Roy Hodgson Must Establish A Common Identity If England Are To Become A Major Force Again

It wasn’t quite Rome 1997 or Istanbul 2003, but England emerged with what looks like a decent draw in their crunch tie with Ukraine on Tuesday evening. Despite a rallying call from captain Steven Gerrard that the Three Lions would do everything in their power to win the game, Roy Hodgson’s side seemed pretty happy to settle for a solitary point early on.

It’s a result that will probably see England qualify for Brazil. It’s not done yet of course, but they should have enough to overcome both Poland and Montenegro at Wembley. Despite this, there has been little positivity following the outing in Kiev, mainly due to the fact that the stalemate in Ukraine was a bit of a nothing performance. And unfortunately, it’s not the only showing of this ilk to have punctured England’s qualifying campaign. Yes, they sit top of their group, but on closer inspection, the only two teams they have actually beaten are Moldova and San Marino.

Thinking back to earlier qualifiers, it’s difficult to recall much of note about the draws against Ukraine, Poland and Montenegro. It’s no surprise really, because even though Hodgson has been at the helm for eighteen months now, the side has no identity whatsoever.

How would you describe England’s playing style? Do they pass out from the back? Sometimes. Do they knock it long? Occasionally. Do they press the ball high up the pitch? Every so often.

What about systems? 4-4-2? 4-3-3? 4-2-3-1? 4-5-1? We’ve seen them all under Hodgson but he has yet to settle on one; sending his team out in a different style at almost every turn. He seems torn between implementing his own tried, tested and sometimes old-fashioned philosophies, and that of the continental approach, which has now been adopted by an overwhelming chunk of the top sides in England.

The blend between these two ideologies has oscillated far too frequently. The end result is a performance like we saw in Ukraine on Tuesday night: neither here nor there, solid and dependable, but that’s about it. Probably enough to qualify for a World Cup, but if the words of the FA’s new top man are to be heeded, England have much bigger goals than that.

Granted there is no overnight fix, but at this current juncture – with the ‘golden generation’ being ushered out and young players being blooded in – this imbalance is having a massively detrimental effect on the team. There is enough instability in and around the squad as it is, and it’s very persistence only highlights the need for a familiar nexus that the side can gravitate around. That has to come in the form of an all-encompassing, stylistic identity.

Pages 1 2 3


  1. Tony Butterworth September 11, 2013
  2. kernel September 11, 2013
    • Flyvanescence September 11, 2013
  3. Smokey Bacon September 11, 2013

Leave a Reply