Man United 2-1 Arsenal: Did Wayne Rooney Dive?

wayne-rooney-dive

In a game of football, there are 9,500 seconds or more for players to score, so why are matches so often decided by a single controversial incident that flashes by in a few seconds?

Take Manchester United’s 2-1 victory over Arsenal on Saturday, for example. Never mind the fact that both teams had a handful of relatively easy chances to put the game away. But it was one incident more than any that changed the landscape of this game and that was the penalty decision by Mike Dean after the clash between Wayne Rooney and Manuel Almunia.

Bottom line, Mike Dean had to award a penalty in this incidence. For him not to would have been a monumentally bad decision whether it was at Old Trafford or not.

BUT, the fact of the matter is that Wayne Rooney played for the penalty. He knew it was a race between himself and Almunia for the ball and he knew that if he timed his run perfectly that he could make contact with the ball and that Almunia wouldn’t be able to stop himself from knocking down Rooney.

But did Mike Dean in fact make the correct decision?

It’s a really tough call. In the heat of the game, I believe Dean made the correct decision. However, if you analyze the incident in slow-motion, you’ll notice that after Rooney knocks the ball ahead of Almunia’s grasp, Rooney begins to fall forward before Almunia makes contact with him.

To me, the decision of whether Mike Dean was correct comes down to whether he’s able to use technology or not. In the heat of the game and in real-time, it looks like a penalty. But if he was able to use video replay and slow-motion, he would have seen that Rooney dove.

This is a perfect example of how referees have an almost impossible job to get the decisions correct. Their job, I believe, will be made even harder if/when additional assistant referees are placed behind goals to see if balls cross the line and to help referees with decisions like these. Again, because they won’t have video replay or technology to help them out, they’re only as good as their eyes and brains are seeing incidents like this in real-time. The addition of these assistant referees behind goals is not going to make eradicate wrong decisions — it’ll only reduce them.

To me, if referees had the aid of technology, they would have seen that Rooney did in fact dive to win the penalty and should have received a yellow card. That said, Rooney didn’t have to dive. If he hadn’t fallen forward, Almunia would have knocked him down. But Rooney didn’t want to take the chance of Almunia somehow avoiding contact with him, which is why I believe he dove.

This one incident shows how flawed the sport of soccer is. If this was the NFL, you would have TV replays to categorically make sure that the correct call was made. But in soccer, there is always going to be controversy for as long as technology is not used.

Imagine what the reaction would have been at Old Trafford if Dean hadn’t awarded that penalty. Blooming heck!

Here’s the reaction of a few select bloggers and football fans on Twitter to the incident:

arseblog-twitter

bpfootball-twitter

chowie74-twitter

richardfarley-twitter

So the controversy rages on. United get the three points and Arsene Wenger is understandably furious. What’s your reaction to the incident and do you believe video technology should be used in games, should Rooney have received a yellow card or am I totally wrong with my analysis? Click the comments link below and share your opinion.

Was Mike Dean correct in awarding a penalty?(answers)

156 Comments

  1. Ryan August 29, 2009
    • Bradley lloydeplt September 26, 2009
  2. s August 29, 2009
    • TINS August 30, 2009
      • me August 30, 2009
        • TINS August 30, 2009
          • Cavalier September 3, 2009
        • amigo August 30, 2009
          • Poinsy August 30, 2009
          • crispine September 2, 2009
      • Lugona September 1, 2009
    • Simon September 14, 2009
  3. Bobby August 29, 2009
  4. Parag August 29, 2009
    • PJ August 30, 2009
    • col August 31, 2009
  5. sucka99 August 29, 2009
    • TINS August 30, 2009
    • amigo August 30, 2009
  6. Mikey D. Tan August 29, 2009
    • amigo August 30, 2009
  7. Darius August 29, 2009
  8. dave August 29, 2009
    • carl August 30, 2009
    • Barry August 30, 2009
      • Finn August 31, 2009
      • KaE September 10, 2009
  9. desigunner August 29, 2009
    • TINS August 30, 2009
      • me August 30, 2009
        • TINS August 30, 2009
          • col August 31, 2009
        • lozcast August 30, 2009
          • Dean Wheatley August 31, 2009
    • Matt August 30, 2009
      • col August 31, 2009
      • Jack August 31, 2009
  10. Clair August 29, 2009
  11. Arindam Maulick August 29, 2009
  12. Andrei August 29, 2009
  13. Goon August 29, 2009
  14. Jay August 29, 2009
  15. Mark Christopher August 29, 2009
  16. Cantona August 29, 2009
    • Bobby August 29, 2009
      • TINS August 30, 2009
        • deebs August 30, 2009
        • Bobby August 30, 2009
          • carl August 30, 2009
  17. SF Gooner August 29, 2009
    • goonergone August 29, 2009
  18. SF Gooner August 29, 2009
  19. Mark Christopher August 29, 2009
    • col August 31, 2009
  20. gooner August 29, 2009
    • TINS August 30, 2009
      • me August 30, 2009
        • Matt August 30, 2009
  21. SF Gooner August 29, 2009
  22. Kevin_amold August 29, 2009
  23. Isaiah August 29, 2009
  24. Jose August 29, 2009
  25. GazzaJ87 August 29, 2009
  26. Tanner August 29, 2009
    • Angryjohn September 4, 2009
  27. George August 29, 2009
    • TINS August 30, 2009
  28. realisticffan August 29, 2009
  29. ovalball August 29, 2009
  30. noname August 29, 2009
    • TINS August 30, 2009
  31. Ganesh August 29, 2009
  32. Harry Barracuda August 30, 2009
    • SF Gooner August 30, 2009
  33. Matt August 30, 2009
    • Grant August 30, 2009
  34. not so realistic fan August 30, 2009
  35. nick August 30, 2009
    • TINS August 30, 2009
  36. useroz August 30, 2009
  37. Brad August 30, 2009
    • Gooner4eva August 30, 2009
  38. Chris Grey August 30, 2009
  39. Me2 August 30, 2009
  40. Bryan August 30, 2009
  41. alan August 30, 2009
    • Bryan August 30, 2009
  42. Bryan August 30, 2009
  43. Baz August 30, 2009
  44. Gooner4eva August 30, 2009
  45. Tyson August 30, 2009
  46. Baz August 30, 2009
  47. Kay August 30, 2009
  48. Tomaso August 30, 2009
    • Rose Tinted Glasses August 30, 2009
  49. Grant August 30, 2009
    • Kay J August 30, 2009
      • Grant August 30, 2009
        • Kay J August 30, 2009
          • Grant August 31, 2009
          • hank August 31, 2009
  50. gooner4life August 30, 2009
  51. Bombtune August 30, 2009
  52. Geoff August 30, 2009
  53. LI Matt August 30, 2009
  54. Bryan August 30, 2009
  55. Jean August 30, 2009
  56. Shakira August 30, 2009
  57. UnitedAmanda August 30, 2009
    • Grant August 30, 2009
  58. Jean August 30, 2009
    • Grant August 30, 2009
      • Kay J August 30, 2009
        • Grant August 31, 2009
  59. yuds fabregas August 30, 2009
    • Kay J August 30, 2009
      • Bobby August 30, 2009
        • Kay J August 30, 2009
          • Grant August 31, 2009
          • hank August 31, 2009
  60. Kevin Coleman August 30, 2009
  61. bigdavestar August 30, 2009
  62. SSReporters August 30, 2009
  63. GazzaJ87 August 30, 2009
  64. Anthony August 30, 2009
  65. Tomaso August 30, 2009
  66. Ken August 30, 2009
    • dlink09 August 30, 2009
  67. dlink09 August 30, 2009
  68. Grant August 31, 2009
  69. andre August 31, 2009
  70. Hunter August 31, 2009
  71. shawn howard August 31, 2009
  72. trey August 31, 2009
  73. Uarafool August 31, 2009
  74. jaavidhth August 31, 2009
  75. El August 31, 2009
  76. TeflonFong September 1, 2009
  77. hary September 1, 2009
  78. Ian B September 1, 2009
  79. Gaz September 1, 2009
  80. JR September 1, 2009
  81. Dave S September 2, 2009
  82. mike n September 3, 2009
  83. Bob Skillet September 3, 2009
  84. Shrek September 3, 2009
  85. lol September 3, 2009
  86. Ed September 3, 2009
  87. SherZ September 4, 2009
  88. SherZ September 4, 2009
  89. jordan dean September 4, 2009
  90. Rumy September 6, 2009
  91. KaE September 10, 2009
  92. Gunz December 2, 2009
  93. Gooner Wenger December 14, 2009

Leave a Reply