Why I Am Still Avoiding the MLS All Star Game

About a year ago on this site, I wrote an article about why I would not be watching the MLS All Stars face off against Manchester United at Red Bull Arena.  In essence, I felt that another meaningless friendly, but this time with a collection of MLS talent instead of just one team, didn’t peak my interest:

For the record, I tend not to watch all star games of sports I enjoy.  No matter what the schtick (players pick teams, domestic v. foreign, winner gets homefield), if the game doesn’t count for something meaningful then I tend to enjoy it less.  And that I think is the root cause of my lack of interest in tonight’s game.

Except for a major injury, no matter what happens on the pitch tonight it won’t matter. No trophies will be awarded, no points towards a final goal will be given, and there is nothing for MLS to gain from this match.  If anything, there’s more to lose: witness the press surrounding last year’s game.  I may be in the minority, but when there is so little at stake in a game I have little impetus to watch it on television.

In the past I have stated that I enjoy international friendlies; does this make me a hypocrite?  Not at all, because I think the key difference is that I am watching this game on television. I can watch Manchester United on ESPN2 plenty of times in the coming months, in games that matter.  If I were at Red Bull Arena and feeling the atmosphere of the game, I would be more excited and interested.  But I am relegated to my couch, so I lose the atmosphere of the game and what appeals to me most about friendlies: seeing a team I can’t normally see play in-person.

A year later, it’s another Premier League team visiting our shores to face our collection of the best of the best (or, the best available).  While Chelsea has a bit more prestige, having just won the UEFA Champions League, the scenario is basically the same.  The only two differences that will maybe convince me to watch tonight are the arena and the head coach.  Philadelphia’s soccer stadium has one of the best views in the league, and I enjoy watching games in HD played there simply because the view is unparalleled.  The second reason is Ben Olsen.  The DC united head coach is an up-and-coming manager with an oversized personality.  How he manages his roster of all stars and enjoys the moment could be fun to see.

Does all this mean I will be tuning in tonight?  Probably not.  Because at the end of the day, the game doesn’t mean anything.  An MLS win will be portrayed as them beating a traveling team tuning up for the season, while another loss to an EPL side will further cast doubt on MLS as product (rightly or wrongly).  I’ll take a pass on this one and wait for a match that actually determines something in the standings.

96 Comments

  1. Alex July 25, 2012
    • Tijuana Robert July 25, 2012
      • Charles July 25, 2012
  2. Alex July 25, 2012
    • Tijuana Robert July 25, 2012
      • Charles July 25, 2012
  3. The original Tom July 25, 2012
    • Charles July 25, 2012
      • Tijuana Robert July 25, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 25, 2012
        • Alan July 25, 2012
        • Ted July 28, 2012
  4. The original Tom July 25, 2012
    • Charles July 25, 2012
      • Tijuana Robert July 25, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 25, 2012
        • Alan July 25, 2012
        • Ted July 28, 2012
  5. Johnny V July 25, 2012
  6. Johnny V July 25, 2012
  7. Charles July 25, 2012
    • SSReporters July 26, 2012
      • Alan July 27, 2012
  8. Charles July 25, 2012
    • SSReporters July 26, 2012
      • Alan July 27, 2012
  9. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 25, 2012
    • Sam July 26, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
  10. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 25, 2012
    • Sam July 26, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
      • Alex August 3, 2012
        • Alex August 3, 2012
        • Bob August 3, 2012
  11. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 25, 2012
  12. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 25, 2012
  13. Charles July 26, 2012
  14. Charles July 26, 2012
  15. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
    • Charles July 26, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
  16. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
    • Charles July 26, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
        • Charles July 31, 2012
  17. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
    • Robert Hay July 26, 2012
  18. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
    • Robert Hay July 26, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) August 2, 2012
  19. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
    • Alan July 27, 2012
  20. Roger(Pro/Rel) July 26, 2012
    • Alan July 27, 2012
  21. Alan July 27, 2012
  22. Alan July 27, 2012
  23. Eric Imhof July 28, 2012
  24. Eric Imhof July 28, 2012
  25. Bob July 28, 2012
    • Charles July 30, 2012
    • Alan July 30, 2012
  26. Bob July 31, 2012
    • Alan July 31, 2012
      • Bob July 31, 2012
        • Charles July 31, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) August 1, 2012
  27. Alan July 31, 2012
    • Bob July 31, 2012
      • Alan July 31, 2012
        • Bob August 1, 2012
          • Charles August 1, 2012
          • Alan August 1, 2012
  28. harry cee August 1, 2012
    • Charles August 1, 2012
    • Bob August 1, 2012
      • Charles August 1, 2012
    • Alan August 1, 2012
      • Charles August 3, 2012
        • Alan August 3, 2012
  29. Roger(Pro/Rel) August 1, 2012
    • Bob August 1, 2012
      • Alan August 1, 2012
      • Roger(Pro/Rel) August 2, 2012
      • Charles August 3, 2012
        • Bob August 3, 2012
          • Charles August 6, 2012
          • Charles August 6, 2012
          • Alan August 7, 2012
      • Gazza August 3, 2012
        • Bob August 3, 2012
    • Alex August 3, 2012
      • Charles August 3, 2012
      • Alan August 3, 2012

Leave a Reply