FRI, 2:30PM ET
MAR
NAN
FRI, 2:30PM ET
SOC
ELC
FRI, 2:30PM ET
FRE
STU
SAT, 7:45AM ET
WBA
ARS
SAT, 10AM ET
MUFC
HULL
SAT, 10AM ET
SWA
CRY

Where Does MLS Rate Worldwide?

Major League Soccer seems like a misunderstood step child of World Football. As a fairly young league by international standards, its growth has been remarkable and the fact that the United States has been to five consecutive World Cups appears lost on some critics of the league. One of these critics even referred to MLS as a “third tier” league while labeling the Championship, the second division in England which boasts far fewer regular national team players per team than MLS as a “second tier” league. The critic claimed that the rating system was based on the top teams in the league not on the entire league, which with salary cap based leagues like MLS and the Aussie A-League is an easy way to put them at the bottom of any rating system.

This particular critic is one of several here in the United States that seem to want to ridicule anything the league does. These critics often compare MLS in every facet to Northern European leagues, particularly the Premiership forgetting that geography, culture, and climate make MLS very unique.

Applying a distinctly Northern European standard to rating MLS is unfair and flat out wrong. Here’s why:

1-Geography

In England teams often times take a one or two hour coach ride to next match. In Major League Soccer Chivas USA for example probably has to take a six flight flying in coach class to Boston to board a bus to take an hour drive to Foxboro. Plane travel itself is more consuming physically than ground travel, not to mention to change of time zones.

2- Climate

MLS critics like to make a big deal about when MLS’ season takes place. Now personally I’d love to see the league on the same August to May calender that the top European leagues are on. However, the harsh climate in the northern US and Canada makes this impossible. It is no coincidence that since MLS began play, leagues similar climates such as Scandinavia and Ireland have moved their calender more in line with MLS.

3- Culture

The style of Major League Soccer has become more and more distinctly Latin than it was let’s say in the 1996 to 2000 time period when it had more of a Northern European flavor. You can argue which style of play is better or more attractive. However, applying a strictly Northern European standard to judging MLS quality and attractiveness is wrong. It is in fact something I have personally been guilty of in the past because I watched the Premier League and Bundesliga (or at least the highlight shows we received in the US) before MLS existed.

Part of me believes comparing leagues is foolhardy and something just meant to provoke controversy by certain individuals. It seems that despite the efforts of some to ridicule the product in MLS, many around the globe and even in the United Kingdom enjoy watching the league. Certainly no argument can be made that MLS is on par with the top divisions in England, Spain, Italy and Germany. However, a legitimate argument could be made that MLS as a whole (again not the top teams, as in a salary cap based league parity rules) is nearly as good as several other European top divisions and is far superior to the second division (the Championship) in England. Those who watch very little football from outside of England and admit fast forwarding through many of the English games themselves aren’t in a credible position to judge and rate leagues from around the world.

This entry was posted in Leagues: Major League Soccer, Major League Soccer. Bookmark the permalink.

About Kartik Krishnaiyer

A lifelong lover of soccer, the beautiful game, he served from January 2010 until May 2013 as the Director of Communications and Public Relations for the North American Soccer League (NASL). Raised on the Fort Lauderdale Strikers of the old NASL, Krishnaiyer previously hosted the American Soccer Show on the Champions Soccer Radio Network, the Major League Soccer Talk podcast and the EPL Talk Podcast. His soccer writing has been featured by several media outlets including The Guardian and The Telegraph. He is the author of the book Blue With Envy about Manchester City FC.
View all posts by Kartik Krishnaiyer →

4 Responses to Where Does MLS Rate Worldwide?

  1. Louis says:

    Your line of thinking is certainly interesting. I don’t think MLS could ever compare to the top four or five leagues in the world but as you point out after that it’s tough to judge because of the salary cap. Do I think DC United or Chivas USA could win the French league or the Dutch league? No. Would they get a Champions League or UEFA Cup spot from those leagues? Likely not. At the same time I follow your logic about the salary cap. Take the Galaxy for instance who finished 11th in a 13 team league. I don’t think they’d get relegated in France or Holland.

    These critics you refer to all reside on a single TV network and radio show. Do you really feel this sort of nonsense coming from those types is necessary to write about? Honestly, I wouldn’t give them the time of day. I mean I love English Football but if you watch the Championship with all of its bad giveaways, defensive lapses and goalkeeping errors as much as I try to, you’d realize MLS as a whole is much much better.

    You also failed to mention that MLS is slower because it is played in oppressive summer heat. That is another thing that the radio host I believe you are referencing seems to have forgotten.

    Well written post but again, I’m not sure you want to give the person I believe you are criticizing a platform for his wrongheaded views.

  2. Harvey says:

    Good read, and your points are spot on at least from an American perspective.

  3. eplnfl says:

    I do not know if the comparison can help anyone at this time. The growth of the MLS has been remarkable and it has reached such a level that it threatens to take major players away for the European market that have some value.

    I think the fan and league focus should be on setting a plan to at least be equal to a second tier European league by 2012. This should be a practical goal and one that is necessary for increased fan support. The key here as all else is increased tv revenue.

  4. Mark says:

    This debate is dominated by two extremes. The Anglosnobs who think everything rises and sets with the England National Team and the Premier League and American Soccer snobs who contatsntly over rate the quality of our league and our players. Both sides are dead wrong.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>