5 Reasons Why England Aren’t Good Enough to Compete with the World’s Best

In all actuality, shouldn’t we have seen this coming like some run away freight down the frozen road of Precedence St. set by all those England players before? A capitulation of the highest order, a failing against those we least want to fail against and lastly, an outcome that was so sure to happen, we all seemed to pull the wool over our very eyes and convince ourselves through sheer self fulfilling prophecy that it was somehow going to end different this time. Only it didn’t, and who knows how long it could actually be until it does.

How was it ever going to end differently and why didn’t I see this coming? A pizza is still made to taste like a pizza does with dough, cheese, sauce and toppings, regardless of who does the mixing. Fancy Italians and three piece suits do not a gourmet chef or World Cup winning side make.

This England fan was wrong all along. And as I sit trying to convince myself that a 2-2 halftime situation somehow leads to an England victory against superior athletes, superior tactics and superior planning, I’m left only with the realization that my heart felt passion for a football team originating for a home country other than my own is equally as odd in thinking a new chef can somehow make the same old ingredients somehow taste differently.

Yes England failed in the 2010 World Cup because they weren’t good enough, we get that, and we’ve read it over and over again since the match drawn with the US. But deeper and darker questions must now be asked by the footballing community and answered by the FA if England are to ever renew their stamp on the world’s game that has whittled with age and expired all those years ago. Tough questions that will need serious answers specifically concerning youth development, home grown managers and the bloated Premier League.

The core of the England national team now float away into international waters of regret and unfulfilled promise. Forever a generation that was pipped for glory, if not in 2006, then surely in 2010, the tired old English squad with their Premier League dreams of glory set sail for a much deserved vacation with pockets full of gold seemingly happy they’ll now have time for some much needed rest before the so called “best league in the world” resumes.

What many fail to realize is that as TV contracts are won, parachute payments are paid and transfer fees are negotiated, the next generation of English millionaires sit aside, waiting in the Premier League wings planning their futures before they’ve planned how they’ll break down a midfield with one less player, pass the ball out of trouble, link play to strikers or compete in a World Cup without getting “bored”. In a nation where the majority of footballers choice of club v country is an easier choice than which football boots to wear, one can easily start to see the origins of a mindset and mentality inspired more by bling than by basics spreading like a cancer across the hearts and minds of young footballers the country over.

Before qualification for Euro 2012 starts this September, here are a few reasons why I think my (still, maybe now more than ever) beloved England just aren’t good enough to compete against the World’s best. Think of it as therapy.

  • The lack of quality English managersWhen we get it wrong, let’s bring in someone else, a big name, a foreigner, that’ll fix everything. I’ve been a pretty big proponent of Fabio Capello for the last year and a half. How can you not be? With a CV a mile long, a strict, glaring stare to put even the wildest of England players in their place coupled with the ability and guile to ban WAGS and ketchup in one swift stroke, Mr. Capello sure as hell got his England tenure started off on the right path in 2008. But his inability to adapt tactically to those set out in front of him in addition to his communication skills or lack thereof, were the prop fellers to Capello’s once sea worthy vessel. The England players need an English manager, someone who gets the England mindset, but whom? Since an Englishman has yet to win England’s Premier League, the list of suitable replacements stand about as long as England’s Shaun Wright-Phillips is tall. In his mumbling, broken English, did Capello ever possess the ability to inspire the troops the way other British managers like Bill Shankly or Brian Clough could? For England to emerge out of this international football desert, they’ll need to appoint an English manager soon who can inspire and instill a sense of pride in playing for England that this current squad lacks.
  • England needs to change their footballing cultureWe’re tired, Mom, when are we gonna be there? We’re bored. England fans and players always seem to come up with a myriad of excuses as to why they under perform. Whether it’s the long domestic season, a ball, being bored at a World Cup – which let’s face it, is one of the best ever – the mentality of the English player is weak and pampered. For England to break through their 44 year slump, the culture surrounding the England team needs to change to one of a focused, fit, smart and thinking player. Hey, kind of like the Germans. Although it’s gotten better in recent years, the WAG and tabloid culture and the insanity of Premier League wages have all done their part in corrupting the mentality of the English player. England fans and the media are also to blame with the lofty expectations they impose upon the players who are nothing more than a third tier international side. Think of England as League One representatives while Argentina, Spain, Germany and Brazil occupy the traditional big 4 of the Premier League.
  • England players have to want it– You might think this is common sense, that of course the JT’s, the Stevie G’s, the Lamp’s, the Wazza’s and the Crouchie’s want to win, but do they really? This tournament more than any other has shown England fans some incredibly scared and ultimately tired looking performances that I don’t recollect seeing from any other national team competing in the World Cup.  And yes, a World Cup where so many other players compete in top European leagues with equally as insane schedules. But maybe these boys do have a case for being burnt out and reaching levels of exhaustion. Will the FA ever look into a winter break like the German Bundesliga has? As the first two group stage games played out to a relatively boring and lackluster draw, it was clear to me that England lacked what the US was so full of this tournament. Heart and desire. I saw it on Sunday in sections when England were eventually eliminated, but it’s something that has to be infectious and on display throughout. In a tournament this competitive, ability and skill alone will never be enough to progress past the round of 16. Pride, passion and desire – three traits many of these English players lacked – must compliment natural footballing talent for success to be achieved.
  • England must catch up tactically to that of the rest of the world4-4-2, surely the best way to catch up with the rest of the evolving football world. In a tournament that has seen Chile and Algeria play 3 at the back with moderate to good success, and a tournament that has seen many teams play a preferred 4-2-3-1, England have reverted to the classic old 4-4-2 formation that saw their midfield struggle all tournament and all day against Germany in servicing the 2 central strikers because of their man disadvantage in the midfield. Overlooked by many to their own detriment, tactics are so important especially in international football these days and also especially for England. England seem to have the personnel, but rarely understand or know how to get the best out of the players on offer. In Sunday’s match v Germany, the more tactically astute Germans played a continental style 4-2-3-1 which gifted Germany the man advantage in midfield while England chased and chased. The formation was half the battle, Germany also possessed the ability to exploit the weakness presented in front of them with the advantage they had. Time after time, Mesut Ozil and the German attacking front drew out England’s center backs which created gaps for others to run into. These attacking movements created Germany’s second goal which allowed them to then sit back and pick off England on the counter attack. England left again in the stone age of football tactics.
  • The Youth are starting to changeso sang MGMT, but the lack of a strong youth presence at this World Cup was devoid like that of a strong tactical plan to serve Rooney up front. England’s U21 in fact made an impressive run to last summer’s Euro 2009 Championship before losing in emphatic fashion to Germany, 4-0. On that side of impressive young Englishmen, only James Milner made the plane to South Africa while 4 Germans – a respectable balance between young and old – started the game on Sunday that earned Germany a trip to the quarter finals. The list of potentially good young English players runs a mile long, but if these players aren’t brought in and nurtured on an international level thus gaining valuable experience, then the gap between England and the rest of the world will widen. And what of the next generation of potential England players? The 9, 10, and 11 year old kids currently focusing their talents in the youth development leagues of England. Will these players come good on their potential in a fledgling youth system? Certainly more questions than answers as the pain of elimination is still so fresh.

England have a serious mountain to climb if they’re to reach the summit of international football again in mine or anyone else’s lifetime. The FA need a clear and concise plan, a date set for accomplishment and a restructuring of their organization in order for England to move forward. If they revert to more of the same, England fans can expect the same results for years to come.

11 thoughts on “5 Reasons Why England Aren’t Good Enough to Compete with the World’s Best”

  1. Good post Jesse-

    England’s lack of tactical flexibility is shocking. McLaren tried to play a 3-5-2 against Croatia in Zagreb to disastrous results, but that was the right idea. Pack the midfield, and expand the possibilities on the flanks. The problem was England’s wide midfielders didn’t defend well enough in that game.

    Hiring a foreign coach in Sven and now Capello have been clear admissions of failure in my book. When have Germany, Holland Italy, Brazil and Argentina hired foreigners? Never, or at least not in my lifetime. England demands to be placed among the world elite, but when you cannot even produce a list of decent managers (all of the countries I named export large numbers of managers to other domestic leagues and national teams) you are really behind the eight ball so to speak.

    Consider McLaren’s plight. He was almost too creative and tactically flexible for England. His success in Holland has come because he went to a 4-3-3 at Twente adjusting to his squad and now at Wolfsburg is certain to do the same if they keep Dzecko and Grafite. That way he can start O. Martins as well.

    I’m not sure about this “lack of hunger.” I think the unrealistic and ridiculous expectations of the British press and the England fans take a psychological toll on the players. I actually feel VERY SORRY for the three lions players as they are constantly expected to garner results well above their collective talent levels, tactical awareness/flexibility and technical ability.

    I would add to your post, England fans and the press need to be more realistic and less jingoistic about their national team. The vast majority of people I speak with that actually watch multiple domestic leagues and follow the international game did not consider England a contender this year and only thought of them as an outside contender in 2006, when the English press was convinced it had the best team in the world. By placing so much unrealistic pressure on the players you see the performances you do.

    England has not been to a major final since 1966. I once rattled off the nations that have been to major finals since and an English friend of mine told me to stop making up things. Denial is all around. Germany has advanced further than England in ELEVEN straight World Cups indicating that these problems aren’t new and are not limited to the Premier League, which is being blamed by many xenophobes and 606 callers for England’s demise.

    Until a full accounting is taken of England’s structure, nothing will change. England will simply continue to be noisy outsiders at the party of world football elites.

  2. No technical, no tactical.

    These guys couldn’t string three passes together until German intentionally let them. You can talk tactics all day long, but if you don’t have players who can make it happen, it does not matter. No formation on the planet changes the fact that Gareth Barry and John Terry are slow and gave balls away. Until you create a culture where your defenders are as comfortable on the ball as your strikers, you don’t have a chance.

  3. Great article.

    As a Brazilian, though, I had to go back and take a look on your “Five Reasons Why Brazil Won’t Win the World Cup and Five Reasons Why England Could” article.

    I don’t think Brazil will win the World Cup – Argentina and Germany are both looking stronger in my point of view. If we are not careful, Bielsa will teach us a lesson today – and I tell you he is VERY capable of doing so.

    But your points on why Brazil woudn’t win were kind of pathetic, really.

    Weather: most of our players play in Europe during the winter and are well adapted. Brazil has cold winters too. Forget the image of Brazil as a tropical paradise with wild animals roaming the streets…

    Not Enough Brazilian Outfield Players Playing for Top European Clubs: which most of England’s players do, to no international success whatsoever. We produce talented players everyday (ex.: Ganso, Neymar, the list goes on) and they usually play as a whole in the national side. Moreso, we have arguably the best defense in the world (compare Julio Cesar, Lucio and Maicon to James, JT and Johnson).

    Kaká: ok, he’s not in his best shape, but imagine the impact of such a player – fast and creative – on the English side. Kaká is the most objective Brazilian player to ever grace the pitch, and due to his characteristics, Brazil implemented a style of play in which counter-attacks can be deadly. Germany understood the importance of counter-attacking and used it to devastating effects yesterday.

    Dunga Doesn’t Seem Confident: oh, he does. In fact, he’s overconfident (another reason I can’t stand him at all).

    Who is the Star on this Brazil Team?: Lucio, Julio Cesar, Maicon, Kaká – take your pick. But don’t forget that stars don’t win World Cups. We had many of them in the 2006 World Cup (Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Adriano, Kaká, etc.) and it didn’t work out. And by the way: who is the star of Germany’s team?


  4. England squeaked by the group stage and then got kicked out by a really good German side at the round of 16. This has all happened before. Is the sky really falling?

    I would say average performance for England is somewhere between the round of 16 and the quarter-finals. A really great performance for them is the semi-finals. Jesse, this is par for the course. That doesn’t mean we can’t compete with the world’s best – it means we can sometimes compete with the world’s best and sometimes get destroyed by the world’s best. Welcome to being an England supporter. This isn’t new.

    Is this really such a shock or a reason to say we’re much more terrible (or better) than we usually are?

    The media always hypes up the team. But the media in every country hypes up their team (look at ESPN in the States – Lalas spoke multiple times about the US going to the semi-finals). If you talk to 90% of the England fans, they had hopes of a semi-final run before the Cup started. After seeing the side in group play, they probably were thinking that we’d possibly squeak by Germany and get kicked out by Argentina. I don’t know if that’s incredibly unrealistic. Similarly, everyone around me in the US was talking about the tough game they’d have with Uruguay before Ghana even kicked the ball. Media hype is ridiculous and fans get carried away but it’s a result of the passion for football.

    I do agree with two ideas here:

    Stop with the four-four-‘effing-two. These players play on clubs in England that do not play four-four-two. They are capable of playing something else and even (gasp) changing formating game to game or even (gasp again) mid-game.

    Relating to that, there are two good English managers off the top of my head that would jump at the opportunity to coach England. Harry Redknapp is one that and Roy Hodgeson is the obviously best choice.

  5. This is a hypothetical (spelling?) and could be an excellent piece for the website.

    If the four United Kingdom FAs (England, Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland) all combined into one national team, would they have a better shot at winning a World Cup before the United States?

    I would love to see a discussion on this one. As an American, I would have to say that a combined UK team would win before the USA, but I would not be surprised if the reverse happened.

    1. excellent question. I think they would. The question I’m not sure about tho is – will England win a world cup before the US. I’m not sure I know the answer to THAT question.

  6. There is a number of reasons why England didn’t do well. I don’t agree with the long season being an excuse. The number of league and cup games is exhausting. How many other leagues take breaks and have so many cup games? There is also a problem with mentality. Because England haven’t won anything they think mentality they cannot win anything. The lack of team work was also on show. To win anything you need to play as a team and work as a team, which is what the Germans did (despite not having the best players in the world). The expectations are too high. How can anyone expect England to do well as they haven’t won anything. England though played much better in qualifiers. I disagree that England had an easy qualifying group – no international teams are easy anymore and expect to get beat 10-0 even Andorra. Beating Croatia is not that easy. There is not enough English talent and a lack of experience playing abroad, which would help England players getting used to playing different styles etc but also coming back to play for England means they would look forward to it more, rather than simply playing in the Premier League all year without a break, with the same old English players. Technically English players are not as good and indeed British and Irish players generally, they need to keep the ball not just get rid of it. But I never hear the Irish complain about their squad and over expect things – they are just happy to be in a world cup. At least England are winning games and competing in world cups, people should be grateful and not at the bottom of qualifying groups. There are many things wrong but simply attacking people does nothing – people need to do something about it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *