Inevitably, David Moyes’ arrival at Manchester United was greeted with echoing sighs of disappointment from some fans. Many believe this was a safe and colorless appointment, one lacking the ambition and statement of intent shown by their rivals. Zero trophies to the Scots name and a distinct lack of European experience still has the United faithful holding him at arm’s length. Sir Alex’s rallying cry for support for Moyes during his farewell Old Trafford speech has provided fans with new found optimism – Sir Alex’s opinion is still regarded as highly as any – but it would be ill-timed to conclude that fans have been won over by the appointment. The general consensus amongst any stakeholder in the club is that they could, and should, have done better.
Perhaps there is a just reason for concern. Or perhaps Manchester United have maybe just landed Fergie 2.0. Moyes’ record speaks for itself. What he achieved at Everton is nothing short of a miracle. The Scot was thrown in front of the wheel of an out-of-control Toffees side flirting dangerously with relegation. In the decade leading up to Moyes’ arrival on Merseyside, the club had only managed one top 12 finish. Toffees fans had very little reason for optimism. In his first full season in charge, the club secured seventh place in the league. Just two years later and the Scot had achieved the unthinkable. Widely tipped for relegation at the turn of the season, Moyes steered his team to Champions League qualification, finishing about neighbourhood rivals Liverpool and breaching the fortressed ‘Top 4’ of old. And with no disrespect to the Blue’s 2005 squad, this astonishing standing was achieved with a team that most managers would struggle to keep afloat in the Premier League of today – a forward line of Marcus Bent and James McFadden was rarely fancied.
Upon completion of his Goodison tenure, Moyes had amassed nine top 8 finishes in his eleven years in charge. His one career regret to date will be failing to lift silverware with the Blues – the nearest miss being a 2-1 Wembley defeat to Chelsea in the 2009 FA Cup final. However, sensibly Moyes had rightly prioritized the league. Climbing the Premier League ladder has proved to pay dividends in longevity for managers in today’s game, rather than stocking up the trophy cabinet (just take a look at Birmingham’s Alex McLeish).