Sign up for the free World Soccer Talk newsletter to find out how you can win 2 free tickets to Copa America »


3 EPL Managers Who Crossed The Line To Manage Their Rival Club

alex mcleish11 3 EPL Managers Who Crossed The Line To Manage Their Rival ClubIn light of the recent McLeish-Villa-Birmingham saga, let’s take a look at other managers who have crossed local lines to manage hated rivals.

The king of this category has to be Ron Saunders. Not only did he manage Aston Villa and Birmingham City, but also West Bromwich Albion. Saunders led Villa to promotion in 1974. He won two League Cups before guiding Villa to the title in the 1980-81 season. In the very next season, he decided to move on due to a dispute with the board when the team was set to play in an European Cup quarterfinal.

Saunders decided to move across town to Birmingham City. In his second season at Birmingham City, the club was relegated — much to the delight of the Villa faithful. However, Saunders was able to bring the Blues back to the top-flight just a season later. Saunders then made the decision to move on to another local rival — West Bromwich Albion — in 1986.

Saunders joined West Brom in February of 1986, but the club was eventually relegated to the second division. He retired in 1987 after failing to win promotion for the Baggies.

Over in north London, there was another prominent manager who crossed the local lines to manage a hated rival.

Since I am an Arsenal fan, I have to mention manager George Graham. The Scot made 227 appearances for Arsenal as a player in the ‘60’s and 70’s. In 1986, he took over as manager of the Gunners and had a successful nine-year run, winning two league titles. Graham was banned from management for a year in 1995 due to suspicious transfer dealings.

After a short stint with Leeds, Graham was hired as manager of Tottenham. Many Spurs supporters were angered that the Arsenal man was appointed. Despite winning the League Cup in 1998-1999, Graham was fired mainly because of his unpopularity.

Harry Redknapp knows all about crossing the line in a local derby. Redknapp took over at Portsmouth in 2002. The cockney manager enjoyed success while leading Portsmouth to promotion to the Premier League in his first full season. ‘Arry kept Pompey in the Premier League in ’03-04 before resigning due to disagreements with the owners.

Redknapp promised the Portsmouth supporters that he would not be taking over at Southampton. Well, as it turned out, he did decide to go “down the road” to Southampton. It was not a good move for Redknapp. He took over a struggling side looking to stay afloat in the Premier League. Unfortunately for ‘Arry, Southampton failed to avoid relegation. Redknapp had yet another dispute with ownership, and the Pompey job opened up. It was time for him to head back to Portsmouth.

Redknapp enjoyed even more success in his second time around with Portsmouth. He was able to keep the club in the Premier League while guiding them to a surprise FA Cup triumph in 2008. Some attribute his success in his second term to a flow of money into the club.

Fans are always angry when a manager switches to a rival club. The original club’s supporters feel betrayed by their former manager. The new club’s supporters feel alienated and flat-out disgusted when the owners hire an enemy to run their team. It is not a good situation for anyone and possibly those in command should refrain from hiring rival managers in the future.

How would you feel if this was happening at your club (or if you are actual Birmingham or Villa fans)? On one hand, managers are not obligated to be loyal to their clubs. If someone sees a way to advance their career, then why not do so. That is how it is in the real world, but football isn’t the real world. Supporters do not jump from club to club like customers jump to different brands at a supermarket. How do you feel about these issues? Share your opinions in the comments section below. I’d love to read your insight.

This entry was posted in General, Leagues: EPL. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to 3 EPL Managers Who Crossed The Line To Manage Their Rival Club

  1. Ian Porterfield says:

    Got to mention Stokoe also. Moved from Magpie to Black Cat and took down mighty Leeds in the FA Cup.

  2. Bobby says:

    As a Villa fan it’s not just that Mcleish has managed Birmingham but that he is also not the right man for the job. His teams never play entertaining soccer. If the manager in question had an excellent record managing and his style of play was entertaining there would be fewer fans who would be upset. It’s not as if McLeish is a top manager. He is mediocre at best. Villa deserve better.

    • Jack Tomczuk says:

      Not too mention that Birmingham were relegated this season despite winning the league cup. As an Arsenal fan, I know that Birmingham knew how to beat us.

      I agree with you that Villa deserve a better manager. Just as the Gaffer posted the other day, there are a number of other candidates that are available.

      Who knows? McLeish may work out, but it will be difficult seeing as he is already on the supporters’ bad side. I hope everything turns out well for Villa.

  3. Daniel Okim Etta says:

    Arsene is not doing his club any good because they set to face the worst season this year, i urge all arsenal fans to rise up and do something

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>