Did Nani Cheat With His Controversial Goal Against Spurs? (Video)

On Saturday, Manchester United’s Nani scored a goal against Tottenham Hotspur which was extremely controversial and will be the topic of many conversations over the next few days. Looking at it again and again, the goal was a result of poor sportsmanship by Nani and a mix-up in communication between Spurs goalkeeper Heurehlo Gomes and the referee and assistant referee.

The incident happened after Nani made a run inside the Tottenham box late in the second half. There was minimal contact on Nani but he continued to run into the box and then dived to the ground and handled the ball. At this point, it appeared that Gomes believed that a free kick had been awarded to Spurs, so as he prepared to take it and waited for his players to get into permission, Nani ran near the ball and poked it past Gomes into the net. Nani celebrated in front of the Stretford End as Clattenburg ran over to his assistant to discuss the incident. After a brief discussion, the goal was awarded to Manchester United. And the Tottenham players went berserk, surrounding the referee and assistant referee in complete disbelief that the goal had been given.

The goal was legitimate but a cheap one. Nani shouldn’t have dived in the box in the first place. And second, a free kick should have been given for Nani’s hand ball. Then Gomes made the mistake of misunderstanding what call the referee had made. To make matters worse, Nani was unsportsmanlike to kick the ball into the net. Sure, the ball was live but it was a cheap goal made even cheaper after his ridiculous dive in the box and hand ball just seconds earlier.

Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson blamed the incident on Gomes by saying,

“You can look at the referee and look at the linesmen and blame them, but the goalkeeper should know better. He’s an experienced goalkeeper. I thought he made a mess of it. The referee played on because the goalkeeper took possession of the ball. He then went to take a free-kick thinking it was a foul. He made an error.”

And, not surprisingly, Tottenham manager Harry Redknapp saw it the other way around:

“It was handball. He put his hand on the ball and dragged it down. He should have been booked. The referee didn’t see him handball it, that’s why he’s allowed play to go on. The assistant referee has seen it, that’s why he’s flagged. He’s handled the ball. If he’s handled the ball he should be booked and it’s a free-kick. Gomes puts the ball down to take a free-kick. It’s obvious. Why would he stand there and leave the ball there after he saw him handball it?”

What do you think? Did Nani cheat? Should he have exercised better sportsmanship? Should the goal have stood? Who was right, Ferguson or Redknapp? Share your opinion in the comments section below.

141 Comments

  1. Fitzy October 30, 2010
    • canyid October 30, 2010
    • fan October 30, 2010
      • retards annoy me October 31, 2010
        • Leiuh March 10, 2011
    • handball October 31, 2010
    • David November 6, 2010
  2. MattL October 30, 2010
    • Earl October 30, 2010
      • Why? October 30, 2010
        • Tony November 2, 2010
      • anon@anon.com November 3, 2010
  3. dada October 30, 2010
    • The Gaffer October 30, 2010
      • Bishopville Red October 30, 2010
        • Matt October 30, 2010
        • cgncgnd October 30, 2010
        • Jim October 30, 2010
          • Marc October 31, 2010
      • Why? October 30, 2010
      • jm October 30, 2010
      • fan October 30, 2010
      • Maik October 31, 2010
  4. kale October 30, 2010
  5. Enorme Nuez October 30, 2010
  6. Charles October 30, 2010
  7. Earl October 30, 2010
    • Earl October 30, 2010
    • Charles October 30, 2010
      • Earl Reed October 30, 2010
  8. yes October 30, 2010
  9. Why? October 30, 2010
  10. theymake mesick October 30, 2010
    • Tom R October 31, 2010
  11. Ringo October 30, 2010
  12. proper eyesight October 30, 2010
  13. jezz09 October 30, 2010
    • Why? October 30, 2010
    • Earl Reed October 30, 2010
    • Matt October 30, 2010
  14. joseph October 30, 2010
    • Charles October 30, 2010
  15. jose October 30, 2010
  16. C Dub October 30, 2010
  17. Bishopville Red October 30, 2010
    • MennoDaddy October 30, 2010
      • Bishopville Red October 30, 2010
    • Matt October 30, 2010
      • Bishopville Red October 30, 2010
    • Solskjaer24 October 31, 2010
  18. jezz09 October 30, 2010
  19. JW October 30, 2010
    • Earl Reed October 30, 2010
  20. Carolyn October 30, 2010
  21. Fernando October 30, 2010
    • Tom R October 31, 2010
  22. Andy October 30, 2010
    • Charles October 30, 2010
    • Matt October 30, 2010
      • Bishopville Red October 30, 2010
        • Matt October 30, 2010
          • Bishopville Red October 30, 2010
  23. Gooner October 30, 2010
  24. Ian October 30, 2010
  25. fivefouls1987 October 30, 2010
  26. Dave C October 30, 2010
  27. Matt October 30, 2010
  28. farlieonfootie October 30, 2010
  29. MrRichPeoples October 30, 2010
    • Durandal October 30, 2010
  30. Ryan October 30, 2010
  31. Up the Chels! October 30, 2010
  32. jammer October 30, 2010
  33. Sir Guy October 30, 2010
    • MrRichPeoples October 30, 2010
      • Andrei October 30, 2010
        • Sir Guy October 31, 2010
      • David the Yank October 30, 2010
        • Durandal October 30, 2010
  34. Andrei October 30, 2010
  35. RomaChelsea-American October 30, 2010
  36. brn442 October 31, 2010
    • The Gaffer October 31, 2010
      • Andrei October 31, 2010
      • Sir Guy October 31, 2010
  37. SSReporters October 31, 2010
    • Earl October 31, 2010
  38. WoAd October 31, 2010
    • David the Yank October 31, 2010
  39. David the Yank October 31, 2010
    • d rock October 31, 2010
  40. Why? October 31, 2010
  41. pat October 31, 2010
  42. RVPFan October 31, 2010
  43. jleau October 31, 2010
  44. This One Guy in Detroit October 31, 2010
  45. d rock October 31, 2010
  46. Pete October 31, 2010
  47. James October 31, 2010
  48. Football Souvenirs October 31, 2010
  49. Terry October 31, 2010
  50. Squiz-Wolf October 31, 2010
  51. Mike October 31, 2010
  52. Nick October 31, 2010
    • Nick October 31, 2010
  53. Mike October 31, 2010
    • Nick October 31, 2010
  54. Tom R October 31, 2010
  55. fan November 1, 2010
  56. brazilian November 1, 2010
  57. Mike November 1, 2010
  58. Sir Guy November 1, 2010
    • The Gaffer November 1, 2010
  59. B November 1, 2010
  60. the devil himself November 1, 2010
    • Bishopville Red November 1, 2010
  61. Arsenal Station November 1, 2010
    • Why? November 2, 2010
  62. Reno November 1, 2010
  63. Tom R November 1, 2010
    • David the Yank November 1, 2010
      • Why? November 2, 2010
  64. John November 1, 2010
  65. Tom R November 1, 2010
    • David the Yank November 1, 2010
  66. joseph marshall November 2, 2010
  67. Alex November 2, 2010
  68. Cid November 2, 2010
  69. Premierleaguered November 2, 2010
    • The Gaffer November 2, 2010
      • Premierleaguered November 2, 2010
  70. Joey B November 2, 2010
  71. Bob November 2, 2010
  72. man u foreva November 3, 2010
    • Premierleaguered November 4, 2010
  73. Manchester U Freak January 14, 2011
  74. Leiuh March 10, 2011
    • NotTheNoob March 10, 2011
    • Manchester U Freak April 25, 2011

Leave a Reply