

    July 11, 2007 at 10:05 am

    No, I agree with Kartik on Hejduk. He’s a useful player and it seems as he mentioned the US always plays better when he’s in the lineup. He isn’t a glory type player, but quite honestly he is an important cog in everything good we seem to do. Regarding Olsen, it’s hindsight that he was great. I think the fact he got pulled for Gaven has us thinking he was better than he was, but in reality he’d be a regular if he wasn’t always injured.

  2. Anonymous

    July 10, 2007 at 10:05 pm

    I would have given both Boca and Gooch an F. They were as bad if not worse than Twellman. Don’t kid yourself. Both were constantly out of position and played foolish back passes and bad balls forward.

  3. MJ

    July 10, 2007 at 4:50 pm

    Agreed with that last comment. Hejduk gets an A and is the “best US defender”?? Ridiculous. Bocanegra and Onyewu getting the same grade? No. Bocanegra played much better than Onyewu.

    Spector, with an -o, not an -e.
    DaMarcus, with an -a, not an -e. How many times do I have to tell you that??

  4. Anonymous

    July 10, 2007 at 3:41 pm

    Hedjuk and Olsen an A, but Donovan a B? Are you nuts?

  5. USA2010

    July 10, 2007 at 1:39 pm

    And that’s why he was fired.

  6. Bring Back Arena

    July 10, 2007 at 10:03 am

    Arena would have declined the invitation and would have spared us the embarrasment of the Copa.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

More in Copa America

Translate »