Tom Cleverley: Manchester United’s Midfield Enigma

Manchester United supporters are at a disadvantage. They don’t get to see Tom Cleverley in training every day. Apparently Cleverley is one hell of a player on the training ground because Red Devils managers keep selecting the midfielder into United’s starting eleven; one of those managers being the legendary Sir Alex Ferguson. National team coach Roy Hodgson (who is assisted by former United defender Gary Neville) also sees something in the player because Cleverley has also found his way into England’s starting eleven.

What are these managers seeing that the average football fan isn’t?

First off, Cleverley is a nice footballer and would be a good addition to many teams in the Premier League. He can be tidy moving the ball side to side and…um?…if someone can point out other things he does well, please comment below.

Sarcasm aside, there was a time when Cleverley rapidly moved up the ranks at Manchester United. His ascent was slowed because Paul Scholes and Michael Carrick had cemented their places in Sir Alex Ferguson’s midfield. So Cleverley was initially loaned out; first to Leicester City, then Watford, and ultimately Wigan. The midfielder shined at each destination and was hailed as Manchester United’s “midfielder of the future”.

Beginning in 2009, Cleverley was used by England U-21s and eventually received an invitation to play in a friendly with the national team in August 2011. Coaches raved about him and his combination of maturity mixed with a youthful energy. Young midfield players have a tendency to go looking for the ball too often, desperate to get themselves involved, but Cleverley showed a maturity by pulling away to find little pockets of space in behind the opposing midfield. When he did receive the ball, he instantly looked forward for the next pass or pushed it into attacking areas. He was a player brimming with confidence and potential.

At the start of the 2011-12 Premier League season, Paul Scholes retired and Cleverley had finally secured his place on Manchester United’s squad. The midfielder impressed the fans and coaching staff during United’s preseason tour of the United States. He followed up those performances by playing a huge part in Manchester United’s come-from-behind victory over Manchester City during the Community Shield:

Cleverley then contributed to Manchester United’s opening three wins of the season; including an 8-2 rout of Arsenal at Old Trafford:

But in United’s fourth game of the season at Bolton, Cleverley suffered ligament damage to his foot after a hard tackle from Kevin Davies. The injury sidelined the midfielder for a month:

(The video quality is poor, but the tackle takes place just after the 30 second mark)

Cleverley returned for a League Cup match in October, but had to leave the following match against Everton in the 57th minute due to an ankle injury. That injury would take him out of the lineup until February 2012. Sir Alex Ferguson would eventually convince Paul Scholes to come out of retirement; a decision that thrusted United back into the title race. When Cleverley did return from injury, he wasn’t the same player and was dropped down the midfield pecking order. Whether this was due his fitness, a lack of confidence, or other circumstances; fans will never know.

Since that time and up until this point Cleverley hasn’t produced for Manchester United. His lack of progress is really under the spotlight with the recent loss of Michael Carrick to United’s starting eleven.

Cleverley is currently David Moyes best option as a midfield replacement for Carrick. Anderson showed fine form early in his career at Manchester United, but the Brazilian’s skills have dipped in recent years while also suffering through numerous injuries. Marouane Fellaini was bought during the recent transfer window but has yet to find a regular place on the first team; either a result of his injured wrist or an inability to gel with his new teammates. Shinji Kagawa isn’t really a central midfielder. The Japanese international’s best role is behind the striker. When United do use him, he is mostly lines up on the left side of the midfield. Lastly, Nick Powell and Jesse Lingard are inexperienced and out on loan. This is Cleverley’s opportunity to prove his worth to United and its supporters. But fans are growing more and more frustrated with his each performance.

Cleverley appears to have no anticipation on the pitch; it seems that he is always one or two seconds late in reading what is going on during the game. He isn’t scoring (not that he’s being asked to), nor is he making passes into attacking areas, taking set pieces, tackling or intercepting passes. He also isn’t a physical presence and (at best) is a slightly below average defender.

So what does Manchester United do? The only thing David Moyes can do is choose from the players at his disposal, coach them up, and hope they perform to expectations. Tom Cleverley has the best resume of any of United’s current midfield options.

Can the 24-year-old find the confidence and form he had only two years ago? Or is he too mentally/physically damaged to regain the skills he displayed leading into the 2011-12 season? Is a player of his quality worthy of first team status at a club with the size and history of Manchester United?

Manchester United’s next match is Wednesday at home to Everton. Will the real Tom Cleverley show up? Or do United supporters need to sneak into the Aon Training Complex to see what no one else is seeing?

Editor’s note: For the latest Red Devils news, analysis and opinion, visit the Manchester United team page.

16 thoughts on “Tom Cleverley: Manchester United’s Midfield Enigma”

  1. I’m not sure he’s really an enigma anymore. Just mediocre.

    The thing that drives me bananas about him is how rarely he does anything positive with the ball, instead choosing to maintain possession. Today against Spurs, there were 5-6 times where Spurs were pushed deep and Cleverly got the ball all alone, 25 yards out, right in the center….and did NOTHING. Each time he chose to play that little 1-2 pass with Rooney coming out the the 18 to meet him.

    The problem is that with MUFC’s midfield, they can’t really maintain possession, so you should always attack. Maintaining possession just means postponing the turnover.

  2. Why does everybody have it in for the lad? He is not the finished article by any stretch but he is busy, gets around the pitch, supports and breaks up attacks. Not bad for a midfielder. Someone has to do the unsung stuff. If he could improve his passing and add a finishing touch we would not be having this debate.

    1. If I had wings I could fly. He is a decent footballer playing for a fan base that was told he would be great. The fact that he sniffs the England squad is a travesty.

    2. I don’t think it’s that we loathe him…..he’s just not a very great player and he’s playing for a great club. He also wouldn’t be good enough at Arsenal, Chelsea, City, Liverpool, Spurs, etc.

  3. Since this was written, Spurs and Man Utd fought out a 2-all draw, and Cleverley brought nothing of note to the table. When Cleverley is on the team sheet, I shudder. Yes, I a United fan. What I can’t understand is why Moyes at some point didn’t bring on Nani and allow Kagawa to play behind Rooney in the hole. All the play was directed through Valenica and became predictable. It was good that was Welbeck replaced but not in any way to change the shape of the game. Moyes is concerned that United are 9 behind Arsenal. So he should be as he doesn’t have the insight to handle a top club. And Cleverley should join Moyes when they leave, no later than this summer.

  4. Notso, cannot pass in any direction but sideways or backwards. Not ideal for a midfielder. Will someone please wake up Ed Woodhead and have him buy a CAM of some repute? Haul Notso and the Next Ronaldinho out with the Hair. Let’s have us a midfield…PLEASE.

  5. This kid was so overhyped it was ridiculous. Typical young English player who the media makes into the second coming of [place legendary English footballer here]. He can only pass sideways or backwards like the last comment says. I’m not a United fan but the fact that he is starting for them is pretty sad. Cleverley wouldn’t play for any of the top European clubs. Not even off the bench.

  6. When Rooney took the shot from Cleverly yesterday when Valencia passed it into the box summed it up…I’d rather have Rooney take a half-chance than Cleverly miss a good one.
    Until he starts putting the ball in the net every so often like Scholesy used to do, he’ll be considered a second rate Utd player.

  7. He has lost a step and is always a second late reading the game. Great point. He could be a serviceable player but there’s something going on in his head. I think he has cracked under the pressure of playing for Man Utd. It was fine for him when he was receiving positive press and the fans loved every little thing he did. But once he hit hard times and faced some criticism he played more and more like sh*t.

    He needs to man up before he’s shipped back to the Championship. Because Man Utd are going to buy midfielders in January and over the summer window. They can’t keep waiting on players like Anderson and Cleverley.

  8. I just watched that Community Shield clip. I didn’t watch it last night when I first read the article. What happened to that player??? I’m a Celtic fan. But I haven’t seen Cleverley move and pass like that ever. The second goal was messmerizing. He looks like a completely different person. Maybe change back to #35.

    We’d DEFINITELY take him at Celtic!

  9. Fletcher played 90 minutes for the reserves last night. Hopefully he will be back during the festive period. He is what United need in the midfield right now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *