WED, 2:45PM ET
LIV
REAL
WED, 2:45PM ET
AND
ARS
WED, 2:45PM ET
OLY
JUV
WED, 2:45PM ET
GAL
BVB
WED, 2:45PM ET
ATL
MAL
WED, 2:45PM ET
LEV
ZEN

Ryan Giggs Swipes PFA Award

He took down the long pass along the left side touchline. He turned the first West Ham defender who came at him and carried the ball into the box. Two quick touches and he turned the next defender as well. The box was still thick with players from the recent corner kick, but Giggs didn’t worry about anyone as he fired the ball through traffic, into the far corner. It was a beautiful goal and a brilliant solo effort. But it was PFA award winner Ryan Gigg’s only goal this season.

Yes, with a mere 12 starts and that one goal, Ryan Giggs bags this year’s PFA Footballer of the Year Award.

No former winner has come close to Giggs in terms of winning the award with so few starts. The next fewest starts for a PFA Footballer of the Year is almost twice Giggs’s numer at 23, attained by two other United stalwarts: Teddy Sheringham and Ruud van Nistelrooy. And while Giggs’s 12 appearances as a sub at least gets him closer to a reasonable amount of game-time, Sheringham and van Nistelrooy scored a lot more goals in their award-winning seasons. Sheringham: 15 goals in 2000-2001. van Nistelrooy: 23 goals in 2001-2002 (in 26 overall appearances, no less). True, they were both strikers, but if we’re talking about honoring accomplishment, their contributions made them obvious choices for those years.

Ryan Giggs winning can only be justified by his age and the length of time he’s played for United.

There is no question that Giggs is a great player and that the service he has given to United and football should be recognized. But the name of this accolade is Footballer of the Year. This award is meant to recognize accomplishments from a single year, not from an entire career. This is the award they gave Alan Shearer for 34 goals in 42 starts in 1995.

Giggs, while still a fine player with probably another year or two at the top level in him, is far from the peak of his career. He won the PFA Young Player two years in a row (1992, 1993) when his explosive talent was undeniable. But by giving him the award for 12 appearances and one goal, the Footballer of the Year award becomes more of a career achievement award. Which is simply wrong.

Perhaps the players who voted for him believe in Karma and hope this act will come back and ensure their careers are as long as Giggs. Knowing that Giggs’s career cannot go on forever, they wanted to make sure he received the award before he retired.

Many expected this year’s award to go to Steven Gerrard for his 13 goals in 27 appearances and this would seem far more in line with past winners. Along with Gerrard, Edwin van der Sar, Glen Johnson, Rio Ferdinand, Nemanja Vidic, Patrice Evra; Ashley Young, Ryan Giggs, Cristiano Ronaldo, Nicolas Anelka and Fernando Torres all made the PFA team of the year and any one of them has contributed more to the game this season than Mr Giggs.

The PFA gives out a Merit Award each year for service to Football on all levels. Jimmy Armfield, Alex Ferguson, George Best and Shaka Hislop are all among the recent winners. One could definitely see Ryan Giggs someday earning this accolade, but as far as Footballer of the Year goes: this should not have been his year.

This entry was posted in General, Leagues: EPL and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Ryan Giggs Swipes PFA Award

  1. tony says:

    That depends on what you call “contribution”. Is a contribution simply about goals and blocks. Or can contribution be something intangible like team spirit, morale, and leadership? I think players and managers are more in-tune with these type of contributions than viewers will ever be.

  2. dean says:

    ryan giggs what has he done this season to deserve it…………….nothing,football is getting worse which idots vote for them.one player that has not had a mention is phil jagielka,he has been far the best player in the premier league this season.played every game this season for everton,broke into the england team and scored the penalty which put them into the fa cup final,hasnt put a foot wrong all season.plays every match with his heart on his sleeve,gives a 100% week in week out.

  3. Christopher Walker says:

    I thought it was scandalous that Giggsy landed it this season. There have been numerous occasions he has probably deserved it but no part of me can say that he has been the best player in the league this season. Surely Torres/Gerrard/Ronaldo/Lampard/Ferdininand and many more have been better players and therefore would have been more deserving of the award. I agree with Dean and Ethan, Jagielka should have been mentioned and Giggs could have taken home a merit award.

  4. tyduffy says:

    There is no rational defense for him winning the award this season. It would seem that priority number one would be that the player has actually played.

  5. Sebastian Shepard says:

    I agree that Giggs winning is outrageous – I thought Vidic was a shoe-in, but I guess nostalgia really does pay, right? Forget the league, was Giggs even the best Manchester United player this year? Ahead of Vidic, Rooney, Van der Sar, etc? Was he more impressive than Jagielka and Lescott? Gerrard?

    It just doesn’t add up. Everyone loves to hate the media for their selections of “team of the year” but this time, the players have fouled up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>