Reviewing Premier League Refereeing Decisions: Gameweek 31

By far the biggest talking point from the weekend’s soccer matches was the decision from referee Andre Marriner to send off the wrong player during Arsenal’s humiliating 6-0 defeat at the hands of Chelsea. Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain clearly saved a shot from Eden Hazard. Chelsea appealed to Andre Marriner who took a long time to award the penalty. To me, at this point, the ref was unsure who committed the handball, and if it actually was a handball in the first place. A red card was then brandished, which Arsenal can have no complaints about, even if the ball was not going into the net. A goal scoring opportunity was denied.

I was then astounded to see Kieran Gibbs walking down the tunnel. A clear mistaken identity error by Marriner, but he was not helped by any of his assistants or the fourth official. The whole stadium and the watching audience could tell it was Chamberlain who handled the ball, but in the heat of the moment, he made the wrong decision. Chamberlain then pleaded with the ref that it was him who committed the foul, but a red card decision can not be revoked once it has been awarded.

Arsenal have appealed against the red card for Gibbs and Chamberlain, but I fully expect the one match ban to be transferred to Chamberlain, who instinctively threw a hand at the ball.

I felt for Marriner, but his hesitation to award the penalty did not show any confidence in his decision, despite the lack of support from his assistants. He has apologized for the error and I am sure The FA will resolve the issue as soon as possible.

Everton’s Ross Barkley was awarded a penalty in the early stages of the Toffees 3-2 victory over Swansea City. A long ball forward from John Stones left Barkley one on one against Chico Flores, who stuck a leg out after the ball had past him. Barkley sensed the opportunity to go down and did so. Despite this, it was a penalty and referee Michael Oliver, who has been very consistent this season, had no hesitation pointing to the spot.

Chris Foy was scrutinized for his performance last week at Villa Park, and he was on arguably worse form on Saturday at the KC Stadium. Firstly, Shane Long was judged to be brought down by Craig Dawson. Foy had the perfect view of the incident, but there was minimal, if any, contact made. The linesman did not indicate that there was an infringement, but Foy pointed straight to the spot. West Brom fan’s have every right to be frustrated by the decision.

Pages 1 2


  1. Bergkamp_10 March 24, 2014
    • Aaron March 24, 2014
    • Brian March 24, 2014
      • Bergkamp_10 March 24, 2014
    • Balboa77 March 24, 2014
  2. Tony Butterworth March 24, 2014
  3. ThompsonLives March 24, 2014
    • Andy Turnbull March 25, 2014
  4. CTBlues March 25, 2014
  5. Andy Turnbull March 25, 2014
    • Pakapala March 26, 2014
  6. Dan March 29, 2014

Leave a Reply