US 0-5 Mexico: El Tri Triumphs After Poor Tournament


Javier Aguirre got a monkey off his back. After a struggle of a tournament which saw El Tri struggle with the likes of Nicaragua and Panama and also need PKs to beat Costa Rica, the Mexican “B” team triumphed today at Giants Stadium.

This same El Tri side didn’t score a legitimate goal versus Nicaragua, a nation that was playing in its first ever major international tournament for 85 minutes. Yet today, they tore apart the Americans in the 2nd half scoring five goals, and perhaps feeling hard done  not to have scored more.

The US controlled much of the first half, but failed to make its chances pay. The insertion of Carlos Vela changed the game in Mexico’s favor. The US lost its composure after the first Mexican goal: an ironic role reversal from the psychological warfare of recent US-Mexico games.

The gamble of playing Gio Dos Santos up front eventually paid off for Aguirre. Early in the match it seemed Gio was lost up top, not seeing as much of the ball as he has when playing on the right side of El Tri’s midfield. Vela and Dos Santos dominate: get used to that storyline- we could be hearing it for years to come.

The US had a clear penalty shout in the first half, when Clarence Goodson was taken down on a corner kick- but no call was made. Robbie Rogers had a clear chance to finish a great cross from Stuart Holden in the 48th minute and didn’t. At the time Mexico was already looking frustrated and losing their cool, a storyline we have seen before. The penalty call on Jay Heaps was shocking, especially given that referee Courtney Campbell has had the reputation in Mexico of being a pro-American.

Dos Santos not only went to ground easily, but he hit Heaps in the face clearly affecting the way the play looked from afar. After Gerrado Torrado, the veteran of this Mexico “B” squad converted the PK, El Tri never looked back. In fact Goalkeeper Troy Perkins kept the scoreline from being more embarrassing, and Robbie Rogers got away with a take down of Dos Santos in the area later. (Perhaps a make up call by Campbell?).

Still the US had a solid tournament, exceeding all realistic expectations. However, the performance in the final provided Mexico with a bigger margin of victory than it had against several weak opponents in the last year when stronger El Tri sides were fielded. So despite reaching the final, the American performance in the final will certainly make Bob Bradley’s decisions about certain players easier going forward.

Bradley, to his credit was the best coach in the tournament and he out thought Aguirre today setting up the US in an aggressive way which gave the Mexican defense fits. But the lack of class in this American side eventually showed. Even more apparent was the lack of composure this side showed. I know this is an unpopular and politically incorrect opinion but that is an outgrowth of the bulk of this team playing in MLS.

I am sure some fans will blame Bob Bradley for this performance which is laughable. But now we know why Bradley is reluctant to play too many MLS based players at once in a big game. MLS is a league that is good in spurts- but it’s tough to find players that play consistently for a full 90 minutes and it is a league where you see teams lose their shape and appear disorganized for long periods of matches. I’ve made these points before and continue to make them when observing MLS matches.

But Bob Bradley still makes changes late, allowing opposing managers to dictate second halves. We saw this versus Italy and Brazil in the Confederations Cup and again today. In some ways, Bradley is a victim of his own success: his pregame tactics work so effectively that the opposing manager makes radical changes (in this case it was the insertion of Vela and dropping Dos Santos back into a roaming role behind Vela and Miguel Sabah) to change the game.

We also now know why Bradley has been so eager to re-discover the form for certain players: Eddie Johnson for instance whose speed and finishing touch is something the US lacks. The fact is the player pool is not as deep as some may have thought and this Mexican team is a define “B” side having retained only 7 of 23 players from the last set of World Cup qualifiers and having struggled to beat some weak opposition in the last three weeks.

Stuart Holden leaves this tournament as a player that needs to be retained for the trip to Azteca. Even when the other American field players were jogging at the end of the game, Holden was fighting until the end, not willing to allow El Tri to play with one another for the remainder of the game. Holden, was clearly the player of the tournament for the USA.

Troy Perkins has clearly established himself as the third or even possible second choice goalkeeper. Perkins has improved a great deal since transferring to Norway a year and a half ago.

Player Ratings (US)

Perkins 6

Heaps 4

Marshall 4

Goodson 5

Pearce 6

Beckerman 4

Pause 4

Rogers 5

Holden 7

Ching 6

Arnaud 5

Cooper 5

Quaranta 5

Cronin NR


Ochoa 7

Magallon 8

Castro 7

Pinto 7

Valenzuela 6

Juarez 7

Torrado 8

Castro 7

Medina 7

Sabah 7

Dos Santos 9

Vela 9

Franco 8



  1. Julius July 26, 2009
  2. Jared Montz July 26, 2009
  3. Lars July 26, 2009
  4. Phillip July 26, 2009
  5. Arnie July 26, 2009
  6. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 26, 2009
  7. Jose July 26, 2009
  8. Mexican Football July 26, 2009
  9. eplnfl July 26, 2009
  10. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 26, 2009
  11. joseph July 26, 2009
  12. kyle July 26, 2009
  13. Rafael July 26, 2009
  14. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 26, 2009
  15. Seybold July 26, 2009
  16. HSNCal July 26, 2009
  17. Jammer July 26, 2009
  18. BC July 26, 2009
  19. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 26, 2009
  20. Mexican July 26, 2009
  21. C Webb July 26, 2009
  22. HSNCal July 26, 2009
  23. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 26, 2009
  24. eplnfl July 26, 2009
  25. BC July 26, 2009
  26. LI Matt July 26, 2009
  27. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 26, 2009
  28. Fernando July 26, 2009
  29. WIll July 26, 2009
  30. David Griffith July 26, 2009
  31. chris July 27, 2009
  32. chris July 27, 2009
  33. Angel July 27, 2009
  34. Franciso July 27, 2009
  35. eplnfl July 27, 2009
  36. Angel July 27, 2009
  37. Ivan A. July 27, 2009
  38. Futbol Mexicana July 27, 2009
  39. Andrew July 27, 2009
  40. Ace July 27, 2009
  41. jake July 27, 2009
  42. Frank July 27, 2009
  43. Ronny July 27, 2009
  44. kralmajales July 27, 2009
  45. Football Tactician July 27, 2009
  46. LI Matt July 27, 2009
  47. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 27, 2009
  48. LI Matt July 27, 2009
  49. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 27, 2009
    • christopher August 8, 2009
  50. Carlos July 27, 2009
  51. tony July 27, 2009
  52. king chico July 27, 2009
  53. Om Mi July 28, 2009
  54. Mexico, 2009 Gold Cup Champions July 28, 2009
  55. Kartik Krishnaiyer July 28, 2009
  56. soccer goals July 28, 2009

Leave a Reply