Sign up for the free World Soccer Talk newsletter to find out how you can win 2 free tickets to Copa America »


Superliga 2008: Some Thoughts

552d3cf78919de6c1b71d5f31ccd8faa300 Superliga 2008: Some Thoughts

Photo by Thomas Shea from Superliga 2008 website

As we enter the knock out stages of Superliga 2008 let me state that while the intensity level was as high for these matches last year the football has been much better this year. No offense to anybody but an LA Galaxy side featuring Alan Gordon and Edson Buddle as starting forwards and an injured David Beckham would not have advanced to the knock out stages of this year’s tournament. That having been said MLS has a lot to live up to in the performance of the Galaxy in last year’s knock out stages. David Beckham’s free kick to sink DC United was a thing of beauty, and Chris Klein’s stoppage time bicycle kick was the type of magic that MLS sides have rarely if ever produced in a critical moment of a match of international significance. Had the Galaxy won the pk shootout that moment would have been etched in stone as one of the greatest in the history of Major League Soccer. I still a year later feel a tinge of sadness that the Galaxy did not win that match. That night they were a credit to MLS and to the game of football even if too often last year they were simply a traveling circus without an effective ring leader.

Alas, the Galaxy did not win the tournament the year FMF sides used the competition as a pre-season warmup. Now the event is being taken seriously, and every participating side came to play, and came to win. Atlante was humbled 4-0 by the Houston Dynamo in the first match but manager Guadalupe Cruz told Telefutura after the match that his side psychologically had been beaten down and he wouldn’t let that happen again. The match which was the first decided by more than one goal in Superliga history actually provided the impetus for the Cancun based side to play some of the best football of the tournament in their next two matches sweeping away DC United and Guadalajara.

For the second consecutive year , CD Guadalajara (Chivas) needed only a draw against a fellow FMF side in the final group match to advance to the knock out stage of the Superliga, and for the second consecutive year Chivas got beat and saw their opponent celebrate advancement. But this year Chivas looked more willing to take chances against Atlante than they did last year against Pachuca and tried to make a game of it. But the reality was Atlante was just too good, and Chivas’ backline suspect. When you consider that Guadalajara got some great breaks like facing Houston with Franco Carracio as the main scoring threat two days before he was waived while Dwayne DeRosario severed a suspension and having three DC United shots hit the post in their victory at RFK Stadium, any whining about not going through to the semifinals despite having a superior goal difference than Atlante should be spared here. Atlante showed the character that allowed them to win the fall Mexican Apertura in their first competition since picking up and leaving Mexico City for Cancun by crushing Chivas in the winner take all match.

In addition, Johnny Magallon who is Mexico’s starting central defender surely did not impress Sven Goran Eriksson who has taken in many Superliga matches with his poor display of positioning and defending. Eriksson who took in many of the matches in person during this competition had to be impressed however with Edgar Castillio and Fernando Arce of Santos Laguna, who could feel hard done by only achieving a draw in a tournament where they seemed to lack the type of luck that Guadalajara received.

However when it comes down to it Pachuca is still the team to beat in these competitions. An indifferent Clausura season in Mexico has not prevented the defending champions of this event from coming to the USA and playing some outstanding football. Despite my pre tournament concerns about the age of Pachuca’s midfield, they have not only held up thus far but essentially controlled the bulk of the two of the teams three Superliga matches. They next face a familiar foe: Houston

We’ve seen Pachuca take care of Houston on two previous occasions at this stage of a tournament including last year’s Superliga. While Houston will have revenge on their mind and will no doubt play lights out to win the semifinals would it be smart to actually pick against Pachuca at this stage against an opponent who completely lacks confidence when facing the likes of Christian Gimenez, Gabriel Cabbalero and others? Not having Stuart Holden, the leading goal scorer in Superliga 2008 who is currently with US Olympic Team preparing to face the world in Beijing is not going to help the Dynamo’s cause.

New England has been outstanding in this tournament. Mexican teams are getting a dose of what it’s like to face a disciplined, tactical European side when facing Steve Nicol’s team which features Shalrie Joseph and Steve Ralston in the midfield. In addition, the speed of Nyassi, Mansallay and Dube gave both Santos Laguna and Pachuca fits. The Revs use patient buildup instead of the frantic going forward without rhyme or reason style many Mexican sides play to break down their opponent and achieve results. Atlante has been outstanding in their last two matches but again having watched New England in this tournament who’d bet against them?

Chivas USA’s performance was a credit to their manager Preki and to the determination of Ante Razov who even at 34 is probably the best striking option for the US National Team. Razov scored in all three Superliga matches and has in fact scored a goal in six consecutive competitive matches for the Goats. However, no other Chivas player has scored during that stretch and in this tournament Sacha Kljestan, another US Olympian was frustrating. He mixed moments of absolute brilliance with moments of stupidity while his team mate Pablo Nagumura, normally steady seemed reckless in this tournament. Chivas was good, but not good enough in a tough group.

That leads us to the one team that hasn’t been discussed in this post to this point. The one team that doesn’t deserve to be discussed, DC United. The performance of United who entered the tournament never having once lost a match to an FMF side at RFK Stadium and three days later had two losses to FMF sides defies all explanation and logic. Sure Marcello Gallardo and Gonzalo Peralta were hurt and Tom Soehn seemed to aggravate Santino Quaranta’s injury by playing him when the team was desperate for a result against Atlante. But the red and black have historically always had a standard in these competitions you could count on regardless of who dawned the jersey. But this week was certainly forgettable in the proud history of DC United, and was culminated by a smashing defeat at the hands of Houston in front of one of the smallest weekend RFK Stadium crowds I can recall going back to 1996. DC was in a word embarrassed and whether or not you take Superliga seriously, their effort didn’t bring any credit to themselves or to MLS.

The TV coverage for these matches on Telefutura has been outstanding. Like last year, the network is utilizing a two man booth and sideline reporter at the matches as well as a studio host. This pales in comparison to the typical Telefutura MLS broadcast that is done at the low end with commentators calling the matches of a TV monitor, and not providing much in the way of pre game or post game analysis.

Superliga is a big event when you base it on how Telefutura covers it compared to its weekly MLS or FMF matches. Only in the Mexican playoffs do their production quality or overall game packaging approach that of Superliga. Then to add the HD component which Telefutura has offered for these matches in selected metropolitan areas (including Miami where I reside) and Superliga 2008 has been slam dunk event for the viewer. Let’s hope this continues in the knock out stages.

This entry was posted in Leagues: Major League Soccer, Superliga. Bookmark the permalink.

About Kartik Krishnaiyer

A lifelong lover of soccer, the beautiful game, he served from January 2010 until May 2013 as the Director of Communications and Public Relations for the North American Soccer League (NASL). Raised on the Fort Lauderdale Strikers of the old NASL, Krishnaiyer previously hosted the American Soccer Show on the Champions Soccer Radio Network, the Major League Soccer Talk podcast and the EPL Talk Podcast. His soccer writing has been featured by several media outlets including The Guardian and The Telegraph. He is the author of the book Blue With Envy about Manchester City FC.
View all posts by Kartik Krishnaiyer →

9 Responses to Superliga 2008: Some Thoughts

  1. LJ says:

    outstanding piece. i’ve been impressed with the event just as much as you have thus far.

  2. Larry says:

    Any predictions for the next stage or are you out of the picks business?

  3. Jack in the Box says:

    Wow, we had to get some sort of “Galaxy is great” reference in a post discussing Superliga 2008.

    Man the rest of the post is nice but lay off the Galaxy kool aid for a while.

  4. Chop says:

    Hopefully we can talk about this on Thursday Kartik, but I disagree slightly with your opinion of United.

    The effort, at least in the first two matches, was there. The execution was not. They were terrible defensively the entire tournament (no excusing that) but they did pour forward in a genuine attempt to cut into defecits, which they were facing for the majority of their 3 matches.

    At the end of the day, United were indeed disappointing, but trust me when I say this, no one (and that includes fans, players and coaches) is shedding any tears over their early departure.

    They have more important things to attend to.

    Keep up the good work.

  5. Torres says:

    Great Tournament.

    Chivas has been eliminated!

    Atlante is a threat.

    Same for Houston.

    i thinks we will see them face off again.

  6. Mark says:

    It’s been a great tournament thus far and here’s hoping the semifinals are not a let down!

  7. laws says:

    I think Houston is going to really be hurting without Holden. Pachuca knows how to beat them and will thrash them.

    Atlante is playing too well right now and will beat New England. We’re going to have an all FMF final boys.

  8. JRT says:

    DC was an embarrassment and I have to assume Soehn will be gone soon.

  9. bsumm1 says:

    Really comprehensive stuff there. Being a devoted Revs fan, I am thrilled to see our boys going up against real quality Mexican sides. The Santos and Pachuca games were tough and in both games victory was never assured. But in the end, winning through grit and determination is just as impressive as winning through style and finesse. While I have been impressed with Houston’s performances, I feel the Revs have pulled through the group stages looking just as strong and just as likely, but have done so under perhaps more difficult circumstances. Injuries and national team duty are slowly taking their toll on the Revs, and yet we just keep on winning. As you mentioned Kartik, the contributions of the African trio has been a huge factor by injecting a ton of pace, guile, and gusto, but so many other players are stepping up, Amaechi Igwe is a player who comes to mind right away. His inclusion into a four man back line as an attack-minded left back, has been a very important cog in Steve and Pauls’ machine. Pat Phelan has been dogged in the center of the park, and unfortunately his eagerness landed him with a nasty concussion, but nevertheless he has been a promising addition to an already promising young side. His ginger twin Jeff Larentowicz has been nothing short of excellent all season, and paired with big Joseph I truly see them as the most dominating midfield duo in MLS. Even local boy Chris Tierny has been filling the holes for Steve and Paul when needed and looking more confident every game. Coming from a fan of the club this may all sound biased, and it probably is, but I feel Kartik’s praise for the Revs is not misplaced. They may not win Superliga necessarily, but without a doubt they have been the best MLS side in the tournament this year.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>