Steven Cohen Blames Liverpool Fans For Hillsborough Disaster

steven-cohen

Steven Cohen, co-host of the World Soccer Daily radio show, has been at it again.

While the rest of the world last week was paying tribute to the 20th anniversary of the Hillsborough Tragedy, Cohen was complaining on his U.S. radio show that Liverpool fans failed to take responsibility for Hillsborough as well as claiming that if 6,000-8,000 ticketless fans had not shown up, the Hillsborough Disaster would never have happened.

The problem is, he’s wrong. Dead wrong.

Steven Cohen’s Statements About the Hillsborough Disaster

So what did Cohen say that was so wrong? Here are three statements that Cohen made about the Hillsborough Disaster on his Monday, April 13, 2009 episode of World Soccer Daily (note, you can listen to the entire audio clip at the bottom of this post):

“People showing up without ticket, hell bent in getting into somewhere where they shouldn’t be going because they don’t have tickets, is the root cause of [the Hillsborough Disaster].”

“I’m yet to read anybody write in this weekend’s Sunday papers in England, where they’re all doing big commemorations about the 96, and why we should never forget and how it’s changed the game, nobody discusses the 6-8,000 who showed up without tickets and my argument has always been, if those people don’t show up, this never happens.”

“[Hillsborough] is a stadium that week-in week-out, Sheffield Wednesday used without incident.”

World Soccer Daily Playing With Fire

Hosted by Steven Cohen and Kenny Hassan, the Los Angeles-based show is broadcast nationwide each weekday on Sirius Satellite Radio and also available as a daily podcast, which is one of the top 10 most popular sports podcasts on iTunes.

Without a doubt, Cohen is the voice of soccer in America. Since the launch of his network in May 2002, Cohen has succeeded in growing World Soccer Daily into the must-listen show about soccer in the United States. Coupled with his weekly co-host slot on Fox Soccer Channel’s Fox Football Fone-In show, 46-year-old Cohen has built a sizeable following, many of whom are impressionable fans who are relatively new to the sport and hang on his every word.

That’s fine when it’s fun and games, but when Cohen (a Chelsea supporter) spews out misinformation about the Hillsborough Disaster, it’s dangerous. One, because his beliefs about Hillsborough are completely wrong. And two, because by making his beliefs public, he’s giving many newbie soccer fans false information and thereby spreading the wrong information about the cause of the disaster. With such a large audience on radio and television, he has a responsibility to educate listeners on what really happened on April 15, 1989.

The Facts About The Hillsborough Tragedy

To dispel his myths, here are the facts:

“The immediate cause of the gross overcrowding and hence the disaster was the failure, when gate C was opened, to cut off access to the central pens which were already overfull,” — The Interim Taylor Report, paragraph 265.

“Planning apart, however, it should have been clear in the control room where there was a view of the pens and of the crowd at the turnstiles that the tunnel had to be closed. If orders had been given to that effect when gate C was opened, the fans could have been directed to the empty areas of the wings and this disaster could still have been avoided. Failure to give that order was a blunder of the first magnitude,” — The Interim Taylor Report, paragraph 231.

“I have already found that there was not an abnormally large number of fans without tickets on this occasion. With one or two exceptions, the police witnesses themselves did not subscribe to the ‘conspiracy’ theory (of a large number of late-arriving ticketless supporters). I am satisfied that the large concentration at Leppings Lane from 2.30 pm to 2.50 pm did not arrive as a result of any concerted plan. There were, I accept, small groups without tickets who were willing to exploit any adventitious chance of getting into the ground. They, together with the minority who had drunk too much, certainly aggravated the problem faced by the police. But that main problem was simply one of large numbers packed into the small area outside the turnstiles,” The Interim Taylor Report, paragraph 208.

“The police witnesses who most impressed me did not consider the number of ticketless fans to be inordinately large. This accords with two other sources of evidence,” The Interim Taylor Report, paragraph 200.

“Sheffield Wednesday FC’s own admission count system showed the terrace did not exceed its 10,100 capacity (for the Leppings Lane end). As part of their analysis, the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) counted the number of [Liverpool] supporters entering the ground, including those through the turnstiles, through Gate C and even those who climbed over the turnstiles. They gave three admission figures based on their analysis. Their first figure was 9,267, their ‘best estimate’ was 9,734, and their third figure was a ‘maximum estimate’ of 10,124. The HSE report stated it was unlikely that the terrace exceeded 10,124 and that total admissions were approximately equal to the designated capacity of 10,100 people. Taylor surmised there was no substance to the allegation that ticketless fans caused the Disaster,” The Hillsborough Football Disaster: Context And Consequences, page 17. Also watch video evidence of the fans walking through the turnstiles and walking into the tunnel.

The Taylor Report exonerated the Liverpool fans of any culpability. “The main reason for the disaster was the failure of police control,” The Interim Taylor Report, paragraph 278.

Leppings Lane stand was deemed unsuitable in 1981 after 38 Spurs fans suffered crush related injuries. Sheffield Wednesday never carried out the work required. In addition to the 1981 incident, crushes also occurred at Hillsborough in 1987 and 1988. In fact Liverpool played Nottingham Forest in the same stage of the tournament one year prior at the same ground where Liverpool fans were crushed. Liverpool filed an official complaint prior to the 1989 FA-Cup semi final to air their concerns about safety.

Cohen was absolutely wrong on his April 13th show regarding the statements he made about the Hillsborough Tragedy. There were not, as he claimed, 6,000-8,000 ticketless fans. Cohen was emphatically wrong when he claimed that Sheffield Wednesday’s Hillsborough Stadium was used week-in week-out without incident. And the reason none of the English newspapers last Sunday discussed the “6-8,000 who showed up without tickets” is because they didn’t exist. The vast majority of English journalists and pundits know better because they’ve taken time to study the facts rather than to believe the lies told by The Sun and the South Yorkshire Police.

Sure, there were a very small minority of ticketless fans at the ground. And sure, some of the supporters were drunken (as at any football game or sporting event), but the fact of the matter is that Cohen is living in the 80s with the inaccurate statements he’s spewing out.

The Liverpool supporters were a victim of a combination of mistakes by the South Yorkshire Police (for failing to notice that the central pen was overcrowded while the pens to the left and right had room for more spectators, as well as not directing the Liverpool fans who came through the turnstiles away from the central pen), Sheffield Wednesday Football Club (Leppings Lane was ill-suited to admit the 10,100 fans, had too few turnstiles and the club failed to fix those and other issues between 1981-1989 even though they were well aware of them) and the Football Association (for deciding to play the semi-final match at Hillsborough despite previous crushing incidents).

Cohen’s History of Blaming Liverpool Fans For Hillsborough

Cohen’s comments last week aren’t the first time he’s created controversy on American airwaves regarding Hillsborough. On December 5, 2006, he appeared on the Fox Football Fone-In TV show on the U.S. network Fox Soccer Channel and claimed that Liverpool fans were responsible for Hillsborough. He then apologized on the December 12 episode of Fox Football Fone-In, but the damage was clearly already done.

In April, 2007, he again blamed the Liverpool fans for causing the Hillsborough Disaster, this time on his radio show.

He may have apologized on Fox Football Fone-In December 12, 2006, but his views haven’t changed one iota — rendering his 2006 apology virtually meaningless.

Comparisons to Kelvin MacKenzie

Cohen’s misinformed views about what caused the Hillsborough Disaster are similar in context to those of Kelvin MacKenzie.

On April 19, 1989, MacKenzie, the former editor of The Sun newspaper published a sensationalized account of what happened at Hillsborough. MacKenzie’s newspaper that day alleged that ticketless and drunken Liverpool F.C. fans were responsible for the disaster, having supposedly tried to fight their way into the stadium by rushing the turnstiles and attacking policemen outside the ground.

It’s taken 20 years of education in the United Kingdom to try to get the public to understand what was the real cause of the Hillsborough Disaster.

Then in November 2006, just days before Cohen said basically the same thing, MacKenzie again claimed that drunken Liverpool fans caused the disaster.

“I’m still reading the same old stuff about who’s responsible. And it’s the police, it’s the stadium, it’s whatever,” said Cohen in the April 13 radio episode. Cohen then inferred that the Liverpool fans don’t take responsibility for their own actions regarding the events that led up to the Hillsborough Tragedy. Despite his December, 2006 apology, he obviously hasn’t changed his controversial beliefs and he continues to appear on the Fox Football Fone-In show week-in week out.

It’s fitting that on the April 13 episode of the Fox show, it was co-host Nick Webster who paid tribute to the 20th anniversary of the Hillsborough Disaster in a pre-recorded segment at the end of the show. Cohen wasn’t included.

Conclusion

Twenty years after the Hillsborough Disaster, we’re still hearing the same old lies about what happened on that fateful day. It’s time for people to educate themselves about what really happened and stand up against those who fabricate misinformation. For our current generation and future generations, we owe it to them and the 96 who died to tell the real truth of what transpired in Sheffield on April 15, 1989.

To learn more about what really happened at the Hillsborough Disaster, read the Interim Taylor Report, and visit the Hillsborough Football Disaster and Hillsborough Justice Campaign websites.

Also, read the follow-up article to this one entitled Steven Cohen Offers Liverpool Fans No Hillsborough Apology.

UPDATE: On May 18, 2009, Steven Cohen apologized on World Soccer Daily for his unfortunate and inaccurate statements he made about the Hillsborough Disaster.

UPDATE 2: The comments regarding the Steven Cohen controversy have been closed. It’s time to return the discussion to football.

UPDATE 3: Fox Soccer Channel announced on July 29, 2009 that Steven Cohen’s position on Fox Football Fone-In has been filled by Eric Wynalda.

UPDATE 4: Steven Cohen announced on August 21, 2009 that his World Soccer Daily show that day would be his last.

335 Comments

  1. Dome April 20, 2009
  2. Matt April 20, 2009
  3. Dicky April 20, 2009
  4. Kent April 20, 2009
  5. Patrick April 20, 2009
  6. Hannah April 20, 2009
  7. dudleyjason April 20, 2009
  8. peter April 20, 2009
  9. John April 20, 2009
  10. Matt April 20, 2009
  11. bob April 20, 2009
  12. Dave smith April 20, 2009
  13. ChrissMari April 20, 2009
  14. pete breen April 20, 2009
  15. Grant Freer April 20, 2009
  16. fsquid April 20, 2009
  17. Paul April 20, 2009
  18. Matt April 20, 2009
  19. fsquid April 20, 2009
  20. GBH April 20, 2009
  21. Matt April 20, 2009
  22. Colso April 20, 2009
  23. Kartik Krishnaiyer April 20, 2009
  24. kirker April 20, 2009
  25. LS April 20, 2009
  26. fsquid April 20, 2009
  27. Andy Goldberg April 20, 2009
  28. Matt April 20, 2009
  29. lainey April 20, 2009
  30. lainey April 20, 2009
  31. josh April 20, 2009
  32. Kate April 20, 2009
  33. forever LFC April 20, 2009
  34. stephen q April 20, 2009
  35. Colm April 20, 2009
  36. FSJ April 20, 2009
  37. AtlantaPompey April 20, 2009
  38. tony f April 20, 2009
  39. tracey April 20, 2009
  40. jhill April 20, 2009
  41. paul April 20, 2009
  42. Samir S April 20, 2009
  43. todd April 20, 2009
  44. Alan Grant April 20, 2009
  45. John April 20, 2009
  46. Mike Humphrey. April 20, 2009
  47. Seve April 20, 2009
  48. Dicky April 20, 2009
  49. Paul Bestall April 20, 2009
  50. T-CFC April 20, 2009
  51. Jon April 20, 2009
  52. Bishopville Red April 20, 2009
  53. Paul Bestall April 20, 2009
  54. The Liquidator April 20, 2009
  55. Mike Humphrey. April 20, 2009
  56. T-CFC April 20, 2009
  57. Paul Bestall April 20, 2009
  58. Morgan April 20, 2009
  59. Peter Connolly April 20, 2009
  60. Mike Humphrey. April 20, 2009
  61. RedZone April 20, 2009
  62. mike grabania April 20, 2009
  63. Michael Pillay April 20, 2009
  64. SMOOTH April 20, 2009
  65. todd April 20, 2009
  66. V Madhav April 20, 2009
  67. Agnar Juliusson April 20, 2009
  68. mike grabania April 20, 2009
  69. Gaz April 20, 2009
  70. Venez Tiger April 20, 2009
  71. doublepivot April 20, 2009
  72. Bishopville Red April 20, 2009
  73. Phil Kirwin April 20, 2009
  74. Sutebia April 20, 2009
  75. ArthurArseGooner April 20, 2009
  76. Harry April 20, 2009
  77. Red4Ever April 20, 2009
  78. ossie's dream April 21, 2009
  79. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  80. ossie's dream April 21, 2009
  81. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  82. Charles April 21, 2009
  83. ossie's dream April 21, 2009
  84. ossie's dream April 21, 2009
  85. ossie's dream April 21, 2009
  86. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  87. Ben April 21, 2009
  88. Chops Jackson April 21, 2009
  89. fid1892 April 21, 2009
  90. fid1892 April 21, 2009
  91. Target Man April 21, 2009
  92. Matt April 21, 2009
  93. Kirsty April 21, 2009
  94. Mike Humphrey. April 21, 2009
  95. Neil Jenkins April 21, 2009
  96. Matt April 21, 2009
  97. Matt April 21, 2009
  98. andy April 21, 2009
  99. Neil Jenkins April 21, 2009
  100. Mike April 21, 2009
  101. RedJohn April 21, 2009
  102. Mattieboy April 21, 2009
  103. Shanks. April 21, 2009
  104. Mike April 21, 2009
  105. Mike April 21, 2009
  106. JD April 21, 2009
  107. Matt April 21, 2009
  108. Rob Oliver April 21, 2009
  109. Mike April 21, 2009
  110. karim April 21, 2009
  111. Bill Shannon April 21, 2009
  112. Neil Jenkins April 21, 2009
  113. Jonty Trunder April 21, 2009
  114. Joe the Pole April 21, 2009
  115. Macca April 21, 2009
  116. Matt April 21, 2009
  117. Fnarf April 21, 2009
  118. Jerry April 21, 2009
  119. jason April 21, 2009
  120. Paul Bestall April 21, 2009
  121. Paul April 21, 2009
  122. Tampa Kopite April 21, 2009
  123. Chops April 21, 2009
  124. rednow.red4ever April 21, 2009
  125. Teabag April 21, 2009
  126. Charmer April 21, 2009
  127. Carl April 21, 2009
  128. jim April 21, 2009
  129. ArthurArseGooner April 21, 2009
  130. esw April 21, 2009
  131. Dave April 22, 2009
  132. wayne April 22, 2009
  133. Mad Alex April 22, 2009
  134. Mark April 22, 2009
  135. Frank Vincent April 22, 2009
  136. celticmark April 22, 2009
  137. Paul S April 22, 2009
  138. Jerry April 22, 2009
  139. Youallgotplayed April 22, 2009
  140. Youallgotplayed April 22, 2009
  141. Jerry April 22, 2009
  142. David April 22, 2009
  143. Roger Hunt April 22, 2009
  144. Johnny Red April 22, 2009
  145. mike April 22, 2009
  146. Seve April 22, 2009
  147. ArthurArseGooner April 22, 2009
  148. LEKS April 23, 2009
  149. shanks April 23, 2009
  150. celticmark April 23, 2009
  151. Matt April 23, 2009
  152. Malcolm April 23, 2009
  153. Paul S April 23, 2009
  154. Frank Vincent April 24, 2009
  155. Jeremy April 24, 2009
  156. Jeremy April 24, 2009
  157. Jeremy April 24, 2009
  158. Paul S April 24, 2009
  159. Joe April 24, 2009
  160. Bobby Paisley April 24, 2009
  161. Joe April 24, 2009
  162. Eric April 24, 2009
  163. Jeff April 24, 2009
  164. joe April 25, 2009
  165. Bobby Paisley April 25, 2009
  166. Scott April 25, 2009
  167. Dave April 25, 2009
  168. Jacko April 25, 2009
  169. Dave April 25, 2009
  170. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  171. Dave April 25, 2009
  172. Joe April 25, 2009
  173. Joe April 25, 2009
  174. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  175. RaiderRich2001 April 25, 2009
  176. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  177. michael April 25, 2009
  178. Pakapala April 25, 2009
  179. pjgalactica April 25, 2009
  180. Jaime April 25, 2009
  181. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  182. Joe April 25, 2009
  183. Joe April 25, 2009
  184. Jaime April 25, 2009
  185. Jaime April 25, 2009
  186. Joe April 25, 2009
  187. Jaime April 25, 2009
  188. Joe April 25, 2009
  189. Jaime April 25, 2009
  190. Jaime April 25, 2009
  191. Joe April 25, 2009
  192. Jaime April 25, 2009
  193. EcuaAlexa April 25, 2009
  194. EcuaAlexa April 25, 2009
  195. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  196. Jaime April 25, 2009
  197. The Gaffer April 25, 2009
  198. Jaime April 25, 2009
  199. joe April 26, 2009
  200. Jaime April 26, 2009
  201. Jimmy James April 26, 2009
  202. Paul S April 26, 2009
  203. joe April 26, 2009
  204. celticmark April 27, 2009
  205. Gaz April 27, 2009
  206. niceltic April 28, 2009
  207. LA Red April 29, 2009
  208. Paul Bestall April 29, 2009
  209. Kate April 30, 2009
  210. Kate April 30, 2009
  211. Matt April 30, 2009
  212. Jaime April 30, 2009
  213. Joe April 30, 2009
  214. Matt May 1, 2009
  215. Philip May 2, 2009
  216. Matt May 2, 2009
  217. Philip May 3, 2009
  218. terry May 3, 2009
  219. Philip May 3, 2009
  220. Matt May 4, 2009
  221. Joe May 4, 2009
  222. Matt May 4, 2009
  223. Charles May 4, 2009
  224. Jon May 4, 2009
  225. Joe May 4, 2009
  226. Kevin Humphreys May 5, 2009
  227. celticmark May 5, 2009
  228. Jordan May 5, 2009
  229. NICELTIC May 5, 2009
  230. Joe May 5, 2009
  231. Jon May 5, 2009
  232. Joe May 5, 2009
  233. Joe May 5, 2009
  234. Shakira May 5, 2009
  235. Philip May 7, 2009
  236. Joe May 7, 2009
  237. John May 7, 2009
  238. Jeremy May 7, 2009
  239. Jeremy May 7, 2009
  240. Matt May 7, 2009
  241. Joe May 7, 2009
  242. Philip May 7, 2009
  243. Philip May 7, 2009
  244. Jeremy May 8, 2009
  245. Matt May 8, 2009
  246. Matt May 8, 2009
  247. Philip May 8, 2009
  248. Joe May 8, 2009
  249. Neutral May 9, 2009
  250. Philip May 10, 2009
  251. liamo May 10, 2009
  252. Shakira May 10, 2009
  253. Joe May 10, 2009
  254. Philip May 10, 2009
  255. Philip May 10, 2009
  256. Shakira May 10, 2009
  257. Mark May 11, 2009
  258. Mark May 11, 2009
  259. Mark May 11, 2009
  260. Joe May 11, 2009
  261. Joe May 12, 2009
  262. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  263. RaiderRich May 12, 2009
  264. Jaime May 12, 2009
  265. Jaime May 12, 2009
  266. dutch May 13, 2009
  267. Mark May 13, 2009
  268. Johnny Red May 13, 2009
  269. Martin May 14, 2009
  270. The Gaffer May 14, 2009
  271. liamo May 14, 2009
  272. Rich May 15, 2009
  273. Derek May 15, 2009
  274. Fuuzball May 15, 2009
  275. stan mac May 16, 2009
  276. liamo May 16, 2009
  277. paddy coughlan May 17, 2009
  278. paddy coughlan May 17, 2009
  279. Philip May 17, 2009
  280. Mark May 17, 2009
  281. Daveywavey May 17, 2009
  282. Mark May 17, 2009
  283. Mark May 17, 2009
  284. Mark May 17, 2009
  285. Bob May 17, 2009
  286. Joe May 17, 2009
  287. Joe May 17, 2009
  288. The Gaffer May 17, 2009
  289. Robbo May 17, 2009
  290. Daveywavey May 17, 2009
  291. YANK GO HOME May 17, 2009
  292. paddy coughlan May 17, 2009
  293. Joe May 17, 2009
  294. The chosen one May 17, 2009
  295. Jaime May 17, 2009
  296. Sean Atkinson May 17, 2009
  297. Mark May 17, 2009
  298. Mark May 17, 2009
  299. Philip May 17, 2009
  300. Mark May 17, 2009
  301. Frank May 18, 2009
  302. Rich May 18, 2009
  303. The Gaffer May 18, 2009
  304. Frank May 18, 2009
  305. Sean Atkinson May 18, 2009
  306. Rick Rottman May 18, 2009
  307. Sean Atkinson May 18, 2009
  308. The Gaffer May 18, 2009
  309. Sean Atkinson May 18, 2009
  310. Rick Rottman May 18, 2009
  311. tank99 May 18, 2009
  312. Gaz May 18, 2009
  313. Rich May 18, 2009
  314. Shakira May 18, 2009
  315. Joe May 18, 2009
  316. evertonian_rob May 18, 2009
  317. Seve May 18, 2009
  318. Philip May 18, 2009
  319. Mike Sheeley May 18, 2009
  320. Joe May 18, 2009
  321. NikkiMc May 18, 2009
  322. Shakira May 18, 2009
  323. Paul Bestall May 18, 2009
  324. Joe May 18, 2009
  325. Shakira May 18, 2009
  326. Mark May 19, 2009
  327. Mark May 19, 2009
  328. Philip May 19, 2009
  329. Joe May 19, 2009
  330. Mark May 19, 2009
  331. phil May 19, 2009
  332. NikkiMc May 19, 2009
  333. The Gaffer May 19, 2009