Why Tim Ream, Not Andy Najar, Should Have Been Named MLS Rookie of the Year


Now that Major League Soccer has started to give out their awards in certain categories, there is one they’ve awarded that is highly questionable. That’s the Rookie of the Year category. The three nominees were Danny Mwanga of the Philadelphia Union, Tim Ream of the New York Red Bulls and Andy Najar of DC United. To win this category, I believe you need to consider rookies having solid seasons, from start to finish, to win that award.

Unbelievably, Najar was voted by MLS as Rookie of the Year. From a terrible season for the club in our Nation’s Capital he scored five goals with an assist and started twenty-two out of the twenty-six games he played. What he has shown to all of us is that he is going to be the future at DC United and a possible member of the US National Team. Or he could play for Honduras if he has to make a choice. There’s no doubt that he’ll be a shining star out of a doom and gloom season at RFK. But while it’s nice to see him get this award, sadly there was a mistake made by the league and those who think they did the right thing.

Rookie central defender Tim Ream, who has played every single match and every single minute in his first season in MLS, deserved the award. The former St. Louis University defender did more than Najar with a club that was having a spectacular season, made the playoffs and is an MLS Cup contender. No matter where Ream was on the field he always tracked back and when he got close enough to the attacker, he would clear the ball away from his man without ever having to take him down. If this award is supposed to be given to an exciting goal scorer, then we should just make two separate awards for Rookie Forward of the Year and Rookie Defender of the Year.

Major League Soccer has done a disservice in their decision to name Najar Rookie of the Year. Some will say that Najar slightly did better than the other two nominees, but that is a laughable excuse. I am not saying Najar won’t be an exciting player in the league in the future. I think he has a bright future for his club career and as a potential national team player, but as the only bright spot in a horrible season for DC United it wasn’t enough for him to win the award.

Pages 1 2


  1. Oscar Torres November 3, 2010
  2. Lloyd November 3, 2010
  3. Jason November 4, 2010
    • Daniel Feuerstein November 4, 2010
  4. Charles November 4, 2010
  5. Cavan November 4, 2010
    • Daniel Feuerstein November 4, 2010
  6. Ivan November 4, 2010
    • Kevin November 4, 2010
      • Ivan November 5, 2010
  7. Kevin November 4, 2010
  8. Dan November 4, 2010
  9. TorontoFC November 5, 2010
    • Noah November 12, 2010
  10. Mike Johnston November 11, 2010

Leave a Reply