Should FIFA Ban the Vuvuzela for the Duration of the World Cup?

June 14, 2010 - Cape Town, SOUTH AFRICA - A street vendor sells Vuvuzelas before a World Cup game Monday, June 14, 2010 near Green Point Stadium in Cape Town, South Africa.

Whether you’re new to the World Cup or you’re taking in your tenth finals, you’re sure to have noticed the incessant drone at matches this past weekend from the stadium horns known as vuvuzelas that are so common in South Africa. Love them or hate them, it seems the vuvuzela, or lepatata is as much apart of football in South Africa as crowd songs are in England or hot dogs are in American baseball. Is the vuvuzela really ruining the World Cup experience across the globe? They seem to be here to stay for the remainder of the tournament, or will they?

Before you make up your mind on the vuvuzela, let’s look at the positives and negatives of what I like to call the plastic bee. On the negative side, besides the obvious, reports have surfaced from players who’ve said that they’re unable to hear other players on the pitch. If this is to be believed, could the vuvuzela somehow effect the outcome of an important match? The swarm of bees-like drone has overpowered national anthems, fan songs and chants, and has been a major distraction and annoyance for commentators and millions watching on television across the world.

Major Television broadcasters have spent millions of dollars to bring unprecedented coverage of the tournament to the masses only for their investment to be potentially buzzed out by the horns that only seem to get louder as matches progress. If lower than expected viewership and TV ratings surface at the end of the tournament, will the vuvuzela become a vilified entity in the annals of history outside of South Africa?

Earplug sales in South Africa are rumored to be high as fans attending matches are becoming increasingly concerned with hearing damage and or hearing loss. A potential ban of the vuvuzela is no new thing. After last years Confederations Cup in South Africa, FIFA was flooded with thousands of emails from fans pleading with soccer’s governing body to ban the horn for this summer’s World Cup. It seems as if the emails fell on deaf ears.

So what positives can be taken from such an over-powering sound? According to FIFA, the vuvuzela is said to be too entrenched in the culture of South Africa to even consider a serious ban. And isn’t accepting a different culture what the World Cup is all about? How would the English or other European countries feel if outsiders protested against crowd songs or the removal of banners at matches?

For now it looks as if the vuvuzela is here to stay unless it poses some form of health risk, i.e., if fans attempt to throw them on the pitch or use them as weapons. The plastic horn means too much to the South African people and their culture for FIFA to swoop in and take them away from the fans who have represented themselves so brilliantly thus far.

Viewers in the UK may soon have a reprieve of the noise within the next few days. Due to hundreds of complaints, the BBC is considering an option that would allow match viewers to mute ambient background noise while still being able to hear match commentary. The option would allow viewers to press a button on their remote and receive a quieter version of the broadcast on a different channel. The alternate channel may not be a bad compromise for viewers who can take the noise no longer.

Regardless of your opinion, the majority of us better get used to the buzz for the next month if we plan on watching more matches simply because it seems FIFA refuse to take the controversial step of banning the horn. If you hate the vuvuzela, leave a comment below explaining why FIFA should ban them. If you don’t mind the bee-like buzz and think it adds to the experience in South Africa, defend FIFA’s decision to allow them at matches.

Contact Jesse on Twitter @JesseChula

Meanwhile, if you want to let ESPN know how you feel about the vuvuzelas, whether you love them or hate them, find out more information about how to contact ESPN.

139 Comments

  1. Rob Sedgwick June 15, 2010
  2. Raatzie June 15, 2010
  3. footballfutbolfitba June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
      • Bishopville Red June 15, 2010
        • Raatzie June 15, 2010
        • Ginger Joe June 15, 2010
  4. Jose June 15, 2010
  5. Meg June 15, 2010
    • robert poverello June 15, 2010
  6. Ndixman 'weMPopoma (waterfalls) Ndiweni June 15, 2010
    • robert poverello June 15, 2010
      • SHARON JONES June 16, 2010
  7. James June 15, 2010
    • robert poverello June 15, 2010
    • M June 15, 2010
  8. David C. June 15, 2010
    • Duke June 15, 2010
  9. MC Pope June 15, 2010
  10. Jesse Chula June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  11. Raatzie June 15, 2010
    • cincyspurs June 15, 2010
      • Raatzie June 15, 2010
    • McBride June 15, 2010
      • Raatzie June 15, 2010
        • McBride June 15, 2010
          • Raatzie June 15, 2010
          • McBride June 15, 2010
          • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  12. Anything-but-horny June 15, 2010
  13. Jason Gatties June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
    • Robert June 15, 2010
  14. Steve June 15, 2010
  15. Herbert June 15, 2010
  16. Tinnitus June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  17. Thomas June 15, 2010
  18. John Abassian June 15, 2010
  19. Raffi June 15, 2010
  20. G.Hersch June 15, 2010
  21. Robert June 15, 2010
    • Duke June 15, 2010
  22. Brian June 15, 2010
    • Duke June 15, 2010
  23. Dave June 15, 2010
  24. GUP June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  25. Lyle June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  26. Carl Jago June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  27. Lyle June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
      • M June 15, 2010
        • Raatzie June 16, 2010
  28. Jim June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
      • Patrick June 15, 2010
        • Raatzie June 15, 2010
    • M June 15, 2010
  29. Bayern82 June 15, 2010
  30. Vuvuzela June 15, 2010
  31. Machojesus June 15, 2010
    • Patrick June 15, 2010
  32. Ste M June 15, 2010
  33. IanCransonsKnees June 15, 2010
  34. Mike June 15, 2010
    • Patrick June 15, 2010
  35. joe June 15, 2010
  36. Tim June 15, 2010
  37. elizabeth Jones June 15, 2010
  38. joe June 15, 2010
    • Duke June 15, 2010
  39. CT_Blues2006 June 15, 2010
  40. Bayern82 June 15, 2010
  41. efrain June 15, 2010
  42. Matt T. June 15, 2010
  43. Matt T. June 15, 2010
  44. ovalball June 15, 2010
  45. unimpressed June 15, 2010
    • CT_Blues2006 June 15, 2010
  46. VuvuzelaLove June 15, 2010
  47. Angelo June 15, 2010
  48. Raatzie June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  49. Patrick June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 15, 2010
  50. Jesse Chula June 15, 2010
    • The Gaffer June 15, 2010
      • M June 15, 2010
        • Buzzbored June 15, 2010
          • M June 15, 2010
  51. Eious June 15, 2010
  52. gary June 15, 2010
  53. Darren Brogden June 15, 2010
  54. john June 15, 2010
  55. Buzzbored June 15, 2010
  56. zv June 15, 2010
  57. LeeView June 15, 2010
  58. Don Wood June 15, 2010
  59. US Soccer Fan June 15, 2010
    • Jeff June 15, 2010
  60. Vuvuno June 15, 2010
  61. drcbk June 15, 2010
  62. James Dean June 15, 2010
  63. Stephane June 15, 2010
  64. buzzbored June 15, 2010
  65. LFerr June 15, 2010
  66. LFerr June 15, 2010
    • Raatzie June 16, 2010
  67. Patty Sidune June 16, 2010
    • Raatzie June 16, 2010
    • Duke June 16, 2010
      • Duke June 16, 2010
  68. Sagar June 16, 2010
  69. Al June 16, 2010
  70. Alex June 16, 2010
  71. M June 16, 2010
  72. Mick June 16, 2010
  73. Machojesus June 16, 2010
  74. graeme boreham June 17, 2010
  75. graeme boreham June 17, 2010
  76. Domenico June 20, 2010
  77. JohnA June 21, 2010
  78. JohnA June 21, 2010
  79. Mick June 21, 2010
  80. Mick June 21, 2010
  81. Andrew June 21, 2010
  82. Karanth Srihari June 22, 2010
  83. sal June 23, 2010
  84. slimj091 June 23, 2010
  85. slimj091 June 23, 2010
    • Sean June 23, 2010
  86. Domenico June 23, 2010
  87. A June 25, 2010
  88. Paul S. June 28, 2010
  89. Dino June 28, 2010

Leave a Reply