Can Paolo Di Canio Make Sunderland Dark Horses for Europa League Qualification?

There is little doubt that since Paolo Di Canio took over the helm at Sunderland in March, an optimistic wind has blown in over the Wearside club; and not the usual cautious optimism so often used to describe most managerial changes either. The fiery and charismatic Italian seems to have affected a shift in the attitude and outlook of everybody associated with the club, not least with the fans and certainly with the media – who have fervently pursued any anecdote, controversy or scrap of news about The Black Cats and their boss with the same zeal usually reserved for their neighbors down the road, fierce rivals Newcastle United.

The already well-documented unpredictability of his playing career seems to have transferred into his relatively short managerial life already and could be just what Sunderland require to continue a kick-start away from a long period of stagnation. A hugely impressive tenure at Swindon Town in League 2, where he cut his teeth, led them to promotion in his first season, followed by a competitive first half of the campaign in League 1. However, this success was not without its clashes and quarrels; high-profile spats with striker Leon Clarke and keeper Wes Foderingham were the first warnings that Di Canio was not a man to be crossed, even in the infancy of his time as a boss. This culminated in a run-in with his board at the County Ground though when he took exception to them making no transfer funds available (despite an offer by him to personally pay for loan signings) and selling winger Matt Ritchie to Bournemouth. Di Canio ultimately resigned shortly after in January, cementing his reputation as a firebrand, not willing to accept anything less than absolute support from everybody associated with him.

This was not to go unnoticed. When owner and chairman Ellis Short brokered a deal to bring Di Canio to the Stadium of Light, Sunderland were perilously close to the drop and firmly entrenched in a relegation dog-fight. He had inherited an unfit and demoralized squad that looked to be heading to the Championship under previous incumbent Martin O’Neill. Immediately, reports surfaced of double training sessions and a more hard-line approach; whilst stricter disciplinary procedures toward members of the squad, notably Phil Bardsley, caught in a casino late at night and public criticism of the likes of Connor Wickham became early trademarks as Di Canio attempted to arrest the slide through the trapdoor. It worked. Sunderland preserved their Premier League status, via an historic 3-0 Tyne Wear away derby win over Newcastle at St James’ Park and set about an overhaul of their playing staff.

The close season transfer dealings began in earnest with Rome-born Di Canio releasing a number of players, not least Titus Bramble and Matt Kilgallon, in an attempt to clear the decks; this was followed by the sale of the outstanding Simon Mignolet to Liverpool and Egyptian international Ahmed Elmohamady to Hull City. In their place, a veritable who’s who of largely unknown players have arrived alongside one or two more familiar faces. Joining former Hull City and current USA international striker Jozy Altidore from AZ Alkmaar and ex-Arsenal keeper Vito Mannone include midfielder Cabral from Basel and French defenders Modibo Diakité from Lazio and Valentin Roberge from Maritimo; whilst youngsters David Moberg Karlsson and El-Hadji Ba bring a fresher approach to what many would agree was an under-achieving squad. This is only going to be further enhanced by the imminent arrival of Italian international Emanuele Giaccherini from Juventus, an excellent signing that will bolster the squad significantly.

All of this would seem to point to a brighter future and a good 2013/14 season, a new dawn under a vibrant, passionate manager overseeing a younger, hungrier and more streamlined squad that is going to have an element of surprise is in stark contrast to what has often looked like a tired, stale and ill-disciplined outfit that looked goal-shy and out of ideas. Players like Adam Johnson and Steven Fletcher have the opportunity of a new lease of life playing under Di Canio and with players like Altidore and Giaccherini, surely things are looking very promising indeed?

However, former chairman and Sunderland legend Niall Quinn recently was quoted as saying,

“It’s going to be tough. He’s got a lot of players with very little experience in the Premier League and I think it might be tough for him.”

There is of course a chance Sunderland could struggle again, players need to gel and other clubs will also have strengthened by the time the season kicks off. With the man in charge however, nobody is in any doubt of what is required, it certainly won’t be dull and there is every chance of Sunderland being dark horses for a shock UEFA Europa League qualification. The jury is out.

17 thoughts on “Can Paolo Di Canio Make Sunderland Dark Horses for Europa League Qualification?”

  1. While Di Canio makes Ian Holloway look positively asleep at the wheel, it remains to be seen if that schtick can last a year in the Prem.

    Don’t the bookies have a line on that yet?

    1. A fair point Guy, it seems that Di Canio isn’t all mouth and sound-bites though. He seems to do a great job lifting players and his time at Swindon was impressive. Thanks for the comment mate.

      1. Exciting times ahead i think but do agree with Quinny squad needs time to gel but a huge overhaul of the squaf is whats needed. I for one looking forward to the bew season.

  2. Whatever the outcome, an interesting season beckons for SAFC and their fans. Quinn is right to be cautious but I believe the Cats will surprise a few people. However, this revamped squad will need to time to gel as it has been revolution and not evolution at the Stadium of Light with the coaching, scouting and key management positions all being changed.

    1. Thanks Keith, I think a lot of people would echo those thoughts. It has been a revolution. There might just be a spark somewhere though, history shows the league has a funny way of throwing up a surprise package …..

  3. It’d worry me they’re making the same mistake Bruce did in signing umpteen new players.

    There was an interesting post on The Oatcake from someone who has a lot to do with football administration on a national level who commented that ” Ellis Short admitted he rues the day he met Niall Quinn”. That said he always seems to back a manager financially.

    1. I do believe he will slot most of them into the starting line-up. Altidore, Diakite and Giaccherini arrive with at least some pedigree to talk about. Mannone, I thought, always looked dependable at Arsenal and could flourish with games. An attacking stable of Altidore, Giaccherini, Fletcher and Johnson looks good in my opinion.

  4. Good article.

    I am a fan of Di Canio. I’m at the age when I can remember him as a player and I’ve seen his progression as a manager.

    I bring this up in most of my posts, so I’m sorry if people get tired of it….but I have been a college basketball coach in the states for 15 years. Sometimes when a new manager/coach comes in, he has to “blow up” the current roster. This can either be because the manager feels the players don’t fit his philosophy or they aren’t buying into his philosophy.

    I’m not surprised Di Canio has released so many players from Sunderland. The team I saw against Man United (a few days before O’Neil was fired) was dead. They were going through the motions.

    Di Canio’s arrival sparked the club for a short time, but that fire had died down over the next few weeks. And the players from the previous regime had seemed to cool on the new coach. This happens in sports.

    There’s no doubt players like Mignolet are talented. But O’Neil and Di Canio aren’t the first managers who have had difficulty getting a consistent effort out of that player. So he had to go. You can only wait around on a “talented” player for so long. At some point they either learn to buy into a manager or they don’t. Mignolet didn’t buy in. My feeling is he will continue to be a football journeyman.

    I’m rooting for Sunderland. I want to see the new kids succeed and I want to see Di Canio’s critics eat some crow.

    There is no doubt the club will suffer through some early pain. Much the same way Aston Villa did when they went with the youth.

    But if the players brought in can play as passionately as their manager, they will be out of the relegation scramble at the end of the year.

    I do think (if Di Canio doesn’t go off the deep end and eventually attacks his ownership) that Sunderland can fight for a Europa League spot in the next few years. They have a solid base of support from their fans and their owners seem willing to spend a little.

    I’m another person who is looking forward to this Premier League season more than any other.

    That seems to be the feelings with the majority of EPL fans. Let’s hope we’re not disappointed.

    1. Thank you for taking the time to reply at length Pete. They did die down, but I believe that was due to the limitations of a squad who knew the axe was due to be swung. I must say your evaluation of Mignolet is surprising, he’s rated very highly.

  5. My mistake….I meant Sessegnon.

    And as far as I know, he’s still on the roster. I’m not a fan of his.

    Mignolet will be a huge lose.

  6. Can Paolo Di Canio Make Sunderland Dark Horses for Europa League Qualification?

    NO…they are relegation fodder

  7. From: Monday, July 15, 2013
    To: Saturday, August 17, 2013

    Result: 33 days

    Or 1 month, 2 days

    2,851,200 seconds
    47,520 minutes
    792 hours

    … Tick-tock. Tick-tock…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *