Claims that Manchester City Bought the FA Cup Are Hypocritical

Photo by ivan03

Manchester City have had an incredible season after qualifying for the Champions League, winning the FA Cup and finishing the season in third place, tied with second-place Chelsea on the same number of points. They finally got the monkey off their back by winning a piece of silverware, their first meaningful one since 1976.

However, it’s interesting to see what the reaction has been from some rival supporters. Rather than congratulating City on a well-deserved season, rival supporters have thumbed up their noses at Manchester City’s achievements. “You can’t buy history.” “They bought the FA Cup.” And so on. These are just a couple of the many similar comments made against City in recent days.

Rival supporters are trying to dismiss City’s achievements, to knock them down a peg or two. In their minds, anyone can buy a title if they have enough money, But while an infusion of cash into a club’s coffers definitely helps, it doesn’t guarantee success. It can help significantly, but the club still has to perform on the pitch to get the necessary results.

The “You can’t buy history” taunts are nothing new. When Roman Abramovich bought Chelsea, many supporters said the same thing about the Blues and dismissed their achievements by saying that club bought success too. However, the truth of the matter is that all English clubs buy success. Manchester United is a buying club. So too is Arsenal and Tottenham and Liverpool. The list goes on and on.

The claims that Manchester City “bought the FA Cup” often come from Man United supporters. But consider some of United’s stars this season:

  • Wayne Rooney – Bought from Everton
  • Edwin van der Sar – Bought from Fulham
  • Antonio Valencia – Bought from Wigan
  • Dimitar Berbatov – Bought from Tottenham
  • Chicharito – Bought from Chivas
  • Rio Ferdinand – Bought from Leeds
  • Etc.

Of the 11 Manchester United players who started against Blackpool this past Sunday, only Jonny Evans and Paul Scholes came through Manchester United’s youth system. Everyone else was bought.

Manchester City critics may argue that it’s the extent to how much City paid that makes the claim that “They bought the FA Cup” more real. Looking at this season’s wage bills for the clubs in the Premier League, Manchester City does have a bigger wage bill (£133m) than Man United (£131m), but only by £2 million. If City “bought the FA Cup,” then Man United “bought the Premier League title.” Looking more closely at the wage bills of the Premier League clubs, it’s Chelsea who has the worst wage bill at £174m. But as I said before, money doesn’t guarantee success. Chelsea finished the season empty handed.

So the next time when supporters start a banter about how your club bought their success, remember that all clubs buy success. Some more than others, yes. But we live in a day and age where all Premier League clubs are heavily involved in the transfer market as they try to get a competitive advantage over their opposition by procuring the best talent from England or anywhere else in the world. Manchester City isn’t the only club on this planet who spends a ton of money to help achieve their goals.

166 Comments

  1. Earl Reed May 24, 2011
    • Troy May 24, 2011
      • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
        • Troy May 24, 2011
  2. Carmello May 24, 2011
  3. Chris May 24, 2011
    • WINDY MILLER May 24, 2011
      • Shuggie May 24, 2011
    • Grandsolo June 3, 2011
    • Ian Cav June 4, 2011
  4. James Dunmore May 24, 2011
    • tim May 24, 2011
      • James Dunmore May 24, 2011
        • Mike May 24, 2011
          • James Dunmore May 24, 2011
          • shuggie May 24, 2011
        • Keith May 24, 2011
    • 750mil n counting May 24, 2011
      • James Dunmore May 24, 2011
        • Mike May 24, 2011
        • Why? May 24, 2011
    • Carlos May 24, 2011
      • James Dunmore May 24, 2011
        • Carlos May 24, 2011
          • Troy May 24, 2011
    • Brad June 3, 2011
  5. Andrew May 24, 2011
    • Why? May 24, 2011
  6. Nico May 24, 2011
    • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
      • Nico May 24, 2011
        • Troy May 24, 2011
          • Troy May 24, 2011
        • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
          • Georgie B. May 24, 2011
          • Troy May 24, 2011
          • Adam May 25, 2011
        • Mike May 24, 2011
          • Nico May 24, 2011
          • Carlos June 7, 2011
        • wyted May 25, 2011
    • Carlos May 24, 2011
    • Why? May 24, 2011
    • somervillain May 24, 2011
  7. Chris May 24, 2011
  8. Chris May 24, 2011
  9. The Toast May 24, 2011
  10. Jason Halfpenny May 24, 2011
  11. Jason Halfpenny May 24, 2011
    • The Toast May 24, 2011
      • Blueape May 24, 2011
        • James Dunmore May 24, 2011
        • Zach May 24, 2011
          • Why? May 24, 2011
          • Zach May 24, 2011
          • Zach May 24, 2011
      • WINDY MILLER May 24, 2011
        • Jay May 24, 2011
      • Carlos June 7, 2011
    • Jay May 24, 2011
      • James Dunmore May 24, 2011
      • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
      • 750mil n counting May 24, 2011
        • Jay May 24, 2011
          • Jay May 24, 2011
          • Why? May 25, 2011
        • Why? May 25, 2011
      • Why? May 24, 2011
        • Zach May 24, 2011
          • Why? May 24, 2011
          • Why? May 24, 2011
        • Jay May 24, 2011
  12. Jason Halfpenny May 24, 2011
    • The Toast May 24, 2011
    • Jay May 24, 2011
  13. Jason Halfpenny May 24, 2011
  14. Jason Halfpenny May 24, 2011
    • The Toast May 24, 2011
  15. Mekias May 24, 2011
    • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
      • Zach May 24, 2011
        • Troy May 24, 2011
          • Zach May 24, 2011
        • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
          • Zach May 24, 2011
          • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
  16. MCHobbit May 24, 2011
    • The Gaffer May 24, 2011
  17. Why? May 24, 2011
    • Matt T. May 24, 2011
    • Jay May 24, 2011
      • Why? May 25, 2011
        • Jay May 25, 2011
          • Why? May 25, 2011
          • Jay May 25, 2011
          • Why? May 25, 2011
  18. Guy May 24, 2011
    • Mekias May 24, 2011
  19. Patrico May 24, 2011
    • Why? May 24, 2011
  20. Harry May 24, 2011
  21. Gordon May 24, 2011
    • Zach May 24, 2011
  22. Zach May 24, 2011
    • Mizzy May 25, 2011
  23. El Tri 2014 May 24, 2011
  24. jasonc May 24, 2011
    • The Toast May 24, 2011
      • jasonc May 24, 2011
  25. Troy May 24, 2011
    • Mekias May 24, 2011
      • Troy May 24, 2011
      • Why? May 24, 2011
        • Troy May 24, 2011
        • Stop Making Sense May 25, 2011
          • Why? May 25, 2011
          • Stop Making Sense May 25, 2011
          • Why? May 25, 2011
          • Stop Making Sense May 26, 2011
  26. jasonc May 24, 2011
    • Troy May 24, 2011
      • Elliot May 24, 2011
        • Troy May 24, 2011
      • jasonc May 24, 2011
        • Troy May 24, 2011
  27. clevblue May 24, 2011
  28. big red May 24, 2011
    • Why? May 24, 2011
    • somervillain May 24, 2011
    • Amber May 24, 2011
      • The Gaffer May 24, 2011
      • Earl Reed May 24, 2011
        • Zach May 25, 2011
    • The Gaffer May 24, 2011
      • Why? May 25, 2011
        • Zach May 25, 2011
          • Why? May 25, 2011
  29. Mizzy May 24, 2011
  30. Dave May 24, 2011
    • Jamie August 26, 2011
  31. Garth May 24, 2011
    • Zach May 25, 2011
  32. Warner May 24, 2011
  33. Dr. G May 24, 2011
  34. somervillain May 24, 2011
  35. satan May 25, 2011
    • Why? May 25, 2011
      • satan May 25, 2011
  36. Zach S. May 25, 2011
  37. bluePRINT May 25, 2011
    • Troy May 25, 2011
    • Matt May 26, 2011
  38. Zach May 25, 2011
  39. Larry May 25, 2011
  40. Brian May 25, 2011
  41. H June 3, 2011
  42. jimbob james June 4, 2011
  43. nicki June 7, 2011
  44. john July 1, 2011
  45. Sminky July 2, 2011
  46. James September 1, 2011
  47. Tim seaton September 5, 2011
    • Why? September 5, 2011
  48. tim seaton September 5, 2011
  49. Why? September 5, 2011
    • Tim seaton September 5, 2011

Leave a Reply