Why Manchester United Would Be Better Off Not Qualifying for the Europa League

Even the most optimistic of Manchester United supporters would admit that UEFA Champions League qualification through the Premier League is out of reach this season. So naturally, Manchester United should target UEFA’s secondary European competition, the Europa League. I have to confess, I’m not a fan of this tournament. And the more I bring this topic up, the more I find that a lot of soccer fans agree with me.

The Europa League hasn’t always been like this. Having provided some great moments for Europe’s most prominent teams including Bayern Munich, Real Madrid, Juventus and United’s great rivals Liverpool, the Europa League was at one point a genuinely coveted trophy. All of which makes its recent fall in status even more glaring. Since the Europa League is played on Thursday nights for television purposes, many clubs see it as more of a hindrance to league form than a worthwhile competition. The matches have often featured under-strength line-ups and youth players, turning a once prestigious tournament into glorified friendlies. Worse yet, it has turned into an absolute death knell for Europe’s coaches.

Of the 48 teams taking part in this year’s group phase, an astonishing 19 of them have undergone a change in manager since the first round of games that were played in September last year. This includes all three English clubs (Wigan, Tottenham and Swansea) as well as long-time big hitters Valencia and Lazio. Whilst some of those clubs (notably Anzhi) were due to other factors, the fact remains that almost 40% of participating clubs now have a different manager from when the competition started.

It is the fates of Andre Villas-Boas and Michael Laudrup that have received the most attention in the UK. Whilst nobody knows what would have happened had they not been playing on Thursday nights, Manchester United manager David Moyes needs to look no further than the other end of the East Lancs Road for evidence of what not qualifying can do for you. After missing out due to league position last year, Liverpool have undergone a dramatic transformation in fortune. Brendan Rodgers found managing an assault on both domestic and European fronts too much for his team last year, which resulted in a seventh place finish in the league. The finish also resulted in a real fight to keep his star striker Luis Suarez at the club last summer. This year, solely focused on the Premier League and powered by Suarez and strike partner Daniel Sturridge. Liverpool find themselves at the top of the Premier League table entering April, along with boasting the most prolific attack in the division.

David Moyes has found himself under severe pressure in his first season in the job. Saturday’s fan protest banner, whilst seemingly having had the opposite effect to their intentions, does underline a growing feeling among supporters that Alex Ferguson may have got this one wrong. Talk of a hefty summer spending spree to rebuild United’s ageing defense and faltering midfield is common. Should David Moyes be the man trusted with the rumored warchest, he may well appreciate a chance to build his new side away from the European spotlight. The Scotsman would be unlikely to survive a second season like the current one, particularly at a club like Manchester United. It will also likely prove hard enough embedding six or seven new signings into the squad. It is a difficult endeavor and that’s without having to traipse his team to the other side of Europe every Thursday night.

Whether or not David Moyes keeps his job this summer could well depend on the availability of names such as Jurgen Klopp and Diego Simeone. But if David Moyes does remain in his role, it is likely to be the most important summer transfer window in the clubs rich history. The Sunday Telegraph newspaper this week suggested that up to £200 million will be available to spend. As important as recruiting new players will be, clearing the squad of highly paid under-motivated and under-performing players will be as important. Having to bolster a squad for a Europa League challenge would make this more difficult for the Manchester United manager.

Yes, the Europa League may provide a financial boost and a welcome distraction to the Premier League grind. Middlesbrough enjoyed a fantastic run that highlighted their season in 2006. Rangers also enjoyed a famous campaign that led to the final in 2008. However this is Manchester United. A club that demands success and fully believes that they should be looking to Europe’s grandest stage. The Europa League should be seen as an unwanted detour on the way back to the top.

For more Manchester United news, analysis and opinion, visit the Manchester United team page.

8 thoughts on “Why Manchester United Would Be Better Off Not Qualifying for the Europa League”

  1. it’s hard to disagree with this. Liverpool out of the CL in the past year has motivated them and it’s very clear in their play. If the MUFC side will be doing some cleaning out, then a year out of the CL would probably do them a world of good, giving them an opportunity to get new team members to gel without the added pressure of playing against top clubs with solid squads. They may miss some of the money but what good is playing for something out of reach when your squad is falling apart?

  2. The Europa League would provide some good experience for Man Utd’s fringe players. With a squad as large as Utd’s, many of the first team players could most likely bypass the tournament.
    I don’t particularly disagree with the article but there might be an upside to it.

  3. Beginning next season the winner of the Europa League gets into the Champions League the following season. So the Europa League has been made more relevant and important. Having two avenues to the Champions League is better than one.

  4. I think all this concern about the poor darlings playing Thursday night is nonsense. Next thing you know there’ll be mandatory seven day periods between all games to allow for some relaxation at a spa, have their nails done and get a hot seaweed wrap.

    If a player can’t play a Thursday and then a Saturday then he just isn’t fit.

  5. I see the downsides, but United also has a pretty deep squad. I know that they aren’t overflowing with excellence, but they’ve designed the squad to play 2x per week. I don’t see what it would hurt. It’s not like Rooney and Mata are going to be playing on Thursday night in Cyprus. What’s the harm of letting Welbeck and Cleverly get a start in Cyprus?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *