Promotion / Relegation American Style

portland-timbers-logoseattle-logo

There has been a lot of discussion among fans of the beautiful game in the U.S. about promotion and relegation.  On this site, Daniel Feuerstein supported the idea down the road.   One of his main points was that, once MLS and USL clubs have their own stadiums … a lot of the obstacles to this format, would then work themselves out.

I agree that if North American soccer were to make this switch, it would take some time and that teams having their own facilities would be a giant step in the right direction.   However, another possibility has begun to formulate.

Perhaps, promotion / relegation might find a beginning in this part of the world, a different way.  Maybe, in light of the essential “promotion” of Seattle and Portland to MLS franchises (and the flirtation with FC Barcelona Miami), the U.S. based leagues will start with their own model.  USL could be a breeding ground for new MLS sides.

For starters, this issue, is an extremely divisive one.  It seems that there are just as many advocates of pro / rel, as there are those who like the conference style / playoff setup.  I also want to point out that, playoffs and pro / rel could also work together.  Personally, I think that pro / rel wouldn’t be a bad idea, but definitely well down the road.  However, I don’t want to see the playoff system thrown out the window, as it is culturally relevant to American sports.  Not to mention, it’s nice to see different leagues around the world take on their own identity and style in soccer, while still keeping unity with the beautiful game, around the globe.

For pro / rel to ever work … MLS and USL would have to develop a better relationship, of course.  And this cooperation could start with a franchise building partnership. Cross – marketing, would benefit both leagues.   New teams to the North American system, could start off in USL.  There, these clubs could get their bearings straight, learn the ins and outs of the American game.  Then, once they have set up shop and proven their ability to thrive as a franchise, make the jump to the top tier.

Granted, MLS would definitely have to compensate the USL financially, as the best teams would be leaving after establishing themselves in the second tier.  But, it would be a good way to test markets and organizations, before adding them to the top level.  Though the USL – 1 product doesn’t appear to be so different in quality than MLS, solid teams are already jumping ship.

It would be a start anyways, as we are very far away from having soccer – specific, club – owned facilities for all teams.    And it would be a good opportunity for foreign investors, such as the Stoke City based ownership group, of the Austin Aztex.   This type of arrangement, would allow them to try their hand in the American game, before completely committing their finances.

In the end, I think soccer has the best chance in succeeding in this country, through solidarity.   So here’s hoping, one way or the other, to some kind of kinship among all domestic brands, to build the strong foundation we need.

55 Comments

  1. FootyFan April 13, 2009
  2. Chris Riordan April 13, 2009
  3. Jason Davis April 14, 2009
  4. Jason Davis April 14, 2009
  5. Oscar Baechler April 14, 2009
  6. Emlyn April 14, 2009
  7. L.E. Eisenmenger April 14, 2009
  8. dude April 14, 2009
  9. Tom April 14, 2009
  10. Steve April 16, 2009
  11. Ted Westervelt May 7, 2009
  12. Mike May 7, 2009
  13. Theodore May 12, 2009
  14. Lance May 19, 2009
  15. dave b July 25, 2009
  16. Bastien November 5, 2009
  17. Roger December 18, 2009
    • Lars December 18, 2009
    • DCUDiplomat96 April 23, 2010
  18. Roger May 29, 2010
  19. ExtraMedium July 14, 2010
    • bradjmoore48 July 14, 2010
    • Roger July 14, 2010
      • ExtraMedium July 24, 2010
        • Roger July 24, 2010
          • Daniel Feuerstein July 24, 2010
  20. soccerreform.us July 15, 2010
  21. ExtraMedium July 24, 2010
    • ExtraMedium July 24, 2010
      • Daniel Feuerstein July 24, 2010
        • Roger July 24, 2010
          • Daniel Feuerstein July 24, 2010
        • Roger July 24, 2010
          • Daniel Feuerstein July 25, 2010
  22. americanizingsoccer.com July 24, 2010
    • Charles July 25, 2010
  23. Roger July 24, 2010
    • Daniel Feuerstein July 25, 2010
      • Charles July 25, 2010
  24. Roger July 25, 2010
    • Charles July 25, 2010
    • Daniel Feuerstein July 25, 2010
      • Roger July 25, 2010
  25. Roger July 25, 2010
    • Charles July 25, 2010
      • soccerreform.us July 26, 2010
      • Poker Rakeback July 26, 2010
    • soccerrefom.us July 26, 2010
  26. americanizingsoccer.com July 26, 2010
    • Charles July 26, 2010
  27. DCUDiplomat96 July 26, 2010
  28. Roger July 26, 2010
    • Charles July 26, 2010
  29. Charles July 26, 2010
  30. federico January 13, 2011

Leave a Reply