Was Howard Webb Correct in Giving Manchester United a Penalty v Liverpool?

The weekend’s biggest match saw some great, some solid and some absent performances from both sides. I believe the 2-1 scoreline in favor of Manchester United was a good indication of how United dominated possession and created more clear cut chances than Liverpool. That said, Liverpool impressed me throughout the afternoon as they refused to gift United the space they crave in attack to crush opponents by 3 or 4 goals. Liverpool were quick to close down United in midfield, stayed organized, and the ever-dangerous Fernando Torres probably should have equalized for Liverpool late in the game.

One could argue that Liverpool set up slightly negative against United implementing more defensive tactics than earlier in the week when a 5 man attacking front saw off Portsmouth 4-1. Such is it that Old Trafford isn’t Anfield, so Liverpool, more specifically, Rafael Benitez trudged onward with the formation he saw fit.

Early on in Sunday’s match, the tactics implemented by Benitez seemed to be working when Liverpool snatched an early 1-0 lead from a Fernando Torres header in the 5th minute. It was only the opening moments of the encounter, but with a 1-0 lead, Liverpool seemed to be in the ascendancy as United struggled with cohesion.

Big matches always seem to create moments of controversey when both sides are evenly matched and not looking to give even the slightest advantage to their opponents. Cue the 10th minute of the match when Liverpool defender Javier Mascherano bundled over United’s Antonio Valencia in the box prompting England’s #1 Howard Webb to award Manchester United a penalty.

In real time, the foul looked like a blantant penalty and Mascherano must have felt lucky not to have been sent off as he was the last defender between Valencia and the Liverpool goal. Replays due however show that initial contact was in fact made outside of the box while Valencia’s momentum took him into the box where contact continued and where he was eventually felled. The Liverpool players immeaditley pointed to a spot on the field directly outside the penalty area hoping Webb would award United a free kick outside of the box instead of the game changing penalty.

Rafa Benitez has since come out criticizing Webb for his decision stating Valencia took a dive to win the penalty. Although Benitez was quoted as saying he thinks Webb is a “good referee”, his statements of displeasure with the penalty being awarded originate from Webb’s decision to give it in the first place. As we all know, Wayne Rooney slotted home his own rebound when Pepe Reina saved from the spot thus leveling the score. The damage had been done for Liverpool when both teams were again on equal grounds. United went on to win the possession battle and found the winner in the second half while Liverpool were left to rue what could have been had the moment of controversy not originated.

Manchester United returned to top of the league while Liverpool sit 18 points behind in 6th with their potential 4th place finish hanging by a thread.

Do you think Howard Webb was correct in giving the game changing penalty? How do you think Webb will perform this summer at the World Cup Finals? Is Howard Webb really the best English referee who’s just having an off season?

123 Comments

  1. HaggsTheRed March 22, 2010
    • Simon BUrke March 22, 2010
    • PeteNutz April 10, 2010
  2. Mike March 22, 2010
    • PeteNutz April 10, 2010
  3. Adeel March 22, 2010
    • Miak March 22, 2010
  4. Peter March 22, 2010
    • Tomy March 22, 2010
    • PeteNutz April 10, 2010
  5. sidney March 22, 2010
  6. sidney March 22, 2010
    • Jeff March 22, 2010
      • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
        • wozza March 22, 2010
          • The_NZA March 23, 2010
  7. James March 22, 2010
  8. OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
    • wozza March 22, 2010
      • Jesse March 22, 2010
        • wozza March 22, 2010
          • Jesse March 22, 2010
    • Josh March 22, 2010
      • Miak March 22, 2010
        • johnsy March 22, 2010
        • Josh March 22, 2010
    • Yespage March 22, 2010
      • wozza March 22, 2010
        • Yespage March 22, 2010
        • KingKenny March 22, 2010
          • Yespage March 23, 2010
      • PeteNutz April 10, 2010
    • Tomy March 22, 2010
    • 7Spink11 March 22, 2010
    • Tyson March 22, 2010
  9. Kishore March 22, 2010
    • Jesse Chula March 22, 2010
  10. James March 22, 2010
    • The Gaffer March 22, 2010
      • James March 23, 2010
        • The Gaffer March 23, 2010
  11. SFGooner March 22, 2010
  12. doros March 22, 2010
  13. Mish March 22, 2010
    • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
      • The Ultimate ABU (Anyone But United) March 22, 2010
        • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
          • KingKenny March 22, 2010
  14. Fish March 22, 2010
    • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
      • The Ultimate ABU (Anyone But United) March 22, 2010
  15. Bishopville Red March 22, 2010
    • Jesse Chula March 22, 2010
  16. Chris from Texas March 22, 2010
    • Bishopville Red March 22, 2010
      • Josh March 22, 2010
  17. Mike March 22, 2010
  18. Xile March 22, 2010
  19. OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
  20. Kuyts reflection March 22, 2010
    • RVPFan March 22, 2010
  21. wiuru March 22, 2010
    • Josh March 22, 2010
      • Andrei March 22, 2010
        • Josh March 22, 2010
        • Jesse March 22, 2010
  22. man99utd March 22, 2010
  23. The Ultimate Abu (Anyone But United) March 22, 2010
    • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
      • The Ultimate ABU (Anyone But United) March 22, 2010
        • Gaz March 22, 2010
          • Tyson March 22, 2010
          • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
          • Gaz March 22, 2010
  24. man99utd March 22, 2010
  25. Pat March 22, 2010
  26. Xile March 22, 2010
  27. Kishore March 22, 2010
  28. James Milnerr March 22, 2010
  29. Gaz March 22, 2010
  30. iangnu March 22, 2010
    • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
      • The Ultimate ABU (Anyone But United) March 22, 2010
        • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
  31. iangnu March 22, 2010
  32. scouser March 22, 2010
  33. The devil March 22, 2010
  34. Fred M March 22, 2010
  35. the anti-scouse March 22, 2010
    • Tyson March 22, 2010
  36. Mish March 22, 2010
  37. Mish March 22, 2010
    • wozza March 22, 2010
    • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
  38. Petzl March 22, 2010
    • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
      • Gaz March 22, 2010
        • OleGunnar20 March 23, 2010
          • Gaz March 23, 2010
          • OleGunnar20 March 23, 2010
          • Gaz March 23, 2010
  39. Mish March 22, 2010
    • wozza March 22, 2010
      • Tyson March 22, 2010
      • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
    • OleGunnar20 March 22, 2010
  40. EastTerracer March 22, 2010
  41. Simon Burke March 22, 2010
  42. David Summers March 22, 2010
  43. Jeff March 22, 2010
  44. Gaz March 23, 2010
    • Tyson March 23, 2010
      • Alistair Hendrie March 23, 2010
    • Petzl March 23, 2010
      • Gaz March 23, 2010
  45. Justin March 23, 2010
  46. Petzl March 23, 2010
  47. James March 23, 2010
  48. StevieM777 March 24, 2010
  49. ugk March 25, 2010
  50. ridic March 26, 2010

Leave a Reply